Navigating the world of men’s hair styling products can feel overwhelming. With countless options available, each promising different results, finding the right product to achieve your desired hairstyle can be a real challenge. If you’re familiar with hair styling, you might have come across Aveda Thickening Paste, known for its ability to add volume and texture to hair. But what if you’re looking for something similar, perhaps more readily available, or exploring different brands?
This guide will break down the world of hair styling products, focusing on finding products comparable to Aveda Thickening Paste. We’ll delve into different types of hair products like pomades, clays, waxes, and pastes to help you discover the best alternative for your hair type and styling needs. Whether you’re seeking similar hold, finish, or hair benefits, we’ll explore your options to help you make an informed decision.
Understanding Hair Paste and Its Role
Hair paste is a versatile styling product favored by many for its balanced hold and texture. Unlike gels that leave hair stiff or pomades that often prioritize shine, hair pastes typically offer a medium to firm hold with a natural to matte finish. This makes them incredibly adaptable for various hairstyles, from structured combed looks to more relaxed, textured styles.
Hair pastes generally have a thicker consistency than pomades, ranging from a creamy texture to a more dense, tacky feel. This texture allows for significant control and shaping of the hair. A key benefit of most hair pastes is their water-based formulation, which makes them easy to wash out without leaving residue.
A jar of Mister Pompadour Natural Beeswax Paste, a firm hold hair paste with a matte finish, showcasing its texture and branding.
When considering alternatives to Aveda Thickening Paste, understanding the characteristics of hair paste is crucial. Aveda Thickening Paste aims to provide thickness and texture, which are core functions of many hair pastes. Therefore, exploring other hair pastes is a logical first step in finding comparable products.
Pomade: Shine and Slickness vs. Paste’s Texture
Pomade is another common term in men’s hair styling, often used broadly to describe products beyond gels and fibers. Pomades are traditionally designed to create slick, neat hairstyles with a high shine finish. Think classic styles like pompadours, slick backs, and side parts – hairstyles typically achieved with a comb. Unlike gels, pomades remain pliable, allowing for restyling throughout the day without hardening or flaking.
Pomades are categorized into oil-based and water-based. Oil-based pomades, the traditional type, offer strong hold and high shine due to ingredients like petroleum. However, they are notoriously difficult to wash out and can lead to scalp and skin issues. Water-based pomades aim to replicate the slickness and hold of oil-based pomades but are easier to rinse out with water.
While pomades excel at creating sleek styles, they generally prioritize shine over the natural, textured finish often sought in thickening pastes. If you appreciate the volume and texture provided by Aveda Thickening Paste, a pomade might not be the most direct substitute, especially if you prefer a matte or natural finish. However, water-based pomades can offer a degree of reworkability and control that might appeal if you’re open to a higher shine look.
Clay: Natural Volume and Texture – A Close Competitor
Hair clay is a more recent category in men’s styling, distinguished by the inclusion of clay ingredients like bentonite. Bentonite clay, derived from volcanic ash, is known for its fine, powdery texture and its ability to swell when in contact with water. In hair products, clay contributes to thickening hair strands, adding body, volume, and structure without weighing hair down.
Two product shots of Mister Pompadour Sculpting Clay, showcasing the jar and the creamy texture of the clay product.
Hair clays are excellent for hairstyles requiring significant volume and a natural finish. They typically provide a matte to semi-matte finish, aligning well with the desired outcome when seeking alternatives to thickening pastes. Furthermore, clay offers additional hair benefits: it can draw out impurities, stimulate the scalp, and nourish hair with minerals, making it suitable for sensitive skin and promoting hair health.
For those seeking a product comparable to Aveda Thickening Paste, hair clay stands out as a strong contender. Its focus on volume, texture, and natural finish closely mirrors the benefits of a thickening paste. If you appreciate the thickening effect and matte finish of Aveda Thickening Paste, exploring hair clays is highly recommended.
Wax: Flexible Hold with Varying Shine
Hair wax is often a source of confusion, as the term is sometimes used generically to describe various styling products. True hair waxes are characterized by their non-hardening nature and typically have a shiny finish. They are most similar to pomades but generally offer a lighter hold.
Waxes provide medium to high shine and are suitable for comb-dependent styles like pompadours and slick backs, similar to pomades. However, their lighter hold might not be ideal if you need the firm control offered by a thickening paste for maintaining volume and shape throughout the day, especially for thicker hair.
If you prioritize flexibility and shine over strong hold and a matte finish, hair wax could be considered. However, for those specifically seeking an alternative to Aveda Thickening Paste’s volumizing and texturizing capabilities with a more natural finish, waxes might not be the closest match.
Texture Powder & Volumizing Powder: Instant Volume Boost
Texture powders and volumizing powders are lesser-known but powerful tools for achieving significant volume and lightweight hold. These powders, often containing silica silylate, work by creating friction between hair fibers, lifting hair at the roots and absorbing excess oil for added volume.
Two images of Mister Pompadour Texture Powder, one showing the product container and the other highlighting the ingredient list.
Texture powders are typically pre-stylers, applied before or after blow-drying and before using a finishing product like paste or pomade. They are applied directly to the roots for maximum lift or to the ends for separation and a piecey effect. While powders excel at creating volume, they can leave hair feeling slightly stiff and are not designed to be used alone for hold and styling in the same way as a paste.
