What Toyota Is Comparable To Honda Pilot? The Toyota Grand Highlander is comparable to the Honda Pilot, offering similar three-row seating and spaciousness, but the choice depends on your priorities, which can be simplified by COMPARE.EDU.VN. If fuel efficiency and value are key, the Toyota Highlander or Grand Highlander Hybrid are excellent choices, while the Honda Pilot shines with its rugged design and off-road capabilities with comparable safety ratings.
1. Honda Pilot vs. Toyota Highlander: Price and Trims
Choosing between the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander models involves understanding their pricing and available trims. These factors significantly influence the overall value and features you’ll receive.
- Base Pilot Sport: Approximately $41,500
- Base Toyota Highlander LE: Around $40,500
- Base Grand Highlander XLE: About $46,500
- Top Picks: Honda Pilot EX-L for $45,000; Toyota Grand Highlander XLE
The Toyota Highlander provides an edge in terms of base model pricing, offering a slightly more affordable entry point compared to the Honda Pilot. However, the Grand Highlander XLE presents a more upscale option, reflecting its enhanced features and larger size. For balanced value, the Honda Pilot EX-L and Toyota Grand Highlander XLE are recommended.
2. Which Toyota Highlander Should You Buy?
Deciding which Toyota Highlander model to purchase involves considering the standard Highlander and the Grand Highlander. Each caters to different needs and preferences.
2.1. Understanding the Two Models
The standard Highlander closely resembles the Sienna minivan, but lacks sliding doors. The Grand Highlander is 6.5 inches longer, venturing into Lexus territory with enhanced appointments and a higher price.
2.2. Highlander as a Value Play
The Highlander presents better value against the Grand Highlander and Pilot, especially in its hybrid form. The base Highlander LE, priced at $40,515 (including destination fee), accommodates eight passengers and features an 8.0-inch touchscreen with wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. It also includes a power driver seat, a power tailgate, cloth upholstery, and advanced active safety features. Toyota supports the Highlander with a 3-year/36,000-mile warranty, plus two years or 25,000 miles of scheduled service.
2.3. Options and Upgrades
Adding all-wheel drive to the Highlander costs $1,600, while the hybrid option incurs an additional $1,600. The $42,115 Highlander LE Hybrid is a strong choice for optimal value and low ownership costs. Available trims include Nightshade, XSE, XLE, XLE Nightshade, Limited, and Platinum, with the latter costing $54,520 for an all-wheel-drive hybrid.
2.4. Considering the Grand Highlander
For approximately $500 more than the top-tier Highlander, the Grand Highlander offers significantly more space and features. The XLE trim, priced at $45,265 as a Highlander Hybrid AWD or $1,150 more as a Grand Highlander, bundles desirable features like a 12.3-inch touchscreen, wireless smartphone charger, heated synthetic leather power front seats, and a panoramic sunroof. A more powerful hybrid powertrain option for the Grand Highlander, nearing $60,000 in Platinum trim, may be excessive for many Highlander shoppers.
2.5. Recommendation
Opt for the Grand Highlander to leverage its added size and enhanced features, providing a more luxurious experience.
3. Which Honda Pilot Should You Buy?
Selecting the right Honda Pilot involves assessing the various trim levels and their respective features to match your needs.
3.1. Base Model Features
The Pilot Sport starts at $41,295, including a $1,395 destination fee, and includes seating for eight, heated and power-adjustable front seats, and four USB ports. It features a 7.0-inch touchscreen with wired Android and Apple smartphone compatibility, and rides on 20-inch black wheels. Honda’s 3-year/36,000-mile warranty does not include scheduled maintenance.
3.2. Value Comparison
Toyota offers better value in its base model and all-wheel-drive upgrade options. All-wheel drive costs an additional $2,100 on the Pilot, except for the TrailSport ($50,495), Elite ($54,175), and Black Edition ($55,675) trims, where it comes standard.
3.3. EX-L Trim Benefits
The $44,595 Pilot EX-L offers the best value, featuring leather upholstery, wireless smartphone charging, a 9.0-inch touchscreen, and a power tailgate. For an additional $300, the middle bench seat can be replaced with captain’s chairs.
3.4. Recommendation
Consider the Pilot EX-L for its balanced features and value, but note that the Toyota Highlander offers a better overall value proposition. Leaning towards the Grand Highlander Hybrid XLE AWD is a strategic choice for enhanced features and performance.
3.5. Overall Advantage
Toyota Highlander offers better value overall, particularly with the Grand Highlander Hybrid XLE AWD.
