Posted incompare

How Do You Compare Gene Sequences Effectively?

No Comments

Are you struggling to compare gene sequences to understand their relationships and functions? COMPARE.EDU.VN provides a comprehensive guide on How To Compare Gene Sequences effectively. This guide will delve into sequence alignment techniques, translation considerations, and tools available for accurate analysis, ultimately helping you make informed decisions based on genetic information. Explore different sequence alignment methods and discover insights into genomic analysis and comparative genomics.

1. What is Sequence Alignment and Why is it Important?

Sequence alignment is the process of arranging two or more sequences of DNA, RNA, or protein to identify regions of similarity that may be a consequence of functional, structural, or evolutionary relationships between the sequences. According to research from the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI), sequence alignment is a fundamental tool in bioinformatics. It is used to infer evolutionary relationships, predict protein structures, and identify conserved domains.

Sequence alignment is critical in:

  • Identifying Homologous Sequences: Determining if sequences share a common ancestor.
  • Predicting Protein Structure and Function: Similar sequences often have similar structures and functions.
  • Analyzing Evolutionary Relationships: Understanding how species have evolved over time.
  • Designing Primers for PCR: Ensuring specific amplification of target sequences.
  • Identifying Mutations and Variations: Detecting genetic differences that may cause disease.

2. What are the Basic Concepts of Sequence Alignment?

The foundation of sequence alignment rests on a few key concepts that govern how sequences are compared and scored. These include matches, mismatches, gaps, and scoring systems, each playing a crucial role in determining the quality and significance of an alignment.

2.1. Matches, Mismatches, and Gaps

  • Matches: Nucleotides or amino acids that are identical in aligned sequences. High numbers of matches indicate a strong similarity.
  • Mismatches: Nucleotides or amino acids that differ between aligned sequences. Mismatches suggest sequence divergence or mutations.
  • Gaps: Insertions or deletions (indels) in one sequence relative to another. Gaps are introduced to maximize the number of matches and reflect evolutionary events.

2.2. Scoring Systems

Scoring systems assign values to matches, mismatches, and gaps to quantify the quality of an alignment. These systems are essential for algorithms to determine the optimal alignment between sequences.

  • Match Scores: Positive values assigned to matching nucleotides or amino acids.
  • Mismatch Penalties: Negative values assigned to mismatched nucleotides or amino acids.
  • Gap Penalties: Negative values assigned for the introduction or extension of gaps. Gap penalties prevent excessive gap usage and ensure biologically meaningful alignments.

2.3. Common Scoring Matrices

Different scoring matrices are used based on the type of sequence being aligned (DNA or protein) and the evolutionary distance between the sequences.

  • For DNA: Simple match/mismatch scoring is often used. A common scheme assigns +1 for a match and -1 for a mismatch.
  • For Proteins: More complex matrices like BLOSUM (Blocks Substitution Matrix) and PAM (Point Accepted Mutation) are employed. These matrices consider the frequency of amino acid substitutions observed in related proteins.
    • BLOSUM matrices: Derived from conserved regions of protein families. BLOSUM62 is a widely used matrix that scores substitutions based on their observed frequencies.
    • PAM matrices: Based on evolutionary models, estimating the number of amino acid changes per 100 residues.

2.4. Penalties for Gaps

Penalties for gaps are crucial to prevent an alignment algorithm from introducing too many gaps, which could lead to biologically irrelevant results.

  • Gap Opening Penalty: The penalty for introducing a new gap.
  • Gap Extension Penalty: The penalty for extending an existing gap.

Using both gap opening and extension penalties helps to model the biological reality of insertions and deletions, where introducing a gap is more significant than extending one.

2.5. Types of Sequence Alignment

Sequence alignment can be broadly classified into two main types: global alignment and local alignment. Each type serves different purposes and is suitable for different scenarios depending on the sequences being compared and the research question being addressed.

2.5.1. Global Alignment

Global alignment aims to align the entire length of two sequences, from beginning to end. This method is best suited for sequences that are similar in length and have a high degree of similarity across their entire span. The Needleman-Wunsch algorithm is a classic example of a global alignment algorithm.

Key Characteristics of Global Alignment:

  • Full Length Comparison: Aligns the entire sequence from end to end.
  • Best Use Case: Suitable for highly similar sequences of similar length.
  • Algorithm Example: Needleman-Wunsch algorithm.

