Product teams constantly face decisions about what to build next. Knowing What To Compare And Contrast is crucial for navigating the complexities of product development and arriving at solutions that truly address user needs. This article explores common pitfalls in decision-making and introduces the Opportunity Solution Tree, a visual framework designed to facilitate effective comparison and contrast exercises, leading to more informed and impactful product choices.
Common Pitfalls: Why We Struggle with What to Compare and Contrast
Often, teams jump to solutions without fully understanding the problem. This leads to several common mistakes:
-
Falling in Love with the First Idea: The immediate satisfaction of generating a solution often leads to premature attachment, hindering objective evaluation of alternative approaches. We stop exploring what to compare and contrast because we’re already convinced.
-
Considering Too Few Ideas: Without exploring a broader range of possibilities, teams miss out on potentially innovative solutions. Robust comparison requires a diverse set of options to contrast against each other.
-
Lack of Alignment on the Target Opportunity: When teams don’t agree on the core problem they’re trying to solve, solutions become disjointed and irrelevant. A shared understanding of the opportunity is essential when deciding what to compare and contrast.
-
Considering Too Few Opportunities: Focusing on a single perceived problem prevents teams from discovering more impactful opportunities. Effective comparison requires evaluating multiple potential avenues for achieving desired outcomes.
The Opportunity Solution Tree: A Framework for Effective Comparison
The Opportunity Solution Tree, inspired by Anders Ericsson’s research on expert performance, provides a visual framework for organizing and analyzing information, enabling teams to make decisions based on a shared understanding. It guides teams on what to compare and contrast at each stage of the decision-making process.
Building the Tree: A Step-by-Step Guide to Comparison
-
Define the Desired Outcome: Start with a clear articulation of the desired goal, ensuring the entire team is aligned on what they are striving to achieve.
-
Identify Opportunities Based on Research: Conduct thorough user research to uncover genuine customer needs, pain points, and desires. Frame these as opportunities that reflect user statements.
-
Structure and Group Opportunities: Organize opportunities into logical groups based on similarities and relationships. This simplifies prioritization and facilitates comparing opportunities at similar levels of abstraction. This step is crucial for determining what to compare and contrast when prioritizing opportunities.
-
Prioritize Opportunities: Systematically evaluate and prioritize opportunity groups, then individual opportunities within each group. This comparative analysis ensures focus on the most impactful areas.
-
Generate Solutions for a Target Opportunity: Focus ideation efforts on a single, high-priority opportunity. This concentrated brainstorming promotes deeper exploration and more creative solutions for a specific problem.
- Compare and Contrast Solutions: Use dot voting to narrow down the solution set, then conduct experiments to compare and contrast the remaining options based on key assumptions. This comparative testing provides data-driven insights for informed decision-making.
Conclusion: The Power of Comparative Thinking
The Opportunity Solution Tree empowers product teams to make better decisions by providing a structured approach to what to compare and contrast. By systematically evaluating opportunities and solutions, teams can move beyond gut feelings and opinions, ensuring that efforts are focused on solving the right problems with the most effective solutions. This framework promotes a culture of data-informed decision-making, ultimately leading to more successful product outcomes. By understanding what to compare and contrast, product teams can unlock their full potential for innovation and impact.