4. Highlander vs. Pilot: Interior and Exterior Design
Comparing the interior and exterior designs of the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander reveals distinct styling approaches and functional priorities.
4.1. Design Overview
- The Pilot features a somewhat retro aesthetic
- The Highlander offers two distinct body styles
- The Pilot lacks the Highlander’s large touchscreen, which some may find appealing
4.2. Toyota Highlander’s Appearance
The standard Highlander sports a body bulge over the rear fender, akin to the Sienna minivan, and features assertive upper and lower grilles. The Grand Highlander, longer and wider, exudes sophistication with smooth body sides, boxy fenders, and a calmer front fascia, resembling Lexus styling.
4.3. Interior Design and Features
Inside, both models emphasize practical storage, including a passenger shelf for smartphones above the glove box. The Grand Highlander offers an open bridge console for added storage and an electronic gear shifter that saves space compared to the mechanical shifter in the Highlander. Both can be equipped with a dominant 12.3-inch touchscreen.
4.4. Honda Pilot’s Design
The Honda Pilot adopts a rugged, retro style, standing out in its segment with a honeycomb grille, wedgy LED headlights, and C-shaped air intakes. Beefy fenders blend into the grille, leading to upturned rear pillars reminiscent of the original Honda Passport and Isuzu Rodeo. The TrailSport trim includes all-terrain tires on 18-inch wheels and roof rails.
4.5. Interior Design Elements
The Pilot’s interior design is cleaner and more subdued than the Highlander’s, with a maximum touchscreen size of 9.0 inches. Honda incorporates physical buttons and knobs for audio and climate controls. Pockets for smartphones, a wireless charging pad, and twin-needle stitching enhance the interior.
4.6. Design Advantage
Pilot TrailSport > Grand Highlander > Pilot > Highlander. The Pilot TrailSport’s rugged design and enhanced features give it an edge, followed by the Grand Highlander’s sophisticated styling.
5. Pilot vs. Highlander: Size, Seating Comfort, and Cargo Capacity
When comparing the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander, size, seating comfort, and cargo capacity are key factors to consider for passenger and storage needs.
5.1. Key Considerations
- All three models offer three rows of seats, accommodating up to eight passengers
- The Grand Highlander provides the most spacious interior
- The Pilot’s removable middle seat adds flexibility
5.2. Passenger Space
If size is a priority, the Grand Highlander leads with its spaciousness. However, the Honda Pilot offers better slide and fold flexibility, a removable middle seat in the second row, and easier folding of second- and third-row seats. All models feature three seats in the third row.
5.3. Toyota Highlander Dimensions
- Grand Highlander: 201.4 inches long, 116.1-inch wheelbase
- Highlander: 194.9 inches long, 112.2-inch wheelbase
- Grand Highlander cargo: 20.6 cu ft (behind 3rd row), 57.9 cu ft (behind 2nd row), 97.5 cu ft (both rows flat)
- Highlander cargo: 16.0/48.4/84.3 cu ft
5.4. Interior Space Comparison
The primary distinction between the Highlander and Grand Highlander is interior space. Both seat eight, but the Grand Highlander features standard captain’s chairs (with a mid-row bench option at no extra cost). Second-row legroom is similar (41 inches in Highlander, 39.5 inches in Grand Highlander), but third-row legroom is more significant (33.5 inches in Grand Highlander vs. 27.7 inches in Highlander).
5.5. Seating Comfort Details
In both hybrid and gas models, second-row seats sit approximately four inches higher than the floor, affecting third-row comfort. Third-row passengers may experience discomfort on long trips due to elevated knees.
5.6. Folding Mechanisms
Pull straps in the cargo area simplify folding the 60/40-split third row, while the latches on the second-row seats may be challenging for smaller users, unlike the Pilot’s push-button operation.
5.7. Honda Pilot Dimensions
- Honda Pilot: 199.9 inches long, 113.8-inch wheelbase
- Cargo: 18.6/48.5/87.0 cu ft
- Second-row legroom: 40.8 inches
- Third-row legroom: 32.5 inches
5.8. Passenger and Storage Details
The Pilot accommodates up to eight passengers and some luggage. It’s not as large as the Grand Highlander but provides more room than the standard Highlander. Front seats are supportive with power adjustments, lumbar support, and heating (except base version). Leather upholstery and wireless smartphone chargers are available. Like the Highlander, the Pilot includes a smartphone and sunglasses storage shelf in front of the passenger.
5.9. Second-Row Configuration
The Pilot’s second row offers a three-section bench seat, with optional captain’s chairs on EX-L trims and above. Touring and Elite versions have a removable middle seat that can be stowed in the cargo floor. This 25-pound seat offers an alternate entrance to the rear.