Example Scenario:

Consider aligning two closely related variants of the same gene from different individuals. Since the sequences are expected to be largely similar, a global alignment can effectively highlight any differences, such as single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) or small indels, across the entire gene.

2.5.2. Local Alignment

Local alignment focuses on finding the most similar regions within two sequences, regardless of the overall similarity of the entire sequences. This method is particularly useful when comparing sequences that are dissimilar overall but may contain conserved domains or motifs. The Smith-Waterman algorithm is a well-known local alignment algorithm.

Key Characteristics of Local Alignment:

  • Identifies Conserved Regions: Focuses on finding the most similar segments within sequences.
  • Best Use Case: Ideal for dissimilar sequences with conserved domains or motifs.
  • Algorithm Example: Smith-Waterman algorithm.

Example Scenario:

Imagine you are studying a protein that is part of a large family of proteins. While the overall sequences of these proteins may vary significantly, they often contain specific domains that are highly conserved due to their functional importance. Local alignment can help you identify these conserved domains, even if the proteins otherwise share little similarity.

2.5.3. Hybrid Approaches

In some cases, hybrid approaches that combine elements of both global and local alignment may be used to achieve more nuanced results. These methods adapt to the specific characteristics of the sequences being compared, providing a more flexible and comprehensive analysis.

Practical Implications:

  • Genomics: Identifying homologous regions in different genomes.
  • Proteomics: Finding conserved domains in protein families.
  • Drug Discovery: Aligning potential drug targets with known proteins.
  • Phylogenetics: Inferring evolutionary relationships between species.

3. What are the Common Algorithms for Sequence Alignment?

Several algorithms are used for sequence alignment, each with its own strengths and weaknesses. The choice of algorithm depends on the specific requirements of the analysis, such as the length of the sequences and the desired sensitivity.

3.1. Dynamic Programming Algorithms

Dynamic programming algorithms are guaranteed to find the optimal alignment between two sequences. The two main dynamic programming algorithms are the Needleman-Wunsch algorithm (for global alignment) and the Smith-Waterman algorithm (for local alignment).

3.1.1. Needleman-Wunsch Algorithm (Global Alignment)

The Needleman-Wunsch algorithm is used for global alignment, which aligns the entire length of two sequences. It is particularly useful when the sequences are similar in length and are expected to have high similarity across their entire length.

How it Works:

  1. Initialization: A matrix is created with dimensions (m+1) x (n+1), where m and n are the lengths of the two sequences. The first row and first column are initialized with gap penalties.

  2. Matrix Filling: The matrix is filled using the following recurrence relation:

    F(i, j) = max {
    F(i-1, j-1) + s(a_i, b_j),  // Match or mismatch
    F(i-1, j) + d,             // Gap in sequence b
    F(i, j-1) + d              // Gap in sequence a
}

    where:

    • F(i, j) is the score at position (i, j) in the matrix.
    • s(a_i, b_j) is the score for aligning the characters a_i and b_j.
    • d is the gap penalty.

  3. Traceback: Starting from the bottom-right cell of the matrix, the optimal alignment is traced back to the top-left cell, following the path that yielded the maximum score.

Advantages:

  • Guaranteed to find the optimal global alignment.
  • Well-suited for aligning sequences with high similarity across their entire length.

Disadvantages:

  • Computationally intensive, especially for long sequences.
  • Not suitable for finding local regions of similarity in dissimilar sequences.

3.1.2. Smith-Waterman Algorithm (Local Alignment)

The Smith-Waterman algorithm is used for local alignment, which identifies the most similar regions within two sequences. It is particularly useful when the sequences are dissimilar overall but may contain conserved domains or motifs.

How it Works:

  1. Initialization: A matrix is created with dimensions (m+1) x (n+1), where m and n are the lengths of the two sequences. The first row and first column are initialized with zeros.

  2. Matrix Filling: The matrix is filled using the following recurrence relation:

    H(i, j) = max {
    0,                       // No alignment
    H(i-1, j-1) + s(a_i, b_j),  // Match or mismatch
    H(i-1, j) + d,             // Gap in sequence b
    H(i, j-1) + d              // Gap in sequence a
}

    where:

    • H(i, j) is the score at position (i, j) in the matrix.
    • s(a_i, b_j) is the score for aligning the characters a_i and b_j.
    • d is the gap penalty.

