American businesses across all sectors and sizes are consistently reporting a significant challenge: finding enough workers to fill open positions. Current data reveals a stark reality – approximately 8 million job openings nationwide, while only 6.8 million Americans are unemployed.
This situation highlights a fundamental issue: there are more jobs available than there are people to fill them. Even if every unemployed individual in the U.S. were to find employment today, millions of jobs would still remain vacant.
To better understand these workforce trends, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce provides up-to-date analysis on job openings, labor force participation, and other key metrics through the America Works Data Center. This article will delve into the national workforce landscape, analyzing the factors contributing to the current labor shortage and comparing the job market of 2023 with the pre-pandemic conditions of 2020.
The Onset of Worker Shortage: Tracing Back to 2020
The roots of the current labor shortage can be traced back to the unprecedented economic disruptions of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020. At the pandemic’s peak, over 120,000 businesses were forced into temporary closures, leading to a staggering 30 million Americans becoming unemployed. As the economy began its recovery, a notable trend emerged: job openings began a steady climb, while unemployment rates decreased at a slower pace.
By 2023, the U.S. job market demonstrated considerable strength, with employers adding 3.1 million jobs throughout the year. While a robust job market is generally positive, a significant portion of these job openings remained unfilled. This gap isn’t due to a lack of available jobs, but rather a deficit in the number of workers to meet the demand. Although workforce participation has increased since the pandemic’s initial impact, the overall percentage of the population engaged in the labor force remains below pre-pandemic levels. Specifically, if the labor force participation rate matched that of February 2020, the U.S. would have over two million additional workers to potentially fill these open positions. This comparison between the job market of 2020 and 2023 underscores the growing challenge businesses face in securing adequate staffing.
Decoding the Participation Gap: Why Aren’t People Working?
Currently, the labor force participation rate stands at 62.7%, a decrease from 63.3% in February 2020 and significantly lower than the 67.2% recorded in January 2001. This decline isn’t attributable to a single factor but is a confluence of several converging issues. The following elements have collectively contributed to the ongoing labor shortage, creating a notable difference in workforce dynamics when comparing 2023 to the pre-pandemic era of 2020.
To gain deeper insights into the reasons behind this workforce gap, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce conducted a survey in May 2022, targeting unemployed individuals who had lost their jobs during the pandemic. The survey revealed several key factors influencing their decisions regarding returning to work:
- Limited Job Search Activity: A significant majority (66%) of Americans who experienced full-time job loss during the pandemic reported being only somewhat active or not very active in seeking new employment.
- Remote Work Preference: Approximately half (49%) expressed unwillingness to consider jobs that did not offer remote work options, highlighting a shift in worker preferences since 2020.
- Reconsidering the Necessity of Work: Over a quarter (26%) indicated that returning to work would never again be essential for them, reflecting a potential change in priorities or financial situations compared to the pre-pandemic job market.
- Shifted Livelihoods: Nearly one in five respondents had made significant changes to their livelihoods, with 17% having retired, 19% transitioning to homemakers, and 14% opting for part-time employment. These transitions mark a considerable departure from the full-time employment landscape more common in 2020.
- Impact of Government Aid: Almost a quarter (24%) suggested that government aid packages distributed during the pandemic had disincentivized their active job search, a factor not present in the job market of 2020.
- Focus on Personal Growth: Younger respondents, aged 25-34, indicated a prioritization of personal growth over immediate job seeking, with 36% stating they were more focused on acquiring new skills, education, or training before re-entering the job market. This emphasis on self-improvement represents a potential shift in career approaches compared to the job urgency prevalent in 2020.
Key Factors Fueling the Persistent Labor Shortage
Several interconnected factors are contributing to the ongoing labor shortage and shaping the differences observed when comparing the job market in 2023 to that of 2020.
Early Retirements and an Aging Workforce:
The pandemic spurred a wave of early retirements. By October 2021, over 3 million adults had opted for early retirement due to the pandemic’s impact. The proportion of adults aged 55 and older who are detached from the labor force due to retirement increased from 48.1% in Q3 2019 to 50.3% in Q3 2021. This trend signifies a considerable reduction in the experienced workforce, a factor less pronounced in the job market at the beginning of 2020.
Furthermore, the U.S. population is aging, with a growing proportion of older individuals. This demographic shift, combined with lower birth rates in younger generations, points towards a continued aging and potential shrinking of the workforce in the years ahead, exacerbating the labor shortage in contrast to the younger workforce profile of 2020.
