When evaluating prices, the phrase “When Compared To” often arises. Is it grammatically different from simply using “compared to”? This article delves into the nuances of these phrases, examining their grammatical structures and exploring whether they convey different meanings. We’ll analyze a linguistic discussion on the topic and draw conclusions about the practical usage of each phrase.
Grammatical Analysis of “When Compared To”
The core of the debate lies in the grammatical classification of “when compared to.” Some argue it’s an adverbial clause introduced by the subordinating conjunction “when,” modifying the main clause. This implies a specific time frame for the comparison. Others contend that “compared to” functions as a prepositional phrase, making “when” redundant. In this view, “when” merely emphasizes the act of comparison without altering the core meaning.
One perspective highlights that “when” can be synonymous with “if” or “whenever,” suggesting a conditional or habitual comparison. For instance, “His price was high when compared to other bicycles” could be interpreted as “His price was high if/whenever compared to other bicycles.”
Conversely, the Cambridge Grammar of the English Language suggests that prepositional phrases, unlike adjective phrases, don’t require a direct predicative relationship with the subject. This supports the argument that “compared to” acts as a prepositional phrase, modifying the adjective “high” without needing “when” to establish a temporal connection. The example provided differentiates between the adjectival phrase “tired of the ship” and the prepositional phrase “ahead of the ship” to illustrate this point.
Practical Usage and Conclusion
In practice, the phrases “when compared to” and “compared to” are often used interchangeably. While “when compared to” might subtly emphasize the act of comparison, the overall meaning remains largely the same. Both effectively convey a relative assessment of one item against others. The choice between the two often boils down to personal preference and writing style.
Ultimately, both constructions communicate a comparative relationship. While a nuanced grammatical debate exists, the practical impact on meaning is minimal. “When compared to” may offer a slightly more formal tone or a subtle emphasis on the comparison itself, but “compared to” remains a concise and widely accepted alternative.