  3. Traceback: Starting from the cell with the highest score in the matrix, the optimal alignment is traced back until a cell with a score of 0 is reached.

Advantages:

  • Guaranteed to find the optimal local alignment.
  • Well-suited for identifying conserved domains or motifs in dissimilar sequences.

Disadvantages:

  • Computationally intensive, especially for long sequences.
  • May not be effective for aligning sequences with high similarity across their entire length.

3.2. Heuristic Algorithms

Heuristic algorithms are faster than dynamic programming algorithms but do not guarantee to find the optimal alignment. These algorithms are suitable for large-scale sequence comparisons, such as searching a database for sequences similar to a query sequence.

3.2.1. BLAST (Basic Local Alignment Search Tool)

BLAST is one of the most widely used algorithms for sequence alignment. It is used to search databases for sequences similar to a query sequence. BLAST is available on the NCBI website.

How it Works:

  1. Seeding: The query sequence is divided into short words or k-mers.
  2. Scanning: The database is scanned for exact matches to these words.
  3. Extension: When a match is found, the alignment is extended in both directions until the score falls below a certain threshold.
  4. Evaluation: The alignments are evaluated based on their score and statistical significance.

Advantages:

  • Fast and efficient for searching large databases.
  • Highly sensitive for detecting weak similarities.

Disadvantages:

  • Does not guarantee to find the optimal alignment.
  • May miss some true positives.

3.2.2. FASTA (Fast Alignment)

FASTA is another popular algorithm for sequence alignment. It is similar to BLAST but uses a different approach for finding initial matches.

How it Works:

  1. Indexing: The query sequence and database sequences are indexed based on short words or k-mers.
  2. Searching: The database is searched for regions with high densities of matches.
  3. Alignment: The regions with high densities of matches are aligned using a banded dynamic programming algorithm.

Advantages:

  • Faster than dynamic programming algorithms.
  • More sensitive than BLAST for some types of sequences.

Disadvantages:

  • Does not guarantee to find the optimal alignment.
  • May be less sensitive than BLAST for highly divergent sequences.

4. How to Perform Sequence Alignment: A Step-by-Step Guide

Performing sequence alignment involves several steps, from preparing your sequences to interpreting the results. This section provides a detailed guide on how to perform sequence alignment effectively.

4.1. Step 1: Preparing Your Sequences

Before you can align sequences, you need to ensure they are in the correct format and free from errors.

  1. Sequence Retrieval: Obtain the sequences you want to compare from databases like NCBI, Ensembl, or UniProt.
  2. Format Conversion: Convert sequences to FASTA format, a standard text-based format for representing nucleotide or amino acid sequences.
  3. Sequence Cleaning: Remove any non-standard characters, such as numbers or spaces, and ensure the sequences are in uppercase.

4.2. Step 2: Choosing an Alignment Tool

Select an appropriate alignment tool based on your specific needs. Options include:

  • Online Tools: NCBI BLAST, EMBL-EBI Clustal Omega, and VectorBuilder’s Sequence Alignment tool.
  • Software Packages: EMBOSS, Biopython, and Geneious Prime.

4.3. Step 3: Setting Alignment Parameters

Configure the alignment parameters to optimize the results. Key parameters include:

  • Alignment Type: Choose between global and local alignment based on the similarity and length of your sequences.
  • Scoring Matrix: Select an appropriate scoring matrix (e.g., BLOSUM62 for proteins).
  • Gap Penalties: Adjust gap opening and extension penalties to balance sensitivity and specificity.

4.4. Step 4: Running the Alignment

Execute the alignment using the chosen tool and parameters. This process may take a few seconds to several minutes, depending on the length of the sequences and the complexity of the algorithm.

4.5. Step 5: Interpreting the Results

Analyze the alignment results to identify regions of similarity and difference. Key metrics to consider include:

  • Alignment Score: A numerical value indicating the quality of the alignment.
  • Percent Identity: The percentage of identical residues in the aligned region.
  • E-value: The expected number of alignments with a score equal to or better than the observed score that would occur by chance. A lower E-value indicates a more significant alignment.

