Words for Comparing and Contrasting: Mastering the Art of Academic Connections

Introduction

Throughout your academic journey, you’ll encounter diverse writing assignments, each demanding a unique approach. Among the most prevalent is the comparison and contrast essay. This type of essay focuses on analyzing subjects—often two—to identify their similarities (comparison) and differences (contrast). Instructors assign these essays to cultivate your ability to forge connections between concepts, hone critical thinking skills, and move beyond simple descriptions. By delving into similarities and differences, you achieve a richer understanding of the subjects, their interrelationships, and their core significance.

Mastering the vocabulary of comparison and contrast is crucial for constructing insightful and well-articulated essays. This article will equip you with the essential “Words For Comparing And Contrasting,” enhancing your analytical writing and ensuring clarity for your readers. We will explore how to recognize comparison/contrast prompts, effectively brainstorm similarities and differences, develop compelling thesis statements, structure your essay logically, and utilize signal words to guide your audience seamlessly through your analysis.

Identifying Comparison and Contrast in Essay Prompts

Sometimes, assignment prompts explicitly signal the need for comparison and contrast using keywords like “compare,” “contrast,” “similarities,” and “differences.” Consider these examples:

• Compare and contrast the leadership styles of two historical figures.
• Analyze the similarities and differences in the themes of two novels.
• Discuss the contrasts between two economic theories.

However, not all prompts are this straightforward. Comparison and contrast may be implied or form a component of a larger analytical task. Examine these prompts, noting the subtle cues for comparison/contrast:

• “Analyze the representations of family in two poems.” (Implies comparing and contrasting different representations)
• “How do different scientific studies approach the problem of climate change?” (Encourages a comparison of approaches)
• “Discuss the strengths and weaknesses of two different research methodologies. Which is more suitable for this study?” (Requires comparison and contrast as part of an evaluation)

Understanding the nuances of assignment wording is the first step in recognizing when and how to employ comparison and contrast effectively. When in doubt, carefully consider the underlying task: Are you being asked to analyze relationships, evaluate different perspectives, or explore multiple facets of a topic? If so, comparison and contrast are likely to be valuable tools in your analytical arsenal.

Utilizing Comparison and Contrast for Broader Writing Projects

Even when not explicitly required, comparison and contrast techniques can be invaluable during the pre-writing phase of any essay. Employing these methods can spark ideas and strengthen your arguments, even if the comparison/contrast analysis itself doesn’t feature prominently in your final draft.

For instance, if you aim to argue that one approach to solving a problem is superior to another, comparing and contrasting their key features, strengths, and weaknesses can solidify your evaluation. By systematically outlining similarities and differences, you can identify key points of divergence and build a more compelling case for your chosen perspective. The initial brainstorming lists of similarities and differences may not appear directly in your final paper, but the analytical process will undoubtedly enrich the depth and persuasiveness of your argument.

Brainstorming Similarities and Differences: Words to Get Started

To effectively compare and contrast, you first need to brainstorm points of similarity and difference between your chosen subjects. Visual aids like Venn diagrams and charts can be incredibly helpful in this process.

Venn Diagram: A Venn diagram uses overlapping circles to visually represent commonalities and distinctions. Each circle represents a subject, and the overlapping section lists shared traits. The non-overlapping sections highlight unique characteristics of each subject.

For example, comparing two different types of renewable energy:

Venn diagram illustrating the comparison of Solar and Wind Energy. The overlapping section includes 'Renewable Energy Source', 'Environmentally Friendly'. The Solar circle includes 'Requires Sunlight', 'High Initial Cost'. The Wind circle includes 'Requires Wind', 'Noise Pollution'.

Chart: A comparison chart organizes information in a table format. Criteria for comparison are listed on the left, and the subjects are listed across the top. Each cell then provides specific details for each subject based on the chosen criteria.

For example, comparing different types of transportation:

As you brainstorm, consider the assignment’s purpose, the course content, and your instructor’s expectations. What key aspects are most relevant to your analysis? What underlying themes or concepts are you meant to explore through this comparison?

