The Subaru Outback has carved a unique niche in the automotive market, blending SUV practicality with wagon-like handling and standard all-wheel drive. Its popularity is undeniable, resonating with those seeking adventure, reliability, and a touch of ruggedness without sacrificing everyday comfort. If you’re drawn to the Outback’s appeal but are exploring your options, you’re in the right place. This article delves into the world of Subaru Outback Comparables, examining vehicles that offer similar attributes and cater to the same discerning audience.
We’ll even revisit an intriguing comparison from the past, pitting the Outback against a surprising contender – the Porsche Macan S – to understand the spectrum of vehicles that can be considered in the same conversation as the Outback. While these vehicles occupy different price points, the comparison highlights the Outback’s surprisingly broad appeal and the diverse needs of SUV buyers.
Let’s first revisit a previous insightful comparison that explored the unexpected similarities between the Subaru Outback and the Porsche Macan S.
A Look Back: Subaru Outback vs. Porsche Macan S
It might seem like comparing apples and oranges – a mainstream Subaru Outback and a luxury Porsche Macan S. However, a closer look reveals some intriguing parallels, as highlighted in a previous comparison. Both vehicles, despite their price disparity, cater to a similar desire for versatility and capability.
The author of the original comparison, much like many American households, owned two SUVs: a Porsche Macan S and a Subaru Outback. This real-world ownership provided a unique perspective on comparing these seemingly disparate vehicles. The Macan, while carrying the Porsche badge and performance pedigree, is, in essence, a compact SUV designed for both spirited driving and everyday practicality. The Outback, on the other hand, represents Subaru’s commitment to rugged capability and value.
Unexpected Similarities:
The comparison revealed surprising common ground:
- Shared Features: Both vehicles boasted features like paddle shifters, lane departure warning systems, heated seats, sunroofs, and ample cupholders. These shared amenities highlight the increasing convergence of features across different vehicle segments.
- Size and Dimensions: Their wheelbases were remarkably close (Macan 110.5 inches vs. Outback 108.1 inches), and the Outback actually offered more headroom. Turning radius was also comparable, showcasing similar maneuverability.
- Speeding Tickets: Humorously, the author noted receiving speeding tickets in both vehicles on separate occasions, suggesting both possess a deceptive sense of speed and effortless cruising ability.
Where They Diverge:
The significant differences, however, were undeniable:
- Price and Options: The Macan S, especially when optioned, could easily cost twice as much as a fully loaded Outback. Porsche’s extensive and tempting options list significantly inflated the price, while Subaru offered value-packed trims and packages.
- Performance and Powertrain: The Macan S, with its 340-horsepower turbocharged V6, delivered nearly double the horsepower of the Outback’s 175-horsepower 2.5-liter flat-four. This translated to a vastly different driving experience, with the Macan offering exhilarating acceleration and handling.
- Fuel Economy and Fuel Type: The Outback excelled in fuel economy and used regular gas, while the Macan S demanded premium fuel and was less fuel-efficient.
- Cargo Space and Stance: Despite being heavier, the Macan S offered less cargo space than the Outback. The Macan also had a wider track, contributing to its sportier and more planted stance.
Driving Dynamics and Interior:
The Macan S truly lived up to the “Sport” in SUV, offering handling that could rival a sports car. The Outback, while comfortable and capable, prioritized practicality over sporty dynamics.
Inside, the Macan’s optional leather interior was undeniably more luxurious, but the Outback’s upgraded interior was surprisingly well-appointed and user-friendly, particularly in terms of its infotainment system’s simplicity compared to Porsche’s more complex controls. Voice activation was also notably absent in the Macan of that era, a feature readily available and functional in the Outback.
Snow and All-Weather Capability:
Both vehicles were deemed capable in snow and wet conditions. Subaru’s reputation for all-wheel-drive prowess is well-established, and the Macan, engineered in Germany where winter conditions are prevalent, also proved to be sure-footed, especially when equipped with appropriate tires.
