Don Edwards vs. Benjamin Moore paint compare reveals which brand offers the best quality, value, and selection for your next painting project. At COMPARE.EDU.VN, we provide an in-depth analysis to help you make the right choice. Discover the key differences in paint quality and brand reputation for informed decision-making.
1. Understanding the Basics of Don Edwards and Benjamin Moore
Before diving into a detailed comparison, let’s get acquainted with these two prominent paint brands. Don Edwards Paint, known for its regional presence and focus on Western US climates, has built a reputation for quality and durability. Benjamin Moore, on the other hand, boasts a wider availability and a long-standing legacy in the paint industry.
1.1. A Brief Overview of Don Edwards Paint
Don Edwards is recognized for its high-performance coatings tailored to withstand the rigors of the southwestern environment. The company emphasizes innovation and quality, particularly in its exterior paints designed to resist fading and cracking under intense sunlight. They have a professional line that is designed for those that want high-quality paint for large commercial jobs.
1.2. A Brief Overview of Benjamin Moore Paint
Benjamin Moore is a well-established brand renowned for its extensive color selection, exceptional quality, and innovative technologies. They offer a wide range of paints suitable for various applications, from interior walls to exterior surfaces, and are known for their durability and color accuracy. Benjamin Moore is sold at independent retailers and ACE Hardware.
2. Paint Line Comparison: Don Edwards vs. Benjamin Moore
Both Don Edwards and Benjamin Moore offer a variety of paint lines catering to different needs and budgets. Understanding these lines is crucial in determining which brand is the better fit for your project.
2.1. Don Edwards Paint Lines: A Detailed Look
Don Edwards offers several paint lines with their own characteristics.
2.1.1. Exquisite
Exquisite is Dunn-Edwards’ top-tier interior paint, comparable to Benjamin Moore’s Aura, known for its ChromaStay Technology, making it washable and resistant to stains, scuffs, and fading. This matte-finish paint is suitable for high-end projects prioritizing low VOCs, priced at $78.50 per gallon.
2.1.2. Everest
Everest, an ultra-premium interior paint line, boasts low odor, zero VOCs, and self-priming properties. It excels in flow, leveling, and resistance to sagging and blocking, making it a competitor to Benjamin Moore’s Regal Select. Available in four finishes, it starts at $67 per gallon.
2.1.3. Suprema
Suprema, another ultra-premium interior option, is an ultra-low VOC acrylic latex paint known for its exceptional hide and durability. Available in five finishes, it provides a more affordable choice at $60.50 per gallon.
2.1.4. Aristoshield
Aristoshield is available in interior and exterior versions, providing an oil-like finish suitable for doors, trim, cabinets, and metal surfaces. It can be applied directly to metal when properly prepared.
2.1.5. Spartawall
Spartawall is a premium indoor acrylic paint known for its ease of application and extremely low odor. It offers high durability, maintaining its original appearance for longer, and is available in five finishes.
2.1.6. Evershield
Evershield is an exterior paint line designed for properly prepared masonry, concrete, stucco, wood, and exterior metal. It offers excellent UV color fade prevention, mildew resistance, and protection against water intrusion and peeling, available in a variety of finishes starting at $72 per gallon.
2.1.7. Spartashield
Spartashield, designed for exterior use, is a 100% acrylic paint that offers self-leveling and sag resistance for easy application. Featuring the most finish options of any Dunn-Edwards product, it is available in six sheen levels.
2.2. Benjamin Moore Paint Lines: A Comprehensive Analysis
Benjamin Moore is a top brand offering many different types of paint.
2.2.1. Aura
Benjamin Moore’s premium Aura line contains proprietary Color Lock technology, offering superior contact and rubbing resistance. With the highest volume solids, it justifies its premium price of $99 per gallon.
2.2.2. Regal Select
Regal Select is Benjamin Moore’s best-selling line, available for both interior and exterior use, and known for its durability. Ideal for high-traffic areas, it features stain-release technology for easy cleaning and is available in a wide range of finishes.
2.2.3. ben
Benjamin Moore’s user-friendly ben line offers extended open time, allowing for easier application without worrying about the paint drying too quickly. It is self-priming, zero-VOC, and the most affordable option, starting at $53 per gallon.
2.2.4. Advance
Advance provides high coverage, low VOCs, and a hard furniture finish for both indoor and outdoor projects. It comes in a selection of sheens for interior applications and a high-gloss option for exterior projects.
