Kirkland Signature golf balls, often found on courses and readily available at Costco, have garnered attention for their value proposition. This review delves into the performance of the Kirkland Signature version 3, comparing it to premium golf balls on the market. After playing several rounds and conducting simulator tests, we aim to answer the question: How do Kirkland golf balls stack up against the competition?
Performance on the Course
The Kirkland Signature v3 didn’t negatively impact scores or overall game performance. Tee shots and approach shots landed in comparable positions to those achieved with premium balls like the Callaway Chrome Soft and Srixon Z-Star. An 8-iron consistently flew 150-155 yards, landing near pin high.
(Image credit: Future)
While previous Kirkland iterations were criticized for excessive spin, the v3 feels firmer. Although a slight increase in hook spin was observed on short irons, this could be attributed to individual swing variations. Whether this ball exacerbates slicing tendencies remains inconclusive, as the tester’s swing doesn’t produce slices.
Simulator Testing and Data Analysis
To quantify performance, launch monitor data was collected and compared with the Titleist Pro V1. With a 7-iron, the Kirkland ball averaged 5,000 rpm of total spin, a launch angle just under 20 degrees, and a ball speed of 107 mph. This spin rate was marginally higher than the Pro V1’s 4,850 rpm, but total distance remained similar (160-165 yards).
(Image credit: Future)
Driver testing revealed comparable average distances of 250 yards for both balls. The longest drives recorded were 266 yards with the Kirkland and 271 yards with the Pro V1. These results, achieved with a driver swing speed in the mid-to-upper 90s mph range, suggest minimal difference for moderate swing speeds. Higher swing speeds might yield different outcomes. Spin rates with the driver were also comparable.
Feel and Putting Performance
Concerns about the Kirkland ball’s feel and roll on the greens were addressed. Putting tests revealed a similar feel to other urethane-covered balls, rolling true and resulting in consistent putts. Blind tests against various urethane balls suggested a slightly less soft feel, potentially due to a thinner cover.
(Image credit: Future)
Aesthetics and Alignment
The Kirkland ball’s aesthetics leave room for improvement. The “Performance” marking with double arrows isn’t an ideal alignment aid, necessitating the use of a stencil. The Kirkland Signature logo also lacks visual appeal.
(Image credit: Future)
Conclusion: A Value-Packed Contender
The Kirkland Signature v3 golf ball delivers comparable performance to premium golf balls, particularly for golfers with moderate swing speeds. While aesthetics and alignment markings could be enhanced, the ball’s overall performance and significantly lower price point make it a compelling alternative to more expensive options. It’s a ball worth considering for those seeking value without sacrificing performance.
