Choosing the right paint for your project can be overwhelming. Two popular brands often considered are Valspar and Sherwin-Williams. This article compares these two paint giants to help you decide which is best for your needs.
Valspar vs. Sherwin-Williams: A Detailed Comparison
We’ve analyzed expert opinions, customer reviews, and product information to compare Valspar and Sherwin-Williams paints based on price, quality, accessibility, and customer satisfaction.
Price: Valspar Offers Budget-Friendly Options
Valspar generally offers more budget-friendly paint options compared to Sherwin-Williams. While price differences can vary depending on the specific product line, Valspar consistently positions itself as a more affordable choice for budget-conscious consumers.
Quality and Performance: Sherwin-Williams Known for Premium Quality
Sherwin-Williams is widely regarded as a premium paint brand, known for its thicker, more pigmented formulas. While often requiring fewer coats and offering superior durability, this quality comes at a higher price point. Industry experts often cite Sherwin-Williams paints as being more chip- and scratch-resistant and providing better overall coverage.
Accessibility: Valspar Widely Available at Lowe’s and Independent Retailers
Valspar paints are readily available at Lowe’s and various independent retailers nationwide, making them easily accessible to most consumers. This widespread availability, coupled with online ordering and shipping options, offers convenience for those seeking readily accessible paint solutions.
Sherwin-Williams primarily sells its products through company-owned stores, although its HGTV Home line is available at Lowe’s. While Sherwin-Williams stores offer expert advice, their limited distribution may require some consumers to travel further for purchases.
Customer Satisfaction: Sherwin-Williams Consistently Ranks Higher
Sherwin-Williams consistently outperforms Valspar in customer satisfaction surveys, including the J.D. Power U.S. Paint Satisfaction Study and the America’s Most Trusted study. This suggests a higher level of overall satisfaction with Sherwin-Williams products and customer service.
The Verdict: Sherwin-Williams Edges Out Valspar
While Valspar offers budget-friendly options and wider accessibility, Sherwin-Williams generally provides superior quality, performance, and customer satisfaction. If budget is a primary concern, Valspar offers viable alternatives. However, for those prioritizing durability, coverage, and overall performance, Sherwin-Williams remains the preferred choice. Ultimately, the best choice depends on individual project needs and budget constraints.