The Verdict Then and Now:
The original comparison concluded that while vastly different in price and target market, both the Macan S and Outback offered compelling attributes. The Macan S delivered a thrilling driving experience and luxury feel, while the Outback provided exceptional value, practicality, and ruggedness.
Interestingly, the comparison suggested that a used Porsche Macan, due to depreciation, could become a surprisingly attractive alternative to a new Subaru Outback, blurring the lines between luxury and mainstream value.
Expanding the Horizon: True Subaru Outback Comparables
While the Macan comparison was insightful, when searching for Subaru Outback comparables, most buyers are likely considering vehicles in a similar price range and segment. The Outback occupies a unique space, straddling the line between wagon and SUV. Therefore, its true competitors are vehicles that offer a blend of:
- Standard or Available All-Wheel Drive: Essential for all-weather capability and light off-roading.
- Wagon or SUV Body Style: Prioritizing cargo space and passenger room over sleek coupe-like designs.
- Rugged or Adventurous Persona: Appealing to those with an active lifestyle and a desire to explore beyond paved roads.
- Competitive Price Point: Generally falling within the mainstream SUV market, rather than the luxury segment.
Considering these factors, here are some key Subaru Outback comparables to consider:
1. Mazda CX-5: Often praised for its sporty handling and upscale interior, the CX-5 provides a more engaging driving experience than many in its class. While not as overtly rugged as the Outback, it offers available all-wheel drive and a refined driving experience.
2. Honda CR-V: A perennial bestseller, the CR-V excels in practicality, fuel efficiency, and reliability. It offers available all-wheel drive and a spacious interior, making it a strong contender for families and those prioritizing functionality.
3. Toyota RAV4: Another dominant player in the segment, the RAV4 boasts a reputation for reliability and offers a wide range of trims, including hybrid and more rugged “Adventure” and “TRD Off-Road” models that directly target the Outback’s adventurous spirit.
4. Ford Bronco Sport: With its retro styling and focus on off-road capability, the Bronco Sport directly challenges the Outback’s rugged image. Standard four-wheel drive (not all-wheel drive, but more off-road focused) and a boxy, utilitarian design make it a compelling alternative for adventure seekers.
5. Jeep Cherokee: The Cherokee offers genuine off-road capability in a compact SUV package. Available with various four-wheel-drive systems and a more traditional SUV design, it appeals to those who prioritize trail-readiness.
6. Hyundai Santa Fe: The Santa Fe provides a compelling blend of value, features, and a comfortable ride. Available all-wheel drive and a spacious interior make it a practical and well-rounded competitor.
7. Kia Sorento: Slightly larger than the Outback, the Sorento offers available three-row seating and a stylish design. All-wheel drive is available, and it provides a good balance of practicality and features at a competitive price.
Choosing Your Rugged and Refined Ride:
Ultimately, the best Subaru Outback comparable for you depends on your individual needs and priorities. If you prioritize sporty driving dynamics and a luxurious feel, exploring used Porsche Macan models might be an intriguing option, as the original comparison suggested.
However, for most buyers seeking a direct alternative in terms of price and segment, the Mazda CX-5, Honda CR-V, Toyota RAV4, Ford Bronco Sport, Jeep Cherokee, Hyundai Santa Fe, and Kia Sorento all offer compelling features and capabilities worth considering. Each of these vehicles brings its own strengths to the table, whether it’s fuel efficiency, off-road prowess, sporty handling, or interior refinement.
The Subaru Outback’s success lies in its ability to blend wagon practicality with SUV capability and a touch of rugged charm. Exploring these Subaru Outback comparables will help you find the perfect vehicle that aligns with your adventurous spirit and everyday needs. Whether you prioritize on-road refinement or off-road exploration, the market offers a diverse range of options to consider in your search for the ideal rugged and refined ride.