2.3. Side-by-Side Comparison Table: Paint Lines
| Feature | Don Edwards | Benjamin Moore |
|---|---|---|
| Premium Line | Exquisite | Aura |
| Best-Selling Line | N/A | Regal Select |
| Budget-Friendly | Spartawall | ben |
| Specialty | Aristoshield (Interior/Exterior), Evershield (Exterior), Spartashield (Exterior) | Advance (Furniture Finish), Floor & Patio Latex Enamel (Floors and Patios), INSL-X Cabinet Coat (Cabinets) |
3. Performance Metrics: Coverage, Durability, and Finish
The performance of paint is determined by coverage, durability, and finish. Let’s see how Don Edwards and Benjamin Moore compare in these critical areas.
3.1. Coverage Comparison
Coverage refers to the ability of a paint to obscure the underlying surface. A paint with good coverage requires fewer coats, saving time and money.
3.1.1. Don Edwards Coverage
Don Edwards paints are known for their good coverage. Specifically, their exquisite series gets very high marks.
3.1.2. Benjamin Moore Coverage
Benjamin Moore is known for having excellent coverage. Regal Select is the most known paint line and has great coverage for a reasonable price.
3.2. Durability Analysis
Durability is how well a paint resists wear and tear, including scratches, scuffs, and stains.
3.2.1. Don Edwards Durability
Dunn Edwards’ durability is very high, with their paints designed to handle UV rays and extreme temperature fluctuations.
3.2.2. Benjamin Moore Durability
Benjamin Moore is well known for being durable. The brand has a great reputation and many reviews from customers that say that the durability is top-notch.
3.3. Finish Options
The finish affects the appearance and functionality of the painted surface, influencing its sheen, texture, and cleanability.
3.3.1. Don Edwards Finishes
Don Edwards offers a wide range of finishes, including matte, eggshell, satin, semi-gloss, and high-gloss, allowing you to achieve the desired look and performance for your project.
3.3.2. Benjamin Moore Finishes
Benjamin Moore also provides an extensive selection of finishes, from flat to high-gloss, ensuring you find the perfect sheen level to complement your design preferences.
3.4. Side-by-Side Comparison Table: Performance
| Feature | Don Edwards | Benjamin Moore |
|---|---|---|
| Coverage | Excellent coverage in most lines | Excellent coverage in most lines |
| Durability | High resistance to wear and tear, UV fade resistant | High resistance to wear and tear |
| Finishes | Matte, Eggshell, Satin, Semi-Gloss, High-Gloss | Flat, Matte, Eggshell, Satin, Semi-Gloss, High-Gloss |
4. Environmental Impact: VOC Content
Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs) are chemicals emitted by paints that can affect indoor air quality and human health.
4.1. Don Edwards VOC Levels
Don Edwards offers several low-VOC and zero-VOC paint options, including the Everest line, aligning with the growing demand for eco-friendly paints.
4.2. Benjamin Moore VOC Levels
Benjamin Moore is committed to reducing VOC emissions, providing zero-VOC options like Aura and ben, and low-VOC alternatives across its product range.
4.3. Comparison Table: VOC Content
| Paint Line | Don Edwards VOC (g/L) | Benjamin Moore VOC (g/L) |
|---|---|---|
| Premium Line | Exquisite: 50 | Aura: 0 |
| Budget-Friendly | Spartawall: 15 | ben: 0 |
5. Color Selection and Matching
Color is a critical aspect of any painting project.
5.1. Don Edwards Color Options
Don Edwards offers a wide variety of colors, allowing customers to choose the perfect hue for their desired look.
5.2. Benjamin Moore Color Options
Benjamin Moore offers an impressive selection of over 3,500 colors, providing customers with endless possibilities to create their desired aesthetic.
5.3. Color Matching Technology
5.3.1. Don Edwards Color Matching
Don Edwards offers the InstaColor iD, a handheld tool that pairs with the mobile app ColorReader to match the exact color of a surface.
5.3.2. Benjamin Moore Color Matching
Benjamin Moore offers a mobile app that helps compare colors in the store or on the go.
5.4. Side-by-Side Comparison Table: Color Selection
| Feature | Don Edwards | Benjamin Moore |
|---|---|---|
| Number of Colors | Over 2,000 | Over 3,500 |
| Color Matching Tools | InstaColor iD | Mobile App |
6. Availability and Distribution
Availability and distribution influence how easy it is to purchase each brand’s products.
6.1. Don Edwards Availability
Don Edwards is a regional brand with stores in select states, including Arizona, California, Nevada, and Texas.
6.2. Benjamin Moore Availability
Benjamin Moore is widely available across the United States, with 7,500 independently-owned paint and hardware stores, including ACE Hardware.
6.3. Side-by-Side Comparison Table: Availability
| Feature | Don Edwards | Benjamin Moore |
|---|---|---|
| Store Locations | Select States | All 50 States |
| Retail Partners | Company Stores, Dealers | Independent Stores, ACE Hardware |
7. Pricing Analysis
The cost of paint is a significant consideration for any project.
