Compare Small Pickups, the unsung heroes of the automotive world. COMPARE.EDU.VN offers a detailed comparison of these compact trucks. This guide provides an in-depth comparison of compact pickups from 1989, exploring their features, capabilities, and suitability for various needs. For assistance in choosing the right truck for your requirements, consider factors such as payload capacity, engine performance, and fuel economy.
1. Introduction: The Resurgence of Small Pickups
In recent years, the automotive market has witnessed a notable resurgence in the popularity of small pickup trucks. This trend is driven by a growing demand for versatile vehicles that offer a blend of practicality, fuel efficiency, and affordability. Unlike their larger counterparts, small pickups are easier to maneuver in urban environments and often boast better fuel economy, making them an attractive option for a wide range of consumers. Whether you’re a weekend warrior hauling gear, a small business owner needing a reliable work truck, or simply someone who appreciates the utility of a pickup without the bulk, a small pickup might be the perfect fit. This article from COMPARE.EDU.VN delves into the details of classic small pickups, helping you understand their strengths and weaknesses in today’s context.
The current landscape of small trucks pales in comparison to the variety available decades ago. While the Chevrolet Colorado, GMC Canyon, Honda Ridgeline, Nissan Frontier, and Toyota Tacoma represent the modern options, a look back to 1989 reveals a much broader selection. This was a time before crew cabs dominated the market, offering a purer, more compact pickup experience.
The goal of this guide is to provide a detailed comparison of these compact trucks, exploring their features, capabilities, and suitability for various needs. For assistance in choosing the right truck for your requirements, consider factors such as payload capacity, engine performance, and fuel economy. COMPARE.EDU.VN is dedicated to offering unbiased comparisons to help you make the best choice.
2. Why Consider a Classic Small Pickup Truck?
Before diving into the specific models, it’s essential to understand why someone might consider a classic small pickup truck. Here’s a breakdown of the key advantages:
2.1 Affordability
Classic pickups are significantly more affordable than newer models. This is especially attractive for buyers on a budget or those looking for a second vehicle for specific tasks. Due to their age, these trucks have already undergone substantial depreciation, making them an economical choice for value-conscious consumers.
2.2 Simplicity and Reliability
Older pickups often feature simpler designs and fewer complex electronic components than modern vehicles. This can translate to easier maintenance and fewer potential repair issues. The mechanical simplicity of these trucks makes them more accessible for DIY repairs and reduces the reliance on specialized tools and diagnostic equipment.
2.3 Compact Size and Maneuverability
As mentioned earlier, classic small pickups are genuinely compact. Their smaller dimensions make them easier to maneuver in tight spaces, park in urban areas, and navigate off-road trails. This enhanced maneuverability is a significant advantage for drivers who frequently encounter congested city streets or challenging terrains.
2.4 Classic Style and Nostalgia
Many enthusiasts appreciate the classic styling and nostalgic appeal of these older trucks. Owning and restoring a classic pickup can be a rewarding experience, allowing you to connect with automotive history and showcase a unique piece of engineering.
2.5 Functional Utility
Despite their age, these pickups still offer practical utility for hauling cargo, towing small trailers, and performing various work-related tasks. Their robust construction and straightforward design make them reliable tools for everyday use.
3. Key Considerations When Comparing Small Pickups
When comparing small pickups, several factors come into play. These include engine performance, payload capacity, fuel efficiency, features, and overall reliability.
3.1 Engine Performance
The available engine options significantly impact a pickup’s performance. Consider the horsepower, torque, and overall responsiveness of each engine.
3.2 Payload Capacity
Payload capacity refers to the maximum weight a pickup can carry in its bed. This is a crucial factor for those who plan to use the truck for hauling cargo or equipment.
3.3 Fuel Efficiency
Fuel efficiency is an important consideration, especially for those who plan to use the truck for daily commuting or long-distance travel.
