Hearing loss can be a challenging experience, impacting communication and overall quality of life. Hearing aids offer a significant solution, amplifying sounds and improving auditory perception. However, with a wide array of hearing aid types, styles, and features available, choosing the right one can feel overwhelming. This guide aims to Compare Hearing Aids, providing you with the information needed to make an informed decision and find the best hearing aid to suit your individual needs and preferences.
Understanding Hearing Aids: How They Work
Before diving into comparisons, it’s essential to understand the basic functionality of a hearing aid. Despite variations in style and technology, all hearing aids operate on the same core principles.
Hearing aids consist of several key components working in concert:
- Microphone: This component captures sound waves from your environment, acting as the “ear” of the device.
- Amplifier: The amplifier is the heart of the hearing aid, increasing the intensity of the sound signal.
- Speaker (Receiver): The speaker delivers the amplified sound directly into your ear canal, allowing you to hear it.
- Battery: Hearing aids are powered by batteries, either traditional disposable batteries or rechargeable options.
- Digital Processor: Modern hearing aids utilize sophisticated digital processors. These chips convert sound into digital code, analyze it based on your specific hearing loss profile and listening environment, and then fine-tune the amplification.
Essentially, hearing aids capture, process, and amplify sound to compensate for hearing loss, making sounds more audible and improving communication.
Comparing Hearing Aid Styles: Finding the Right Fit for Your Lifestyle and Hearing Needs
One of the first steps in choosing a hearing aid is to consider the different styles available. Each style offers unique advantages and disadvantages in terms of size, visibility, features, and suitability for different types of hearing loss.
Here’s a comparison of common hearing aid styles:
Completely In the Canal (CIC) & Mini CIC
- Description: These are the smallest and least visible hearing aids, fitting entirely within the ear canal.
- Pros:
- Most discreet option.
- Less likely to pick up wind noise due to ear canal placement.
- Cons:
- Small size limits battery life and features.
- Can be difficult to handle due to size, especially for those with dexterity issues.
- Susceptible to earwax blockage.
- May lack features like volume control or directional microphones.
- Best for: Mild to moderate hearing loss in adults prioritizing discretion.
In the Canal (ITC)
- Description: Custom-molded to fit partially in the ear canal, slightly larger than CIC.
- Pros:
- More discreet than larger styles.
- Can accommodate more features than CIC, though adjustments may still be difficult due to size.
- Cons:
- Susceptible to earwax blockage.
- Small size can still make handling challenging for some.
- Best for: Mild to moderate hearing loss in adults seeking a balance between discretion and features.
In the Ear (ITE)
- Description: Custom-made to fit within the outer ear bowl (concha). Available in full shell (fills most of the concha) and half shell (fills only the lower part).
- Pros:
- Larger size allows for more features like volume control and directional microphones.
- Easier to handle than smaller styles.
- Longer battery life due to larger battery size, including rechargeable options.
- Cons:
- More visible than smaller in-the-canal styles.
- May pick up more wind noise.
- Susceptible to earwax blockage.
- Best for: Mild to severe hearing loss, those who prioritize ease of handling and features, and are less concerned about visibility.
Behind the Ear (BTE)
- Description: Hooks over the top of the ear and rests behind the ear. A tube connects the hearing aid to a custom earmold that fits in the ear canal.
- Pros:
- Suitable for all ages and most types of hearing loss, from mild to profound.
- Traditionally the most powerful style, capable of greater amplification.
- Can accommodate a wide range of features, including directional microphones.
- Available with rechargeable batteries.
- Cons:
- Traditionally the largest and most visible style, although mini-BTE designs are more discreet.
- May pick up more wind noise than in-the-ear styles.
- Best for: All types and degrees of hearing loss, especially those needing significant amplification or advanced features.
Receiver In Canal (RIC) & Receiver In Ear (RITE)
- Description: Similar to BTE, but the speaker (receiver) is placed directly in the ear canal or ear, connected to the behind-the-ear component by a thin wire instead of tubing.
- Pros:
- More discreet than traditional BTEs as the behind-the-ear portion is smaller.
- Directional microphones.
- Manual control options.
- May be available with rechargeable batteries.
- Cons:
- Susceptible to earwax blockage in the receiver.