For those seeking to amplify the volume achieved with a thickening paste, texture powder can be an excellent addition to your styling routine. It’s not a direct replacement for Aveda Thickening Paste in terms of all-in-one styling, but it’s a fantastic tool for maximizing volume, especially when used in conjunction with a hair paste or clay for hold and definition.
Hair Cream & Lotion: Moisture and Light Hold
Hair creams, also known as hair lotions, are primarily moisturizing products with a light hold. They have a lotion-like consistency and are designed to control frizz and add a soft, subtle hold. Hair creams are often used as pre-stylers to add substance, shine, and separation, particularly for curly or frizzy hair types.
While hair creams can contribute to overall hair manageability and health, they do not offer the hold, volume, or texture that thickening pastes or their alternatives provide for styling. If you’re looking for a product to tame frizz and add a touch of control while maintaining hair hydration, hair cream can be beneficial, but it won’t serve as a direct substitute for Aveda Thickening Paste in terms of styling and thickening.
Hair Gel: Strong Hold, But at a Cost
Hair gel is perhaps the most widely recognized men’s hair styling product, often considered a “starter” product. Gels are known for their strong hold, stiff finish, and high shine. They work by coating hair strands and binding them together, locking hairstyles in place. However, this strong hold comes with drawbacks.
Gels often contain harsh alcohols and chemicals that can dry out and damage hair, leading to flaking, residue, brittleness, and scalp issues. They lack flexibility and restylability and are generally not recommended for maintaining healthy hair and scalp.
Given the potential damage and the stiff, unnatural finish, hair gel is not a comparable product to Aveda Thickening Paste, especially if you value hair health and a natural look. For those seeking volume, texture, and a healthy hair appearance, hair gel is best avoided.
Mousse: Lightweight Volume and Pre-Styling
Hair mousse is a foam-based product designed to add body, light hold, and shine. It’s an often-underutilized product for men, particularly those seeking volume. Mousse works by coating hair strands with polymers that help hair hold its shape as it dries.
Applying mousse at the roots and blow-drying outwards is key to achieving significant volume. Mousse is effective for various hair types and can be used as a pre-styler to create a foundation of volume before applying a paste or clay for further styling and hold. While mousse provides volume, it offers a lighter hold compared to pastes or clays and is primarily used as a volumizing base.
Mousse can be a valuable addition to your styling routine if you need extra volume, especially when used in combination with a hair paste or clay to achieve a style similar to that created with Aveda Thickening Paste. It’s not a standalone alternative but a complementary product for enhancing volume.
Hairspray: Locking in Your Style
Hairspray is used to set hairstyles, enhance shine, reduce frizz, and add hold. It can be used alone or with other styling products like pastes or pomades. Hairsprays come in various hold levels – flexible, medium, and maximum. Flexible hold sprays offer light control and reduce frizz, while maximum hold sprays lock hairstyles firmly in place.
Hairspray is primarily a finishing product to increase the longevity and hold of a hairstyle. It’s not a direct substitute for Aveda Thickening Paste in terms of texture and initial styling. However, if you find that your chosen paste or clay doesn’t provide sufficient hold throughout the day, a hairspray can be used to lock your style in place without compromising the texture and volume achieved with your primary styling product.
Hair Oils: Hair Health, Not Styling
Hair oils, including serums and natural oils like argan, coconut, almond, and olive oil, are primarily hair care products, not styling products. Serums can help control frizz and add shine, particularly for longer hair. Natural hair oils are used to hydrate and repair hair, especially when the scalp’s natural oil production is insufficient.
Hair oils are not designed to provide hold or styling capabilities. They can leave hair looking oily and are best used as overnight treatments or when styling is not the primary goal. While hair oils are crucial for maintaining healthy hair, they are not comparable to Aveda Thickening Paste or similar styling products. However, healthy, well-moisturized hair will always style better, so incorporating hair oils into your overall hair care routine is beneficial, regardless of your styling product choice.
Finding Your Best Alternative
Choosing a product comparable to Aveda Thickening Paste depends on your specific needs and preferences. If you value the thickening effect, texture, and matte finish, hair pastes and clays are your closest alternatives.
- Hair Pastes, like Mister Pompadour Natural Beeswax Paste, offer versatility, medium to firm hold, and a natural to matte finish, making them excellent all-around substitutes.
- Hair Clays, such as Mister Pompadour Sculpting Clay, excel at providing volume, texture, and a natural matte finish, closely mimicking the benefits of a thickening paste while often adding hair health benefits.
- Texture Powders can be used in conjunction with pastes or clays to maximize volume, offering an extra boost when needed.
- Mousse serves as a great pre-styler to create a voluminous base before applying your chosen paste or clay.
While pomades, waxes, creams, gels, and hairsprays serve different styling purposes, they are less direct substitutes for the specific benefits of a thickening paste focused on volume, texture, and a natural finish.
Ultimately, experimenting with hair pastes and clays is the most effective way to discover your ideal alternative to Aveda Thickening Paste. Consider your hair type, desired hairstyle, and preferred finish to guide your choice. Exploring products like Mister Pompadour Natural Beeswax Paste and Sculpting Clay can provide excellent starting points in your search for the perfect thickening and styling solution.
Like What You’ve Read?
Sign Up and Become An Expert Too
