Choosing the right smartwatch for running can feel overwhelming. It seems like every runner has a different device on their wrist, and figuring out what works best for you requires sifting through a ton of information. If you’re like me and prefer an all-day wearable that also tracks your workouts without being overly focused on data logging, a smartwatch might be the perfect solution. I’ve tested a few smartwatches over the years, and I wanted to share my experiences to help you decide which one might be the best fit for your running needs.
Apple Watch Series 2
I initially got the Apple Watch Series 2 with the intention of wearing it constantly. For a while, I did. As someone who isn’t naturally inclined to wear watches, I adapted to it, primarily because I needed it for work. Managing a cycling team meant race weekends were hectic, and the Apple Watch was invaluable for quickly checking messages and emails without constantly pulling out my phone. However, once I transitioned away from that role, the constant notifications became more of a distraction than a necessity. The battery life also became a sticking point. Requiring nightly charging, it often ended up dead due to my forgetfulness.
Despite these drawbacks for everyday wear, I still use the Series 2 as my dedicated running watch. Since I hadn’t invested in a watch specifically for running, the Apple Watch, with Strava compatibility and decent heart rate monitoring, served its purpose. Ideally, though, I would prefer a watch that pairs with a heart rate strap for more accurate data.
Pros: For those deeply embedded in the Apple ecosystem and seeking a smartwatch first and foremost with running capabilities, the Apple Watch Series 2 is a solid option. Its current affordability, significantly lower than its original price, makes it an attractive entry point into the smartwatch market.
Cons: Battery life can be limiting, and heart rate monitoring might not satisfy runners seeking precise data. It leans more towards smartwatch functionality than dedicated running features.
In essence, while the Apple Watch Series 2 is capable, I realized I needed something simpler, more focused on running, with reliable notifications.
Image alt text: Refurbished Apple Watch Series 2 Space Gray Stainless Steel Case showcasing its sleek design.
Samsung Galaxy Watch
The Samsung Galaxy Watch is undeniably stylish. During my month-long review for MapMyRun, it consistently drew compliments. It doesn’t scream “running watch” or even “smartwatch”; it genuinely resembles a sophisticated analog timepiece, especially the rose gold version I tested.
Beyond aesthetics, the Galaxy Watch impressed me with its health app and run tracking features. I was surprised by how much I enjoyed wearing a more substantial watch daily. While the band might benefit from a swap for a better training-to-everyday balance, its functionality was excellent. Smartwatch features thrived on Android (I used an older Android phone for testing before switching to the compatible Apple app). iPhone users might experience some feature limitations, but for Samsung users, this watch could potentially surpass the Apple Watch in overall satisfaction.
Pros: Stunning design, robust health and fitness tracking, strong performance within the Android ecosystem, and a premium feel.
Cons: Some functionality is reduced when paired with iPhones, and finding a versatile band for both training and daily wear can be challenging.
Image alt text: Samsung Galaxy Smartwatch Rose Gold variant, highlighting its elegant and classic watch appearance.
Garmin Forerunner 35
The Garmin Forerunner 35, with its Apple Watch-esque design but more streamlined approach, initially seemed like a promising option for me. The longer battery life compared to my Apple Watch was a major draw. My hesitation stemmed from already owning the Apple Watch Series 2. However, the Forerunner 35’s inability to pair with a heart rate strap or bike power meter on the bike with the Apple Watch made it less than ideal. Ironically, the Apple Watch felt too feature-rich for my current needs!
However (in 2020, and in retrospect), I must strongly recommend the Garmin Forerunner 35. It strikes a fantastic balance for runners who want reliable tracking without excessive bells and whistles.
Pros: Excellent battery life, dedicated running features, simpler interface, and a focus on essential metrics. Often available at a more budget-friendly price point.
Cons: Less comprehensive smartwatch features compared to Apple Watch or Samsung Galaxy Watch.
Image alt text: Garmin Forerunner 35 Black running watch, showcasing its sporty and functional design for runners.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the “best” smartwatch for running is subjective and depends on your priorities. If you prioritize smartwatch capabilities and are within the Apple ecosystem, the Apple Watch (even an older Series 2 if budget is a concern) is a capable choice. Android users seeking style and robust features might lean towards the Samsung Galaxy Watch. For runners who value battery life, essential running metrics, and a simpler, more focused experience, the Garmin Forerunner 35 is a standout recommendation. Consider what you need most in a wearable – smartwatch versatility or dedicated running functionality – to make the right decision for your runs.