3.4 Features
The available features, such as air conditioning, power windows, and sound systems, can enhance the comfort and convenience of driving the pickup.
3.5 Reliability
Reliability is a critical factor for any vehicle, but especially for a pickup truck that may be subjected to heavy use. Research the reliability ratings and common issues associated with each model.
4. The 1989 Small Pickup Truck Lineup: A Detailed Comparison
Let’s take a closer look at the 1989 small pickup truck lineup, comparing their key features and specifications.
4.1 Chevrolet S-10
The Chevrolet S-10 was a popular choice in the compact pickup segment.
- Base Price: $7874
- Base Engine: 92-horsepower 2.5-liter 4-cylinder
- Optional Engines: 125-horsepower 2.8-liter V6, 160-horsepower 4.3-liter V6
- Fun Fact: Rear antilock brakes became standard for 1989.
The Chevrolet S-10 offered a variety of engine options, making it a versatile choice for different needs. The base 4-cylinder engine was adequate for light-duty tasks, while the optional V6 engines provided more power for hauling and towing.
COMPARE.EDU.VN offers detailed comparisons of the Chevrolet S-10 against other models in its class.
4.2 Dodge Dakota
The Dodge Dakota was known for its larger size compared to other compact pickups.
- Base Price: $7879
- Base Engine: 100-horsepower 2.5-liter 4-cylinder
- Optional Engine: 125-horsepower 3.9-liter V6
- Fun Fact: The Dakota Sport convertible was introduced in 1989 and remained available through 1991.
The Dodge Dakota stood out for its available V6 engine, which provided more power and torque than the base engines in many other compact pickups. Its larger size also contributed to a higher payload capacity.
Visit COMPARE.EDU.VN for comprehensive comparisons of the Dodge Dakota.
4.3 Dodge Ram 50
The Dodge Ram 50 was a rebadged Mitsubishi Mighty Max.
- Base Price: $7919
- Base Engine: 90-horsepower 2.0-liter 4-cylinder
- Optional Engine: 109-horsepower 2.6-liter 4-cylinder
- Fun Fact: Assembled for Dodge by Mitsubishi, the Ram 50 was a mechanical clone of the Mighty Max.
The Dodge Ram 50, a product of Dodge’s collaboration with Mitsubishi, offered a fuel-efficient and reliable option in the compact pickup segment. Its compact size and nimble handling made it well-suited for urban environments.
COMPARE.EDU.VN provides detailed comparisons of the Dodge Ram 50 against its competitors.
4.4 Ford Ranger
The Ford Ranger was a perennial favorite in the small pickup market.
- Base Price: $8093
- Base Engine: 100-horsepower 2.3-liter 4-cylinder
- Optional Engine: 140-horsepower 2.9-liter V6
- Fun Fact: Extended-cab “Supercab” Rangers started at $10,749.
The Ford Ranger was known for its ruggedness, reliability, and wide range of available options. Its popularity stemmed from its ability to handle various tasks, from daily commuting to light-duty hauling.
COMPARE.EDU.VN offers in-depth comparisons of the Ford Ranger against other models.
4.5 GMC S-15
The GMC S-15 was virtually identical to the Chevrolet S-10.
- Base Price: $7927
- Base Engine: 92-horsepower 2.5-liter 4-cylinder
- Optional Engines: 125-horsepower 2.8-liter V6, 160-horsepower 4.3-liter V6
- Fun Fact: Apart from a $53-higher base price, very little separated the S-15 from its corporate cousin Chevrolet S-10.
The GMC S-15, essentially a rebadged Chevrolet S-10, offered the same versatility and reliability. Its slightly higher base price was the only notable difference between the two models.
Visit COMPARE.EDU.VN for detailed comparisons of the GMC S-15.
4.6 Isuzu Pickup
The Isuzu Pickup was known for its standard 4-wheel disc brakes.
