Sinéad O’Connor’s powerful rendition of “Nothing Compares 2 U” is an unforgettable classic. But did Prince, the song’s writer, ever record his own version? This article delves into the surprising origins of the song, O’Connor’s transformative interpretation, and the complex relationship between the two artists.
O’Connor’s 1990 release of “Nothing Compares 2 U” catapulted her to international fame. The raw emotion and vulnerability in her voice resonated deeply with audiences, making it a defining song of the decade. However, many are surprised to learn that the song wasn’t originally hers. Prince penned “Nothing Compares 2 U” in 1984 and initially gave it to a side project, The Family, featuring Paul Peterson (St. Paul) on vocals. While a solid performance, The Family’s version remained relatively obscure.
O’Connor’s recording transformed the song. Her shaved head, the stark black and white video, and her tearful performance created an unforgettable visual and emotional experience. She infused the song with a personal pain, reportedly connecting it to her own mother’s death, giving it a depth and rawness that resonated universally. This interpretation turned a relatively unknown Prince track into a global phenomenon, forever linked to O’Connor’s powerful delivery. It topped charts worldwide and solidified her status as a musical force.
But the story doesn’t end there. The relationship between Prince and O’Connor surrounding the song was complex and reportedly fraught with tension. O’Connor herself recounted a disturbing encounter with Prince, alleging physical threats and a hostile environment. While the details remain contested, this complicated history adds another layer to the song’s legacy.
Years after both artists passed away, Prince’s original studio recording of “Nothing Compares 2 U,” recorded in 1984, was finally released. This version offers a fascinating glimpse into the song’s evolution and showcases Prince’s unique vocal stylings and musicality. While undeniably Prince, it lacks the raw emotional power that O’Connor brought to her rendition.
Ultimately, both versions of “Nothing Compares 2 U” hold their own place in music history. Prince’s original demonstrates his songwriting genius, while O’Connor’s transforms it into a timeless anthem of heartbreak and loss. Though the song originated with Prince, it was O’Connor who truly made it her own, forever etching her voice and image into the song’s DNA. The question of who sang it better remains subjective, but there’s no denying the profound impact of both artists on this iconic piece of music.