5. What are the Tools Available for Gene Sequence Comparison?

Several tools are available for gene sequence comparison, each offering unique features and capabilities. These tools can be broadly categorized into online tools and software packages.

5.1. Online Tools

Online tools are accessible via web browsers and do not require installation. They are convenient for quick analyses and small-scale comparisons.

5.1.1. NCBI BLAST (Basic Local Alignment Search Tool)

NCBI BLAST is a widely used tool for searching sequence databases and performing pairwise or multiple sequence alignments.

  • Features:

    • Search against a variety of databases (e.g., nucleotide, protein).
    • Multiple alignment algorithms (e.g., BLASTn, BLASTp, BLASTx).
    • Customizable parameters (e.g., scoring matrix, gap penalties).

  • Use Case: Identifying homologous sequences in public databases.

5.1.2. EMBL-EBI Clustal Omega

EMBL-EBI Clustal Omega is a popular tool for multiple sequence alignment.

  • Features:

    • Progressive alignment algorithm.
    • Guide tree generation.
    • Support for large datasets.

  • Use Case: Aligning multiple related sequences to identify conserved regions.

5.1.3. VectorBuilder’s Sequence Alignment Tool

VectorBuilder’s Sequence Alignment tool allows you to directly compare two sequences at the DNA or protein level, and also compare two DNA sequences based on translation. You can also design vectors containing your sequence of interest.

  • Features:

    • Compare two sequences at the DNA or protein level.
    • Compare two DNA sequences based on translation.
    • Optimize alignments by adjusting the frame for either sequence.

  • Use Case: Examining relationships between proteins or organisms.

5.2. Software Packages

Software packages are installed on your computer and offer more advanced features and capabilities. They are suitable for complex analyses and large datasets.

5.2.1. EMBOSS (European Molecular Biology Open Software Suite)

EMBOSS is a suite of command-line tools for sequence analysis.

  • Features:

    • Wide range of tools for sequence alignment, analysis, and manipulation.
    • Scriptable interface for automation.
    • Support for various sequence formats.

  • Use Case: Performing complex sequence analyses in a high-throughput environment.

5.2.2. Biopython

Biopython is a Python library for bioinformatics.

  • Features:

    • Modules for sequence alignment, database access, and phylogenetic analysis.
    • Easy-to-use interface for scripting.
    • Integration with other Python libraries.

  • Use Case: Developing custom bioinformatics pipelines.

5.2.3. Geneious Prime

Geneious Prime is a commercial software package for sequence analysis.

  • Features:

    • User-friendly graphical interface.
    • Comprehensive set of tools for sequence alignment, phylogenetic analysis, and molecular cloning.
    • Support for various sequence formats.

  • Use Case: Performing a wide range of sequence analyses in a visual environment.

6. How Does Translation Impact Sequence Alignment?

When aligning DNA sequences, it’s crucial to consider how translation affects the alignment, especially when comparing coding regions. The genetic code is redundant, meaning that multiple codons can code for the same amino acid. This redundancy allows for silent mutations, where changes in the DNA sequence do not alter the amino acid sequence of the protein.

6.1. Aligning Translated Sequences

To account for silent mutations, it can be beneficial to align protein sequences translated from DNA. This approach highlights conserved protein domains and functional regions, even if the underlying DNA sequences have diverged.

Example:

Consider two DNA sequences encoding the same protein. Due to silent mutations, the DNA sequences may have only 80% identity. However, when translated and aligned, the protein sequences may show 100% identity, reflecting the conserved function of the protein.

6.2. Using VectorBuilder for Translation Alignment

VectorBuilder offers a tool to align DNA sequences based on translated protein sequences. This tool helps identify mutations that do not affect protein sequence or function.

Steps:

  1. Input the DNA sequences into VectorBuilder’s Sequence Alignment tool.
  2. Select the option to align based on translated protein sequences.
  3. Analyze the alignment results to identify conserved protein regions.

7. What is the Significance of Sequence Similarity Scores?

Sequence similarity scores are crucial metrics in bioinformatics, providing a quantitative measure of the relatedness between two or more biological sequences. These scores are used to infer evolutionary relationships, predict protein functions, and identify conserved regions.

7.1. Understanding Alignment Scores

Alignment scores reflect the degree of similarity between aligned sequences, considering matches, mismatches, and gaps. Different scoring systems assign values to these elements, influencing the overall score.