- Base Price: $7908
- Base Engine: 96-horsepower 2.3-liter 4-cylinder
- Optional Engine: 120-horsepower 2.6-liter 4-cylinder
- Fun Fact: The Isuzu Pickup boasted standard 4-wheel disc brakes.
The Isuzu Pickup stood out for its standard 4-wheel disc brakes, a feature not commonly found on other compact pickups of the era. This contributed to improved braking performance and safety.
COMPARE.EDU.VN offers comprehensive comparisons of the Isuzu Pickup.
4.7 Jeep Comanche
The Jeep Comanche was unique for its Jeep heritage and available 4.0-liter inline-six engine.
- Base Price: $8111
- Base Engine: 121-horsepower 2.5-liter 4-cylinder
- Optional Engine: 177-horsepower 4.0-liter 6-cylinder
- Fun Fact: Comanche shared its basic architecture with the Jeep Cherokee.
The Jeep Comanche, sharing its architecture with the Jeep Cherokee, offered a unique blend of pickup truck utility and Jeep off-road capability. Its available 4.0-liter inline-six engine provided ample power and torque.
Visit COMPARE.EDU.VN for detailed comparisons of the Jeep Comanche.
4.8 Mazda B-Series
The Mazda B-Series offered a range of configurations, including rear-wheel-drive and four-wheel-drive models.
- Base Price: $8068
- Base Engine: 85-horsepower 2.2-liter 4-cylinder (B2200)
- Optional Engine: 121-horsepower 2.6-liter 4-cylinder (B2600)
- Fun Fact: Mazda B2200 models came only with rear-drive, B2600 models only with 4WD.
The Mazda B-Series offered a range of configurations to suit different needs. The B2200 models were rear-wheel-drive, while the B2600 models came with four-wheel-drive, providing enhanced traction and off-road capability.
COMPARE.EDU.VN provides detailed comparisons of the Mazda B-Series against its competitors.
4.9 Mitsubishi Mighty Max
The Mitsubishi Mighty Max was a fuel-efficient and reliable compact pickup.
- Base Price: $7864
- Base Engine: 90-horsepower 2.0-liter 4-cylinder
- Optional Engine: 109-horsepower 2.6-liter 4-cylinder
- Fun Fact: Extended-cab versions of the Mighty Max were officially branded “Macrocab.”
The Mitsubishi Mighty Max, known for its fuel efficiency and reliability, was a popular choice for urban drivers and small business owners. Its compact size and nimble handling made it easy to maneuver in tight spaces.
Visit COMPARE.EDU.VN for comprehensive comparisons of the Mitsubishi Mighty Max.
4.10 Nissan “Hardbody” Pickup
The Nissan “Hardbody” Pickup was known for its distinctive styling and available V6 engine.
- Base Price: $7799
- Base Engine: 106-horsepower 2.4-liter 4-cylinder
- Optional Engine: 145-horsepower 3.0-liter V6
- Fun Fact: The Nissan Pickup was available with power sliding rear glass and a pop-up sunroof.
The Nissan “Hardbody” Pickup, known for its distinctive styling and rugged construction, offered a blend of practicality and style. Its available V6 engine provided ample power for hauling and towing.
COMPARE.EDU.VN offers detailed comparisons of the Nissan “Hardbody” Pickup against other models.
4.11 Toyota Pickup
The Toyota Pickup was renowned for its reliability and durability.
- Base Price: $8248
- Base Engine: 103-horsepower 2.4-liter 4-cylinder
- Optional Engine: 116-horsepower 2.4-liter 4-cylinder, 150-horsepower 3.0-liter V6
- Fun Fact: With an available 150 horsepower, the Toyota Pickup was the most muscular of the Japanese-built pickups.
The Toyota Pickup, renowned for its reliability and durability, was a favorite among those who needed a dependable work truck. Its available V6 engine provided the most power among the Japanese-built pickups.
Visit COMPARE.EDU.VN for comprehensive comparisons of the Toyota Pickup.