5.10. Third-Row Comfort
Two 6-foot passengers can fit in the third row with decent headroom and 32.5 inches of legroom.
5.11. Size and Comfort Advantage
Grand Highlander excels in overall size and passenger comfort, making it the preferred choice for those prioritizing space.
6. Toyota Highlander vs. Honda Pilot: Towing, Off-Road, and Performance
When assessing the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander, towing capacity, off-road capabilities, and overall performance are crucial considerations.
6.1. Performance Specifications
- Highlander: Three engine options, including two hybrid choices
- Pilot: 285-hp V-6, 262 lb-ft of torque
- Towing capacity: Max 5,000 pounds (both models)
6.2. Honda Pilot Performance Details
Front-wheel drive is standard on Sport, EX-L, and Touring trims, with all-wheel drive available (standard on TrailSport, Elite, and Black Edition). The all-wheel-drive system splits torque between front and rear wheels, enhancing power delivery. The Pilot TrailSport features hill descent control and all-terrain tires for off-road capability.
6.3. Engine and Transmission
A revamped 3.5-liter V-6 produces 285 hp and 262 lb-ft, paired with a seamless 10-speed automatic transmission. Expect a 0-60 mph time of under seven seconds. Downshifts can be jumpy in Sport mode. The Pilot’s steering feels responsive, even on base 18-inch all-season tires, providing a comfortable ride.
6.4. Toyota Highlander Drivetrain
The Highlander and Grand Highlander come standard with front-wheel drive, while the Grand Highlander Hybrid Max has standard all-wheel drive. The basic setup sends half the power to the rear wheels when slippage occurs. Limited and Platinum gas Highlanders have torque vectoring across the rear axle. Hybrid models with AWD add a third motor powering the rear axle.
6.5. Hybrid System Details
The Grand Highlander’s exclusive hybrid powertrain uses a full-time all-wheel-drive system, adjusting torque based on driver inputs and modes. Sport mode enhances rear axle torque for better takeoff, while Snow or Rock & Dirt modes distribute low-speed torque more evenly for traction.
6.6. Toyota Highlander Speed and Performance
Performance varies. The 2.5-liter inline-4 hybrid with two front motor generators is the slowest but most efficient, producing 243 hp and 175 lb-ft, reaching 60 mph in 7.9 seconds. It can operate in EV mode up to 15 mph, but may strain uphill. Towing is limited to 3,500 pounds.
6.7. Turbo-4 Engine Performance
Base versions share a 2.4-liter turbo-4 producing 265 hp and 310 lb-ft. In the Grand Highlander, 0-60 mph is 7.5 seconds. Paired with an 8-speed automatic in front- or all-wheel drive, it delivers robust torque for passing.
6.8. Hybrid Max Powertrain
The Hybrid Max combines the 2.4-liter turbo-4 with two motors, supplementing power to the front and rear axles via a 6-speed automatic transmission and a mechanical driveshaft. Producing 362 hp and 400 lb-ft, it achieves 0-60 mph in 6.3 seconds.
6.9. Performance Advantage
Draw. The Pilot offers smoother performance, but the Grand Highlander provides significantly more power.
7. Honda Pilot vs. Highlander: Fuel Economy
When comparing the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander, fuel economy is a significant factor, impacting long-term ownership costs.
7.1. Fuel Efficiency Ratings
- Highlander Hybrid: Up to 36 mpg combined (35 mpg with AWD)
- Grand Highlander Hybrid: 34 mpg combined
- Grand Highlander Hybrid Max: 27 mpg combined (aspired)
- Honda Pilot: Max 22 mpg combined
7.2. Toyota Highlander Fuel Efficiency
The Highlander is more efficient in every form. The base turbo-4 is rated at 22 mpg city, 29 highway, 25 combined with front-wheel drive, or 21/28/24 mpg in AWD.
7.3. Hybrid Efficiency
In hybrid form, the Highlander is the most efficient three-row crossover without a plug. Front-wheel-drive hybrids earn EPA ratings of 36/35/36 mpg, or 35/35/35 mpg with all-wheel drive. The larger Grand Highlander rates at 36/32/34 mpg, regardless of FWD or AWD.
7.4. Hybrid Max Performance
The Grand Highlander Hybrid Max, with standard AWD, achieves 26/27/27 mpg. However, testing suggests real-world performance aligns more with the Highlander turbo-4.
7.5. Honda Pilot Fuel Efficiency
The Honda Pilot lags behind the Highlander, with EPA ratings of 19/27/22 mpg with FWD or 19/25/21 mpg with all-wheel drive. The TrailSport model with all-terrain tires rates at 20 mpg combined.