To guide your brainstorming, consider using these general question starters, adapting them to your specific subjects:

• Characteristics: What are their defining features? What are their qualities?
• Functions: What do they do? What are their purposes?
• Causes: What are their origins? What factors influence them?
• Effects: What are their consequences? What impact do they have?
• Context: Where do they exist? When are they relevant?
• Components: What are their parts? What elements make them up?
• Types: What categories do they belong to? What variations exist?

For specific types of subjects, you can further refine your questions:

Two Historical Periods or Events:

• Timeframe: When did they occur? What were their durations?
• Key Events: What significant happenings defined each period/event?
• Causes & Consequences: What factors led to them? What were their long-term effects?
• Social Structures: What were the dominant social norms, relationships, and values?
• Governance: What forms of government existed? Who were the key figures?

Two Ideas or Theories:

• Core Concepts: What are their central tenets or arguments?
• Origins & Proponents: Who developed them? Who are their key advocates?
• Applications: How are they applied in practice? What are their real-world implications?
• Strengths & Weaknesses: What are their merits and limitations?
• Evidence: What kind of support or evidence is offered for each?
• Plausibility & Scope: How convincing are they? How broadly applicable are they?

Two Literary or Artistic Works:

• Subject Matter: What do they depict or describe? What are their themes?
• Style & Form: What are their artistic techniques? What is their genre or form?
• Creator & Context: Who created them? When and why were they created?
• Quality & Merit: How do they compare in artistic merit or impact?
• Literary Elements (for writing): Plot, characterization, setting, theme, tone, narration.

Two Individuals:

• Background: Where are they from? What are their key demographic characteristics?
• Significance: What are they known for? What is their claim to fame?
• Relationships: How do they relate to each other?
• Personal Traits: What are their personalities, beliefs, and actions?
• Key Distinctions: What makes each individual unique or noteworthy?

Selecting Key Points: Words to Prioritize and Filter

Once you have a comprehensive list of similarities and differences, the next step is to select the most relevant and impactful points for your essay. Not all comparisons are equally important or insightful. Consider these questions to refine your focus:

• Assignment Relevance: Which points directly address the essay prompt?
• Course Context: Which points align with the course themes and learning objectives?
• Significance & Insight: Which points are most interesting, informative, and revealing?
• Argumentative Value: Which points best support the argument you intend to make?
• Centrality & Obviousness: Are there fundamental points that must be mentioned, even if seemingly obvious?
• Overall Emphasis: Are similarities or differences more crucial for your analysis?

For instance, when comparing two novels in a literature class, focusing on typeface or the presence of illustrations would likely be less relevant than analyzing character development, plot structure, or thematic depth. The context of your course and the assignment’s objectives should guide your selection process.

Similarly, some comparisons might be factually accurate but lack analytical depth. Stating that two poems both feature nature as a theme is less insightful than exploring the different ways nature is depicted or the varying aspects of nature emphasized in each poem. Aim for comparisons and contrasts that demonstrate a nuanced and sophisticated understanding of your subjects.

Crafting Your Thesis Statement: Words to Focus Your Argument

The thesis statement is the backbone of your comparison and contrast essay. It provides a clear roadmap for your reader and articulates the central argument you will develop. Avoid vague thesis statements like “This paper will compare and contrast X and Y” or “X and Y are similar and different.” Instead, strive for specificity and analytical depth.

Example of a weak thesis: “Apples and oranges are both fruits, but they are also different.”

Example of a stronger thesis: “While both apples and oranges are citrus fruits sharing similar vitamin content, they differ significantly in taste profile and typical culinary applications, making them suitable for distinct types of dishes.”

To develop a strong thesis, consider these elements:

• Clearly identify the subjects you are comparing and contrasting.
• State your main argument or interpretation about their relationship.
• Hint at the key points of comparison/contrast you will explore.

Here are some sentence starters to help you formulate your thesis:

• “Although X and Y share [similar feature], they diverge significantly in [key difference] due to [reason].”
• “By contrasting [aspect of X] with [aspect of Y], we can see that [main conclusion].”
• “While both X and Y [shared characteristic], their contrasting approaches to [topic] reveal [deeper insight].”
• “The similarities between X and Y in terms of [feature] are less significant than their differences in [feature], which highlights [overall point].”

