Sinéad O’Connor’s powerful rendition of “Nothing Compares 2 U” is unforgettable. But who wrote “Nothing Compares to You” first? This article delves into the song’s origins, O’Connor’s hostile takeover, and the turbulent relationship between her and Prince.
Sinéad O’Connor’s raw and emotional performance of “Nothing Compares 2 U” catapulted her to global fame in 1990. While undeniably O’Connor’s song, the track was penned by none other than Prince. This article explores the fascinating story of how a Prince song became a Sinéad O’Connor classic, examining the song’s journey from Prince’s vault to O’Connor’s iconic music video. We’ll also delve into the complex relationship between the two artists and the impact this had on the song’s legacy.
From Prince’s Side Project to Global Phenomenon
“Nothing Compares 2 U” wasn’t initially a Prince hit. He wrote the song in 1984 for The Family, a side project featuring Paul Peterson, also known as St. Paul, on lead vocals. While a solid performance, the song remained relatively obscure until O’Connor unearthed it for her second album, I Do Not Want What I Haven’t Got.
O’Connor’s interpretation transformed the song. Her shaved head, piercing gaze, and raw emotion in the accompanying music video resonated deeply with audiences worldwide. The song topped charts globally and became synonymous with O’Connor’s unique artistry and vulnerability. But this success came at a cost.
Sinéad O’Connor’s Hostile Takeover: A Song of Grief and Defiance
O’Connor didn’t just sing “Nothing Compares 2 U”; she embodied it. She infused the lyrics with her own personal grief, reportedly dedicating the song to her deceased mother. This intensely personal connection transformed the song from a standard breakup song into a powerful lament of loss and longing.
This transformation, however, didn’t sit well with Prince. O’Connor’s memoir details a fraught relationship with the artist, including allegations of physical threats and a disturbing late-night encounter. While the specifics remain contested, it’s clear that O’Connor’s ownership of the song created tension between the two artists.
The Meaning Behind the Tears: More Than Just a Music Video
The iconic music video for “Nothing Compares 2 U” further solidified O’Connor’s claim on the song. The simple close-up shot of her face, tears streaming down her cheeks as she sang, was revolutionary for its time. It was a stark contrast to the flashy, hyper-edited videos prevalent on MTV, showcasing the power of raw emotion and vulnerability. This minimalist approach amplified the song’s impact, forever linking it to O’Connor’s image.
A Legacy of Two Artists
Despite the controversy and complex relationship between Prince and O’Connor, “Nothing Compares 2 U” remains a testament to the power of songwriting and interpretation. Prince’s original version showcases his melodic genius, while O’Connor’s rendition reveals the transformative potential of a truly gifted artist.
While Prince eventually released his own studio version of the song, it’s O’Connor’s version that continues to resonate with listeners. Her powerful vocals, coupled with the raw emotion she poured into the song, created a cultural moment that transcended the music itself. It became an anthem for heartbreak, loss, and defiance, forever cementing its place in music history. The question of who wrote “Nothing Compares 2 U” first has a clear answer: Prince. However, the question of who truly owns the song is more complex, pointing to the enduring legacy of Sinéad O’Connor.