7.6. Fuel Economy Advantage
The Highlander consistently offers superior fuel economy across its various models.
8. Highlander vs. Pilot: Safety
When comparing the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander, safety ratings and features are critical considerations for peace of mind.
8.1. Safety Ratings
- All three models earn 5-star ratings from the NHTSA and a Top Safety Pick from the IIHS
- Standard driver-assist tech: Automatic emergency braking with pedestrian detection, active lane control, adaptive cruise control, blind-spot monitors
- Grand Highlander: Optional hands-free system for traffic jams
8.2. Advanced Safety Features
In addition to standard safety features, most Highlanders and Pilots offer upgrades such as parking sensors, a head-up display, and a surround-view camera system. The Grand Highlander features a limited hands-free driving system for stop-and-go traffic below 25 mph, available via subscription.
8.3. Safety Advantage
Both models offer comparable safety features and ratings, resulting in a draw.
9. Which Is Better: Honda Pilot or Toyota Highlander?
Deciding between the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander requires evaluating their strengths and weaknesses.
9.1. Overall Comparison
The tale of two Highlanders results in a split that sandwiches the Honda Pilot. The Grand Highlander’s larger size and roomier cabin stand above the standard Highlander, but the two hybrid options give both models an edge over the Honda Pilot, earning a TCC Rating of 7.0 out of 10.
9.2. Honda Pilot Assessment
Limited to just a V-6 option, the Pilot can’t match the efficient options of the Highlander, but it’s similarly well-equipped. The seats are more flexible, and the TrailSport model offers something lacking in the expansive Highlander lineup. It’s just a shade off, earning a TCC Rating of 6.8 out of 10. (Read more about how we rate cars.) It’s much better than the standard Highlander, which has not been updated since 2020.
9.3. Final Recommendation
The Toyota Grand Highlander emerges as the winner, offering superior features and performance.
10. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Here are some frequently asked questions to help you make an informed decision between the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander.
10.1. What Are the Key Differences Between the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander?
The Toyota Highlander offers better fuel efficiency and hybrid options, while the Honda Pilot provides a more rugged design and flexible seating configurations. The Grand Highlander offers more space and luxury compared to both.
10.2. Which Model Is More Fuel-Efficient?
The Toyota Highlander, especially in its hybrid form, is more fuel-efficient than the Honda Pilot.
10.3. Does the Honda Pilot Have Better Off-Road Capabilities?
Yes, the Honda Pilot TrailSport is specifically designed with enhanced off-road capabilities, including all-terrain tires and hill descent control.
10.4. Which Model Offers More Cargo Space?
The Toyota Grand Highlander offers the most cargo space, followed by the Honda Pilot. The standard Toyota Highlander has the least cargo space among the three.
10.5. What Are the Starting Prices for Each Model?
- Honda Pilot: Starting at around $41,500
- Toyota Highlander: Starting at around $40,500
- Toyota Grand Highlander: Starting at around $46,500
10.6. Which Model Has a Better Safety Rating?
Both the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander have excellent safety ratings, earning 5-star ratings from NHTSA and Top Safety Pick from IIHS.
10.7. What Are the Key Features of the Honda Pilot TrailSport?
The Honda Pilot TrailSport includes standard all-wheel drive, all-terrain tires, hill descent control, and unique styling elements for enhanced off-road performance.
10.8. Which Model Has a More Powerful Engine?
The Toyota Grand Highlander Hybrid Max has the most powerful engine, producing 362 hp and 400 lb-ft of torque.
10.9. What Are the Interior Highlights of Each Model?
- Honda Pilot: Flexible seating configurations and a removable middle seat option.
- Toyota Highlander: Smart storage spaces and available 12.3-inch touchscreen.
- Toyota Grand Highlander: More spacious cabin and luxurious appointments.
10.10. Where Can I Find More Detailed Comparisons?
For more detailed comparisons and expert reviews, visit COMPARE.EDU.VN to make an informed decision.
Making a decision between the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander can be challenging given their respective strengths. For a comprehensive comparison tailored to your specific needs, visit COMPARE.EDU.VN. We offer detailed side-by-side analyses, user reviews, and expert opinions to help you make the right choice. Don’t navigate this decision alone; let COMPARE.EDU.VN be your guide to automotive clarity.
Contact us for more information:
Address: 333 Comparison Plaza, Choice City, CA 90210, United States
WhatsApp: +1 (626) 555-9090
Website: compare.edu.vn