Remember to revisit and refine your thesis as your essay develops to ensure it accurately reflects the scope and argument of your analysis.

Structuring Your Essay: Words to Organize Your Points

Effective organization is paramount in a comparison and contrast essay. Two primary organizational structures are commonly used: subject-by-subject and point-by-point.

Subject-by-Subject (Block) Method:

This method dedicates separate sections to each subject. You discuss all aspects of subject A, then transition to discussing all aspects of subject B. This structure works well for shorter essays or when focusing on a few key points for each subject.

Example Outline (Subject-by-Subject):

I. Introduction (Thesis statement comparing/contrasting Pepper’s and Amante pizza)
II. Pepper’s Pizza
a. Ingredients
b. Atmosphere
c. Delivery
III. Amante Pizza
a. Ingredients
b. Atmosphere
c. Delivery
IV. Conclusion (Summarize key differences and reiterate thesis)

Words to signal transition between subjects:

• moving on to
• turning to
• let’s now consider
• in contrast
• conversely

Point-by-Point (Alternating) Method:

This method discusses each point of comparison/contrast across both subjects in alternating paragraphs or sections. You address one point for both subject A and subject B before moving to the next point. This structure is often more effective for longer essays and for highlighting direct comparisons and contrasts.

Example Outline (Point-by-Point):

I. Introduction (Thesis statement comparing/contrasting Pepper’s and Amante pizza)
II. Ingredients
a. Pepper’s Pizza Ingredients
b. Amante Pizza Ingredients
III. Atmosphere
a. Pepper’s Pizza Atmosphere
b. Amante Pizza Atmosphere
IV. Delivery
a. Pepper’s Pizza Delivery
b. Amante Pizza Delivery
V. Conclusion (Summarize key differences and reiterate thesis)

Words to signal transitions between points:

• similarly
• in the same way
• likewise
• on the other hand
• conversely
• however
• yet

The choice between subject-by-subject and point-by-point organization depends on the length and complexity of your essay, as well as your personal preference. Point-by-point often leads to a more integrated and analytical comparison, while subject-by-subject can be simpler for presenting information, especially in shorter essays.

A variation of subject-by-subject is the “lens” comparison. In this approach, you use one subject (the “lens”) to examine and understand the other subject more deeply. You might first discuss the “lens” subject in detail and then analyze the second subject through that lens, highlighting similarities and differences in relation to the first.

Utilizing Cue Words: Words to Guide Your Reader

To ensure clarity and coherence, use transition words and phrases to signal comparisons and contrasts throughout your essay. These “cue words” act as signposts, guiding your reader through your analysis and highlighting the relationships between your points.

Words for Comparison (Similarity):

• similarly
• likewise
• in the same way
• also
• too
• as with
• like
• just as
• akin to
• analogous to
• comparable to
• correspondingly
• equally
• identically
• in a similar vein
• much like
• resembles
• sharing the same trait

Words for Contrast (Difference):

• however
• on the other hand
• in contrast
• conversely
• yet
• but
• while
• whereas
• unlike
• differently
• in opposition to
• on the contrary
• despite
• even though
• nevertheless
• notwithstanding
• opposite to
• diverges from
• distinct from
• varied

Example Topic Sentences using Cue Words:

• Compared to traditional teaching methods, online learning offers greater flexibility.
• Like classical music, jazz requires a high level of technical skill from its performers.
• Despite their shared historical context, the two novels present vastly different perspectives on the war.
• Whereas one theory emphasizes individual agency, the other highlights societal structures as the primary driver of behavior.

By strategically incorporating these words and phrases, you can create a smooth and logical flow in your comparison and contrast essay, ensuring your reader clearly understands the relationships you are drawing between your subjects. Mastering the art of using “words for comparing and contrasting” is essential for crafting sophisticated and insightful academic writing.

This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0

You may reproduce it for non-commercial use if you use the entire handout and attribute the source: The Writing Center, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

Make a Gift