When evaluating vehicle safety, the Overall Vehicle Score is a crucial metric, often represented as a star rating. This score provides a comprehensive assessment of a vehicle’s safety performance by considering various crash scenarios. It’s calculated using the probabilities of injury determined in frontal and side crash tests, along with a projected probability of injury based on rollover resistance ratings. These values are carefully weighted to reflect the real-world frequency and severity of each type of crash. The resulting score is then benchmarked against the average injury risk across all vehicles, indicating whether a specific vehicle poses a higher or lower injury risk compared to this average.
The Overall Vehicle Score is categorized into a five-star system, offering an easy-to-understand safety assessment:
- ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐: Significantly lower than average injury risk.
- ⭐⭐⭐⭐: Lower than average to average injury risk.
- ⭐⭐⭐: Average to greater than average injury risk.
- ⭐⭐: Greater than average injury risk.
- ⭐: Significantly greater than average injury risk.
However, it’s crucial to understand the limitations when you Compare Two Vehicles using their Overall Vehicle Scores. Because this score is partly derived from the frontal crash test rating, direct comparisons are only valid between vehicles that belong to the same class and have a weight difference of no more than 250 pounds. This weight and class restriction is essential for ensuring a meaningful and accurate comparison of safety performance.
To illustrate, consider these examples to clarify when it is appropriate to compare two vehicles based on their safety scores:
-
It is incorrect to compare two vehicles if you are looking at a 4,500-pound SUV and a 3,000-pound sedan. This comparison is invalid because they belong to different vehicle classes and the weight difference significantly exceeds the 250-pound limit. SUVs and sedans are designed with different structural characteristics and are tested against different standards, making a direct safety score comparison misleading.
-
Similarly, it is also inappropriate to compare two vehicles such as a 3,600-pound pickup truck and a 3,400-pound minivan. While the weight difference is within the acceptable range, they are classified as different types of vehicles. Pickups and minivans have distinct designs and intended uses, which affect their safety performance in different crash scenarios. Therefore, comparing their Overall Vehicle Scores directly would not be an accurate reflection of their relative safety.
-
Conversely, it is perfectly acceptable to compare two vehicles if you are considering a 3,400-pound passenger car and a 3,650-pound passenger car. In this case, both vehicles are in the same passenger car class and their weight difference of 250 pounds or less meets the comparison criteria. Comparing the safety scores of these two vehicles provides a relevant and useful insight into their relative safety performance for potential buyers.
In conclusion, while the Overall Vehicle Score is a valuable tool for assessing vehicle safety, it is essential to apply it correctly when you compare two vehicles. Always ensure that you are comparing vehicles within the same class and with a comparable weight range to draw accurate and meaningful conclusions about their safety performance. Ignoring these guidelines can lead to misinterpretations and potentially unsafe vehicle choices.