Historically Low Net International Migration:
Immigration, traditionally a significant contributor to U.S. workforce growth, has drastically decreased. U.S. Census Bureau data reveals that net international migration contributed only 247,000 individuals to the U.S. population increase between 2020 and 2021. This is a stark 76% drop compared to the decade’s high of 1,049,000 population increase due to immigration between 2015 and 2016. This dramatic reduction in immigration significantly limits the influx of new workers into the labor force, a stark contrast to the more robust immigration levels that supported workforce growth in 2020 and prior years.
Childcare Access Challenges:
The lack of accessible and affordable childcare was already a significant issue before the pandemic, and it has been further amplified. Research from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce Foundation estimated that childcare breakdowns cost surveyed states an average of $2.7 billion annually in economic losses even before 2020.
The pandemic exacerbated this issue, forcing numerous childcare providers to close or reduce capacity. Between February and April 2020, the childcare industry lost 370,600 jobs, predominantly held by women. As of September 2021, employment in the childcare industry remained 10% below pre-pandemic levels. This childcare crisis disproportionately affects women’s participation in the workforce. In spring 2020, 3.5 million mothers left their jobs, causing the labor force participation rate for working mothers to plummet from around 70% to 55%. While women’s employment has increased since 2020, their labor force participation rate is yet to fully recover to pre-pandemic levels or the peak of 60.2% in early 2001. The survey by the Chamber also revealed that 27% of unemployed workers cited childcare or family care responsibilities as a major barrier to returning to work. The childcare crisis presents a significant impediment to workforce participation, particularly for women, and represents a more pronounced challenge in 2023 compared to the pre-pandemic conditions of 2020.
Boom in New Business Creation:
Paradoxically, the labor shortage is also linked to a surge in new business creation. Fueled by entrepreneurial spirit, many individuals left employment or remained unemployed to start their own businesses. In 2023, 5.5 million new businesses were launched, continuing a trend of record-high numbers of new business applications in recent years. This entrepreneurial drive, while beneficial for the economy in many ways, also draws potential workers away from traditional employment, contributing to the labor shortage when compared to the business landscape of 2020.
Furthermore, the rise of the digital economy has provided alternative income streams. In 2020, an estimated 2 million individuals earned six figures or more through social media and digital commerce. This shift towards digital entrepreneurship and content creation further diversifies career paths and potentially reduces the pool of workers available for traditional jobs, a trend that has gained momentum since 2020.
Increased Savings:
Government stimulus measures, enhanced unemployment benefits, and reduced spending opportunities during the pandemic contributed to a significant increase in personal savings. Americans collectively added $4 trillion to their savings accounts since early 2020. Enhanced unemployment benefits, in particular, resulted in 68% of claimants earning more on unemployment than they did in their previous jobs.
The Chamber’s survey indicated that 23% of women cited sufficient income from other family members and reduced financial necessity to work full-time as reasons for not re-entering the workforce. Higher savings and household income provided a financial buffer for some individuals, allowing them to remain outside the labor force for longer. However, rising inflation is now eroding these savings, potentially necessitating a return to the workforce for many, a factor that might influence future job market dynamics in contrast to the situation in 2023.
The Great Reshuffle: A Dynamic Labor Market
While the term “Great Resignation” captured the initial wave of workforce shifts, a more accurate description of the ongoing labor market dynamics is the “Great Reshuffle.” In 2023, over 44 million Americans voluntarily quit their jobs, and January 2024 alone saw 3.4 million quits. However, crucially, the hiring rate has consistently outpaced the quit rate since November 2020.
This indicates that while workers are leaving their jobs in large numbers, they are also actively seeking and finding better opportunities in new roles, with different employers, and across various industries. This “reshuffling” of the workforce highlights a dynamic job market where workers are pursuing improved conditions and career advancement, a trend that has intensified since 2020.
Understanding these multifaceted reasons behind the labor shortage is crucial for developing effective solutions. Addressing the gap between job openings and available workers requires comprehensive strategies to attract and retain individuals in the workforce. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce is actively driving such solutions through the America Works Initiative. For further information about this initiative, please contact Stephanie Ferguson at [email protected].
About the Author:
Stephanie Ferguson Melhorn is the Senior Director of Workforce & International Labor Policy at the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. Her expertise on the labor shortage is widely recognized, with citations in prominent publications such as the Wall Street Journal, Washington Post, and Associated Press.
Read more about Stephanie Ferguson