7.1. Don Edwards Pricing
Don Edwards is typically a bit more affordable than Benjamin Moore overall, but prices can fluctuate by line.
7.2. Benjamin Moore Pricing
Benjamin Moore offers a range of prices, with Aura being its most expensive line and ben being the most affordable.
7.3. Comparison Table: Pricing (Per Gallon)
| Paint Line | Don Edwards Price | Benjamin Moore Price |
|---|---|---|
| Premium Line | $78.50 | $89.99 |
| Budget Line | $54.50 | $46.99 |
8. Expert and Customer Reviews
What do the experts and customers say?
8.1. Don Edwards: Pros and Cons
8.1.1. Pros of Don Edwards
- High-quality products
- Good customer service
- Formulated for UV fade protection
- Withstands hot climates
8.1.2. Cons of Don Edwards
- Fewer color selections
- Negative reviews for peeling and fading
- Limited distribution
8.2. Benjamin Moore: Pros and Cons
8.2.1. Pros of Benjamin Moore
- Excellent coverage
- Good durability
- Wide availability
- Trusted brand
8.2.2. Cons of Benjamin Moore
- More expensive than other brands
- Semi-gloss is greater than 50 g/l
8.3. What the Experts Say
- Benjamin Moore Regal Select: Best Interior Paint – The New York Times Wirecutter
- Benjamin Moore Aura Paint: Best Color Selection – The Spruce
- Benjamin Moore: Best Interior Paint Brand – J.D. Power Paint Satisfaction Survey
9. Making the Right Choice: Which Brand Is Best for You?
Deciding between Don Edwards and Benjamin Moore depends on your specific needs, location, and budget.
9.1. Factors to Consider
- Availability: Benjamin Moore is more accessible if you live outside the Western US.
- Budget: Don Edwards is generally more affordable.
- Color Selection: Benjamin Moore offers a broader range of colors.
- Environmental Concerns: Both brands offer low-VOC and zero-VOC options.
9.2. Final Recommendations
- Choose Benjamin Moore if you want a wide color selection and don’t mind spending a bit more.
- Choose Don Edwards if you need high-quality paint that can withstand hot, dry climates and want to save money.
10. Conclusion: Don Edwards vs. Benjamin Moore Paint Compare
Both Don Edwards and Benjamin Moore are excellent paint brands with their own strengths and weaknesses. Your decision should be based on your specific needs and preferences. Whether you prioritize a wide color selection, eco-friendly options, or affordability, both brands offer quality products that can enhance the beauty and durability of your home.
Making an informed choice is easy with COMPARE.EDU.VN. We aim to provide detailed comparisons so that our users can make the best decision.
Ready to make your choice? Visit COMPARE.EDU.VN to explore more comparisons and find the perfect solution for your needs. Our comprehensive guides and reviews help you navigate the decision-making process with confidence.
For more information, contact us at:
Address: 333 Comparison Plaza, Choice City, CA 90210, United States
Whatsapp: +1 (626) 555-9090
Website: compare.edu.vn
11. FAQs: Don Edwards vs. Benjamin Moore Paint
11.1. Is Don Edwards paint good quality?
Yes, Don Edwards paint is known for its high quality, especially its ability to withstand harsh weather conditions.
11.2. Is Benjamin Moore paint worth the extra cost?
Many users believe that Benjamin Moore’s superior coverage, durability, and color selection justify the higher price.
11.3. Which brand offers more eco-friendly options?
Both Don Edwards and Benjamin Moore offer low-VOC and zero-VOC paint options.
11.4. Where can I buy Don Edwards paint?
Don Edwards paint is available at company stores and dealers in select states, including Arizona, California, Nevada, and Texas.
11.5. Where can I buy Benjamin Moore paint?
Benjamin Moore paint is available at 7,500 independently-owned paint and hardware stores across the United States, including ACE Hardware.
11.6. Does Don Edwards or Benjamin Moore have better color matching technology?
Benjamin Moore has a more advanced color-matching mobile app.
11.7. Which brand is better for exterior projects?
Both brands offer excellent exterior paints, but Don Edwards is specially formulated to withstand UV fade and hot climates.
11.8. Are there any specific paint lines recommended for high-traffic areas?
Benjamin Moore’s Regal Select is recommended for high-traffic areas due to its durability and stain resistance.
11.9. What are the key differences in the application process between the two brands?
The application process is similar for both brands, but Benjamin Moore’s ben line is known for its user-friendly application with extended open time.
11.10. How do customer reviews compare between Don Edwards and Benjamin Moore?
Benjamin Moore generally receives more positive reviews and accolades from professional painters and media outlets.
