Mascara is a makeup bag staple for many, but finding the perfect one can be a challenge. Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara is a popular choice, known for its lengthening and volumizing formula. But is it the best option out there? This in-depth review compares Thrive mascara to another cult favorite, Hourglass Unlocked Instant Extensions Mascara, to help you decide which one reigns supreme. We’ll analyze these mascaras based on price, ingredients, brush type, color selection, consistency, volume and length results, staying power, and ease of removal.
Thrive Causemetics vs. Hourglass Unlocked: A Head-to-Head Mascara Showdown
Both Thrive and Hourglass mascaras utilize innovative tubing formulas. This technology encases each lash in a lightweight tube, creating dramatic length and volume without smudging or flaking. These tubes slide off easily with warm water, eliminating the need for harsh makeup removers. But how do they stack up against each other?
Price and Availability
Thrive Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara retails for $24, but free shipping typically requires a minimum purchase of $35 on the Thrive website. Hourglass Unlocked Instant Extensions Mascara is priced slightly higher at $29 but is readily available at major retailers like Sephora and Nordstrom, often with more accessible free shipping options.
Ingredient Analysis
Both mascaras boast clean formulas free from parabens, phthalates, sulfates, and synthetic fragrances. Both brands are also cruelty-free. Thrive’s formula includes castor oil, an ingredient known for promoting lash health and growth. While noticeable lash improvement is possible with Thrive, attributing it solely to the castor oil is difficult, especially for those who also use lash serums.
Brush Comparison
Both mascaras feature similar brushes: thick wands with short, plastic bristles. This type of brush allows for precise application and excellent lash manipulation, making it ideal for achieving defined and separated lashes.
Color Options
Hourglass Unlocked Instant Extensions Mascara is currently available only in black. Thrive Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara, however offers a wider range of color choices, including black, brown, and blue, catering to diverse preferences.
Formula Consistency
Thrive’s formula is initially quite wet but tends to thicken slightly with regular use. Hourglass’s formula has a drier, slightly flaky consistency. Both formulas, however, are buildable, allowing for customized lash looks ranging from natural to dramatic. Application is generally clean and mess-free with both products.
Length and Volume Results
Both mascaras deliver exceptional lengthening and lift, extending lashes beyond their natural length. While both provide volume, Hourglass edges out Thrive in this category. Hourglass consistently creates a feathery, full lash look, whereas Thrive can occasionally clump, especially when layering for more dramatic volume.
Staying Power and Smudge Resistance
Both mascaras excel at staying put throughout the day, living up to their smudge-proof claims. However, Hourglass might exhibit minimal smudging under extreme conditions like prolonged sun exposure or excessive squinting. Despite this, both are suitable for application on lower lashes.
Ease of Removal
Removing tubing mascaras requires a slightly different approach compared to traditional formulas. Gentle massage with a cleansing balm, followed by warm water, will loosen the tubes, allowing them to pill or peel away from the lashes. While both remove easily with this method, Hourglass tends to come off slightly easier than Thrive.
The Verdict: Which Mascara Wins?
While initial impressions favored Hourglass, long-term use reveals that Thrive offers consistently excellent results over time, making it a more valuable purchase. Thrive might require a bit more patience during removal, but its long-lasting performance and wider color selection make it a compelling contender. Ultimately, the best choice depends on individual preferences and priorities.
Which mascara will you choose? Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments below!