  • Matches: Positive scores for identical residues.
  • Mismatches: Negative scores for differing residues.
  • Gaps: Penalties for introducing or extending gaps.

7.2. Key Metrics for Evaluating Alignment Quality

Several key metrics help evaluate the quality and significance of sequence alignments.

  1. Percent Identity: The percentage of identical residues in the aligned region. Higher percent identity indicates greater similarity.
  2. Alignment Score: A numerical value indicating the quality of the alignment, reflecting the sum of scores for matches, mismatches, and gaps.
  3. E-value (Expect Value): The expected number of alignments with a score equal to or better than the observed score that would occur by chance. Lower E-values indicate more significant alignments.

7.3. Interpreting E-values

The E-value is a crucial parameter for assessing the statistical significance of an alignment. It estimates the likelihood that the observed alignment occurred by random chance.

  • E-value ≤ 0.01: The alignment is highly significant, suggesting a strong evolutionary relationship.
  • 0.01 < E-value ≤ 0.05: The alignment is moderately significant, warranting further investigation.
  • E-value > 0.05: The alignment is likely due to chance and may not indicate a true relationship.

7.4. Practical Applications of Sequence Similarity Scores

Sequence similarity scores have numerous practical applications in various fields of biology and medicine.

  1. Phylogenetics: Constructing phylogenetic trees to infer evolutionary relationships between species.
  2. Protein Function Prediction: Identifying proteins with similar sequences to predict their functions.
  3. Drug Discovery: Finding potential drug targets by aligning protein sequences with known drug targets.
  4. Genome Annotation: Identifying genes and other functional elements in newly sequenced genomes.

8. What are the Applications of Gene Sequence Comparison?

Gene sequence comparison has numerous applications in various fields of biology and medicine. These applications range from identifying genetic diseases to understanding evolutionary relationships.

8.1. Identifying Genetic Diseases

Sequence alignment can be used to identify mutations that cause genetic diseases. By comparing the sequence of a patient’s gene to a reference sequence, researchers can identify mutations that may be responsible for the disease.

Example:

In cystic fibrosis, mutations in the CFTR gene can be identified through sequence alignment. Identifying these mutations helps in diagnosing the disease and determining the appropriate treatment.

8.2. Understanding Evolutionary Relationships

Sequence alignment can be used to understand the evolutionary relationships between different species. By comparing the sequences of homologous genes in different species, researchers can infer how the species have evolved over time.

Example:

Comparing the sequences of mitochondrial DNA in different human populations has helped researchers trace the origins and migrations of human populations around the world.

8.3. Predicting Protein Structure and Function

Sequence alignment can be used to predict the structure and function of proteins. By comparing the sequence of a protein to the sequences of proteins with known structures and functions, researchers can infer the structure and function of the protein.

Example:

If a newly discovered protein sequence shows high similarity to a protein with known enzymatic activity, it is likely that the new protein also has enzymatic activity.

8.4. Designing Primers for PCR

Sequence alignment is essential for designing primers for polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Primers are short DNA sequences that bind to specific regions of a target DNA sequence, allowing for the amplification of that sequence.

Example:

When designing primers to amplify a specific gene, the primer sequences must be complementary to the flanking regions of the gene. Sequence alignment ensures that the primers bind specifically to the target sequence.

8.5. Identifying Conserved Domains

Sequence alignment can be used to identify conserved domains in proteins. Conserved domains are regions of a protein that are highly similar across different species, suggesting that these regions are important for the protein’s function.

Example:

The homeodomain is a conserved DNA-binding domain found in many transcription factors. Identifying the homeodomain in a newly discovered protein suggests that the protein is a transcription factor.

9. What are the Advanced Techniques in Sequence Alignment?

As technology advances, more sophisticated techniques for sequence alignment are emerging, offering enhanced accuracy and efficiency.

9.1. Multiple Sequence Alignment (MSA)

Multiple sequence alignment (MSA) extends pairwise alignment to three or more sequences. MSA is used to identify conserved regions and patterns across a set of related sequences.

Algorithms:

  • ClustalW: A widely used progressive alignment algorithm.
  • MUSCLE: A more accurate and faster algorithm than ClustalW.
  • MAFFT: A highly accurate algorithm suitable for large datasets.