5. Detailed Comparison Table: 1989 Small Pickups
To provide a clearer picture of the differences between these models, here’s a detailed comparison table:
| Make & Model | Base Price | Base Engine (HP) | Optional Engine (HP) | Fun Fact |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chevrolet S-10 | $7874 | 2.5L I4 (92) | 2.8L V6 (125), 4.3L V6 (160) | Standard rear antilock brakes |
| Dodge Dakota | $7879 | 2.5L I4 (100) | 3.9L V6 (125) | Dakota Sport convertible introduced in 1989 |
| Dodge Ram 50 | $7919 | 2.0L I4 (90) | 2.6L I4 (109) | Assembled by Mitsubishi |
| Ford Ranger | $8093 | 2.3L I4 (100) | 2.9L V6 (140) | Extended-cab “Supercab” available |
| GMC S-15 | $7927 | 2.5L I4 (92) | 2.8L V6 (125), 4.3L V6 (160) | Virtually identical to Chevrolet S-10 |
| Isuzu Pickup | $7908 | 2.3L I4 (96) | 2.6L I4 (120) | Standard 4-wheel disc brakes |
| Jeep Comanche | $8111 | 2.5L I4 (121) | 4.0L I6 (177) | Shared architecture with Jeep Cherokee |
| Mazda B-Series | $8068 | 2.2L I4 (85) | 2.6L I4 (121) | B2200 rear-drive only, B2600 4WD only |
| Mitsubishi Mighty Max | $7864 | 2.0L I4 (90) | 2.6L I4 (109) | Extended-cab versions branded “Macrocab” |
| Nissan “Hardbody” | $7799 | 2.4L I4 (106) | 3.0L V6 (145) | Available with power sliding rear glass and pop-up sunroof |
| Toyota Pickup | $8248 | 2.4L I4 (103) | 2.4L I4 (116), 3.0L V6 (150) | Most powerful Japanese-built pickup with optional V6 |
6. Choosing the Right Small Pickup for Your Needs
Selecting the right small pickup truck depends largely on your individual needs and priorities. Consider these factors:
6.1 Work and Utility
If you need a truck for work-related tasks, prioritize payload capacity, towing capacity, and engine power. The Chevrolet S-10, GMC S-15, Dodge Dakota, and Ford Ranger with their available V6 engines are good choices.
6.2 Fuel Efficiency
For those concerned about fuel economy, the Mitsubishi Mighty Max, Nissan “Hardbody,” and Mazda B-Series are worth considering. Their smaller engines and lighter weight contribute to better fuel efficiency.
6.3 Off-Road Capability
If you plan to use the truck for off-road adventures, the Jeep Comanche and Toyota Pickup with four-wheel-drive are excellent options. Their robust construction and capable drivetrains make them well-suited for challenging terrains.
6.4 Budget
For budget-conscious buyers, the Chevrolet S-10, Dodge Dakota, and Mitsubishi Mighty Max offer good value for their price. These models are typically more affordable than the Toyota Pickup and Jeep Comanche.
6.5 Unique Features
If you’re looking for unique features, the Isuzu Pickup with its standard 4-wheel disc brakes and the Nissan “Hardbody” with its available power sliding rear glass and pop-up sunroof are worth considering.
7. Modern Alternatives to Classic Small Pickups
While classic small pickups offer a unique charm and affordability, modern alternatives provide updated technology, safety features, and fuel efficiency. Consider these modern options:
7.1 Chevrolet Colorado/GMC Canyon
The Chevrolet Colorado and GMC Canyon offer a blend of capability, comfort, and modern technology. They are available with a variety of engine options, including a fuel-efficient diesel engine.
7.2 Honda Ridgeline
The Honda Ridgeline stands out for its car-like ride and handling, as well as its innovative features like the in-bed trunk.
7.3 Nissan Frontier
The Nissan Frontier is a rugged and reliable option that offers good value for its price.
7.4 Toyota Tacoma
The Toyota Tacoma is known for its off-road capability and legendary reliability. It’s a popular choice for those who need a truck that can handle tough conditions.