- Best for: Most types of hearing loss, those seeking a balance of discretion and features, and potentially better sound quality due to receiver placement in the ear canal.
Open Fit
- Description: A variation of BTE or RIC/RITE, using a thin tube or open dome in the ear canal, leaving the canal mostly open.
- Pros:
- Allows low-frequency sounds to enter the ear naturally, while amplifying high-frequency sounds.
- Often makes the wearer’s own voice sound more natural compared to completely occluding styles.
- Cons:
- Can be visible.
- May be more difficult to insert due to the non-custom dome.
- Best for: Individuals with good low-frequency hearing and mild to moderate high-frequency hearing loss.
Comparing Hearing Aid Features: Enhancing Your Listening Experience
Beyond style, hearing aids offer a range of features designed to improve hearing in various situations and enhance user convenience. When comparing hearing aids, consider which of these features are most important to your lifestyle and listening needs.
- Noise Reduction: Essential for comfortable listening in noisy environments. Most hearing aids offer some level of noise reduction, with varying degrees of sophistication. Advanced noise reduction systems can significantly improve speech clarity in background noise.
- Directional Microphones: These microphones focus on sounds coming from in front of the wearer while reducing sounds from the sides and behind. This feature is crucial for improving speech understanding in noisy settings like restaurants or social gatherings. Some hearing aids offer adaptive directional microphones that automatically adjust their focus based on the sound environment.
- Rechargeable Batteries: Eliminate the need for frequent battery changes, offering convenience and potentially cost savings over time. Ideal for users with dexterity issues or those who prefer an environmentally friendly option.
- Telecoils (T-coils): Allow hearing aid users to connect directly to telecoil-compatible telephones and public address systems (like those in theaters or places of worship). T-coils pick up electromagnetic signals, reducing background noise and improving clarity in these situations.
- Wireless Connectivity (Bluetooth): Increasingly common, Bluetooth connectivity allows hearing aids to connect wirelessly to smartphones, tablets, TVs, and other devices. This enables direct streaming of phone calls, music, and other audio directly to the hearing aids, offering hands-free communication and personalized audio experiences.
- Remote Controls & Smartphone Apps: Provide discreet and convenient control over hearing aid settings like volume, program changes, and other features. Smartphone apps often offer even more advanced control and customization options.
- Direct Audio Input: Allows wired connection to external audio sources like TVs or computers for direct audio streaming, useful in specific listening situations.
- Variable Programming: Allows audiologists to program multiple settings for different listening environments (e.g., quiet, noisy, music). Users can switch between programs to optimize hearing in various situations.
- Synchronization: For those wearing two hearing aids, synchronization ensures that adjustments made to one aid (volume, program changes) are automatically mirrored in the other, simplifying control and ensuring balanced hearing.
Before You Buy: Making an Informed Decision
Choosing the right hearing aid is a significant decision that should involve careful consideration and professional guidance. Here are key steps to take before making a purchase:
- Comprehensive Hearing Test: Consult an audiologist for a thorough hearing evaluation. This test will determine the type and degree of your hearing loss, which is crucial for selecting appropriate hearing aids.
- Medical Check-up: See your doctor to rule out any treatable medical conditions that may be contributing to your hearing loss, such as earwax buildup or infection.
- Consult a Reputable Audiologist: Seek a referral to a qualified and experienced audiologist. They will guide you through the selection process, recommend suitable hearing aid styles and features based on your hearing test results, lifestyle, and budget, and properly fit and program your chosen devices.
- Trial Period: Inquire about trial periods. It takes time to adjust to hearing aids, and a trial period allows you to experience the devices in your daily life and ensure they meet your needs. Understand the trial terms, including costs, refund policies, and what portion of the trial fee can be applied to the final purchase.
- Future Hearing Needs: Discuss potential future hearing loss progression with your audiologist. Choose hearing aids with sufficient amplification range to accommodate potential changes in your hearing over time. Hearing aids typically last around five years, but considering future needs ensures your investment remains beneficial.
- Warranty: Ensure the hearing aids come with a comprehensive warranty covering parts and labor for a reasonable period. Some warranties may also include professional services like office visits for adjustments.
- Be Realistic About Expectations: Hearing aids improve hearing, but they do not restore normal hearing. Be wary of exaggerated claims about eliminating all background noise or restoring perfect hearing. Focus on realistic improvements in communication and sound awareness.