9.2. Profile Alignment

Profile alignment involves aligning a sequence to a profile, which is a representation of a multiple sequence alignment. Profiles capture the conserved patterns and variations within a set of related sequences.

Tools:

  • HMMER: A software package for profile hidden Markov models (HMMs).

9.3. Structural Alignment

Structural alignment aligns sequences based on their three-dimensional structures. Structural alignment is more accurate than sequence alignment for distantly related sequences.

Tools:

  • TM-align: A structure-based alignment program.
  • DALI: A database of structural alignments.

10. How To Troubleshoot Common Issues in Sequence Alignment?

Even with the best tools and techniques, sequence alignment can sometimes present challenges. Troubleshooting common issues can help ensure accurate and meaningful results.

10.1. Low Similarity Scores

Low similarity scores can occur due to several reasons, including:

  • Divergent Sequences: The sequences may be too dissimilar for accurate alignment.
  • Incorrect Parameters: The alignment parameters may not be optimized for the sequences being compared.
  • Sequence Errors: The sequences may contain errors, such as frameshifts or incorrect bases.

Solutions:

  • Use a local alignment algorithm to identify conserved regions.
  • Adjust the alignment parameters, such as the scoring matrix and gap penalties.
  • Check the sequences for errors and correct them if necessary.

10.2. Gaps in Unexpected Locations

Gaps in unexpected locations can indicate:

  • Insertions or Deletions: The sequences may contain genuine insertions or deletions.
  • Incorrect Alignment: The alignment algorithm may be introducing gaps to maximize the score, even if they are not biologically meaningful.

Solutions:

  • Review the alignment manually to ensure the gaps are in the correct locations.
  • Adjust the gap penalties to discourage the introduction of unnecessary gaps.
  • Use a different alignment algorithm to see if it produces a more accurate alignment.

10.3. High E-values

High E-values indicate that the alignment is likely due to chance and may not be biologically meaningful.

Solutions:

  • Increase the stringency of the alignment by adjusting the parameters.
  • Search a larger database to see if there are any more similar sequences with lower E-values.
  • Consider the biological context of the sequences to determine if the alignment is plausible.

FAQ: How To Compare Gene Sequences

1. What is the first step in comparing gene sequences?

The first step is to retrieve and prepare your sequences in FASTA format, ensuring they are clean and error-free.

2. What is the difference between global and local alignment?

Global alignment aligns the entire length of two sequences, while local alignment focuses on finding the most similar regions within the sequences.

3. Which algorithm is best for aligning highly similar sequences?

The Needleman-Wunsch algorithm is best for aligning highly similar sequences as it performs global alignment.

4. Which algorithm is best for finding conserved domains in dissimilar sequences?

The Smith-Waterman algorithm is ideal for finding conserved domains as it performs local alignment.

5. How do I interpret the E-value in sequence alignment results?

An E-value less than 0.01 indicates a highly significant alignment, suggesting a strong evolutionary relationship.

6. What is multiple sequence alignment (MSA)?

MSA aligns three or more sequences to identify conserved regions and patterns across the set of related sequences.

7. How does translation impact sequence alignment?

Translation can reveal conserved protein domains and functional regions, even if the underlying DNA sequences have diverged due to silent mutations.

8. What are some common online tools for sequence alignment?

Common online tools include NCBI BLAST, EMBL-EBI Clustal Omega, and VectorBuilder’s Sequence Alignment tool.

9. What are gap penalties in sequence alignment?

Gap penalties are negative scores assigned for the introduction or extension of gaps, preventing excessive gap usage and ensuring biologically meaningful alignments.

10. How can structural alignment improve sequence alignment accuracy?

Structural alignment aligns sequences based on their three-dimensional structures, providing more accurate results for distantly related sequences compared to sequence alignment alone.

Sequence alignment is a powerful tool for understanding the relationships between genes and proteins. By following the steps outlined in this guide, you can effectively compare gene sequences and gain valuable insights into their structure, function, and evolution.

Ready to take your sequence analysis to the next level? Visit COMPARE.EDU.VN to explore more detailed comparisons and make informed decisions. Contact us at 333 Comparison Plaza, Choice City, CA 90210, United States or reach out via Whatsapp at +1 (626) 555-9090. Visit our website at compare.edu.vn today!

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *