In the realm of SQL database management, synonyms serve as aliases, simplifying object references and enhancing code readability. However, when comparing databases across different environments using tools like SQL Compare, subtle discrepancies in synonym definitions can sometimes be overlooked. This article delves into a common scenario where synonym differences might be missed and provides a straightforward solution to ensure comprehensive database comparisons.
The Scenario: Development vs. Production Synonyms
Imagine a typical database development lifecycle where you maintain separate environments, such as development (Dev) and production (Prod). In Dev, you might have synonyms pointing to objects within the same or different databases for modularity and ease of development. For instance, a synonym in Sales_Feature database might reference a table in Finance_Feature database.
USE [SimpleTalk_1_Dev]
GO
CREATE SYNONYM dbo.MyTable FOR Compare1.dbo.MyTable
GOHowever, in the Prod environment, these synonyms need to be redefined to point to the corresponding objects within the production databases, such as Sales and Finance.
USE [SimpleTalk_5_Prod]
GO
CREATE SYNONYM dbo.MyTable FOR Compare2.dbo.MyTable
GOWhen deploying changes or comparing databases between Dev and Prod using SQL Compare, you might expect to see these synonym differences highlighted. Yet, in some cases, these differences might not be immediately apparent.
The Unexpected Issue: Ignored Synonym Differences
By default, SQL Compare employs a setting that can lead to overlooking these synonym discrepancies. This setting, aptly named “Ignore database and server name in synonyms,” is enabled to accommodate scenarios where synonyms are intentionally pointed to different servers or databases between environments. The tool assumes that you might be aware of these environment-specific differences and are primarily concerned with other structural or schema changes.
When this option is active, SQL Compare focuses on the underlying object name referenced by the synonym, disregarding variations in the database or server name. Consequently, if only the database or server part of the synonym definition differs, SQL Compare might report no difference, even though the synonyms are indeed pointing to different locations.
The Solution: Adjusting Project Options for Accurate Comparison
To ensure that SQL Compare accurately detects and highlights synonym differences, including variations in database and server names, you need to adjust the project options.
- Access Project Settings: In SQL Compare, open your project and navigate to the “Edit project” settings.
- Locate Options Tab: Within the project settings, find and select the “Options” tab.
- Scroll to Synonym Options: Scroll down the options list until you locate the “Ignore database and server name in synonyms” setting.
2022-03-30 16_03_33-New project_
Optimizing SQL Compare project settings by unchecking “Ignore database and server name in synonyms” to ensure accurate detection of synonym differences across database environments.
- Disable the Option: Uncheck the box next to “Ignore database and server name in synonyms.”
- Rerun the Comparison: Save the changes and rerun the database comparison.
With this option disabled, SQL Compare will now consider the entire synonym definition, including the database and server name. As a result, any differences in synonym targets across environments will be correctly identified and displayed in the comparison results.
Broader Application Across Redgate Tools
It’s important to note that this “Ignore database and server name in synonyms” option is not exclusive to SQL Compare. It is a core setting within the SQL Compare engine, which powers a range of Redgate tools designed for database development and deployment. This includes tools like SQL Change Automation, SQL Source Control, Flyway Desktop, and various automation components within Redgate Deploy.
Therefore, if you are utilizing any of these Redgate products and encounter situations where synonym differences are not being detected, ensure that you have reviewed and adjusted this option within the respective tool’s project settings.
Conclusion: Ensuring Accurate Synonym Comparison
In conclusion, while the “Ignore database and server name in synonyms” option in SQL Compare and related Redgate tools serves a purpose in specific scenarios, disabling it is crucial when you need to accurately compare synonym definitions across different database environments. By understanding this setting and adjusting it accordingly, you can ensure comprehensive and reliable database comparisons, leading to smoother deployments and better management of your SQL database landscapes.
If you are seeking robust tools to streamline your database development and deployment processes in a DevOps manner, consider exploring Redgate’s suite of tools. Download a trial to experience the benefits firsthand.