- Budget and Costs: Hearing aid costs vary widely depending on style, features, and technology level. Discuss your budget with your audiologist and understand the total cost, including professional fees, accessories, and potential future maintenance.
- Explore Funding Options: Check if your private health insurance policy covers any portion of hearing aid costs. Medicare typically does not cover hearing aids for adults, but some private Medicare Advantage plans may offer hearing aid benefits. Medicaid coverage for hearing aids varies by state. Veterans may be eligible for hearing aids through the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA).
Getting Used to Your Hearing Aids: Patience and Persistence
Adjusting to hearing aids takes time and patience. It’s a process of retraining your brain to process amplified sounds.
- Hearing Improvement, Not Restoration: Remember that hearing aids amplify sounds but won’t completely restore normal hearing. Focus on the improvement in your ability to hear soft sounds and communicate more effectively.
- Gradual Acclimation: Wear your hearing aids consistently and gradually increase wear time each day. This allows your brain to adapt to the amplified sounds and new auditory information.
- Practice in Different Environments: Experiment with your hearing aids in various listening situations – quiet rooms, noisy environments, outdoors, etc. This helps you understand how your hearing aids perform in different settings and identify areas where adjustments may be needed.
- Seek Support and Stay Positive: Connect with family and friends for support during the adjustment period. Consider joining a hearing loss support group to share experiences and learn from others. Positive attitude and persistence are key to successful hearing aid use.
- Follow-up Appointments: Attend all scheduled follow-up appointments with your audiologist. These appointments are crucial for fine-tuning your hearing aid programming, addressing any concerns, and ensuring optimal performance and comfort.
Choosing the right hearing aid involves comparing styles, features, considering your individual needs and budget, and seeking professional guidance from an audiologist. By understanding the options and taking a proactive approach, you can find hearing aids that significantly improve your hearing and enhance your quality of life.
Mayo Clinic Minute: Hearing aids not ‘one-size-fits-all’
Cynthia Hogan, Ph.D., Audiology, Mayo Clinic
Dr. Hogan: “Hearing aids, because they’re digital, can be adjusted over a wide range of hearing loss.”
That’s one reason why audiologist Dr. Cynthia Hogan says with these devices, one-size-fits-all does not apply.
Dr. Hogan: “So there isn’t one best hearing aid for older people versus younger people. We try to choose a hearing aid that’s going to fit the person’s needs.”
Important decisions include whether the device will have rechargeable batteries or ones that need to be replaced, and whether the hearing aid will sit behind or in the ear.
Dr. Hogan: “This is a full-shell, in-the-ear hearing aid. And, so, it fits all into the ear.”
One of the benefits of this device is wearers can answer and listen to a phone call as they have their whole life. Some hearing aids can even connect to a person’s cellphone.
Dr. Hogan: “They can watch videos or things like that directly from their phone to their hearing aid.”
An audiologist like Dr. Hogan can help you sort through all the options and create a personal solution for your hearing problem.
For the Mayo Clinic News Network, I’m Jeff Olsen.
Sept. 20, 20221. Weber PC. Hearing amplification in adults. https://www.uptodate.com/contents/search. Accessed Sept. 15, 2020.
2. Hearing aids. National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders. https://www.nidcd.nih.gov/health/hearing/pages/hearingaid.aspx. Accessed Sept. 15, 2020.
3. Flint PW, et al., eds. Hearing aid amplification. In: Cummings Otolaryngology: Head & Neck Surgery. 7th ed. Elsevier; 2021. https://www.clinicalkey.com. Accessed Sept. 15, 2020.
4. How to find the right hearing aid for you. American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery. https://www.enthealth.org/be_ent_smart/how-to-find-the-right-hearing-aid-for-you/. Accessed Sept. 15, 2020.
5. Rehabilitation and prosthetic services. U.S. Department of Veteran Affairs. https://www.prosthetics.va.gov/psas/Hearing_Aids.asp. Accessed Sept. 15, 2020.
6. Age-related hearing loss. National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders. https://www.nidcd.nih.gov/health/hearing-aids. Accessed Sept. 15, 2020.
7. Hogan CA (expert opinion). Mayo Clinic. Oct. 6, 2020.