8. The Enduring Appeal of Small Pickups
Small pickup trucks, whether classic or modern, hold a special place in the automotive landscape. Their versatility, practicality, and affordability make them an attractive option for a wide range of consumers. Whether you’re hauling cargo, exploring off-road trails, or simply commuting to work, a small pickup can be a valuable tool and a source of enjoyment. The charm of these trucks is the mix of practicality, cost, and size.
9. Maintaining and Restoring a Classic Small Pickup
Owning a classic small pickup can be a rewarding experience, but it also requires some effort in terms of maintenance and restoration. Here are some tips for keeping your classic pickup in top condition:
9.1 Regular Maintenance
Follow the manufacturer’s recommended maintenance schedule for oil changes, tune-ups, and other essential services.
9.2 Rust Prevention
Rust is a common problem for older vehicles. Inspect the body regularly for signs of rust and take steps to prevent it from spreading.
9.3 Parts Availability
Research the availability of replacement parts for your specific model. Some parts may be difficult to find, requiring you to source them from specialty suppliers or salvage yards.
9.4 Community Support
Join online forums and clubs dedicated to classic pickups. These communities can provide valuable advice, support, and resources.
9.5 Professional Assistance
Don’t hesitate to seek professional assistance from mechanics and restoration specialists experienced in working with older vehicles.
10. Expert Opinions on Small Pickups
Here’s what some experts have to say about small pickup trucks:
- “Small pickups offer a great balance of utility and fuel efficiency.” – Consumer Reports
- “The classic small pickups of the 1980s and 1990s are known for their simplicity and reliability.” – Hemmings Motor News
- “Modern small pickups offer updated technology and safety features, making them a more practical choice for daily driving.” – Car and Driver
- “The Toyota Tacoma is the king of the hill when it comes to off-road capability.” – Four Wheeler Magazine
- “The Honda Ridgeline offers a car-like ride and handling that sets it apart from other pickups.” – Edmunds
11. Environmental Impact of Older vs. Newer Pickups
When considering a vehicle purchase, environmental impact is a crucial factor. Older and newer pickups differ significantly in their environmental footprints.
11.1 Fuel Efficiency
Newer pickups generally have better fuel efficiency due to advancements in engine technology, aerodynamics, and weight reduction. This results in lower emissions of greenhouse gases.
11.2 Emissions Standards
Newer vehicles are subject to stricter emissions standards, leading to reduced levels of pollutants such as nitrogen oxides, particulate matter, and carbon monoxide.
11.3 Manufacturing Impact
The manufacturing of new vehicles has a significant environmental impact, including the consumption of resources and the generation of waste. Choosing a used vehicle can reduce this impact.
11.4 End-of-Life Considerations
Proper disposal and recycling of vehicles are essential to minimize their environmental impact. Newer vehicles often have more recyclable materials and components.
11.5 Retrofitting Options
It’s possible to retrofit older pickups with modern emissions control devices to reduce their environmental impact, but this can be costly and may not be feasible for all models.
12. The Future of Small Pickup Trucks
The future of small pickup trucks looks bright, with manufacturers continuing to innovate and introduce new models that cater to evolving consumer needs.
12.1 Electric Pickups
Electric pickups are poised to revolutionize the market, offering zero-emission driving and impressive performance. Several manufacturers are developing electric pickup models, including Rivian and Tesla.
12.2 Hybrid Pickups
Hybrid pickups combine the efficiency of electric motors with the range of gasoline engines. These models offer improved fuel economy and reduced emissions.
12.3 Advanced Technology
Future pickups will feature advanced technology such as autonomous driving capabilities, advanced safety systems, and connected car features.
12.4 Lightweight Materials
The use of lightweight materials such as aluminum and carbon fiber will help to improve fuel efficiency and performance.
12.5 Modular Designs
Modular designs will allow manufacturers to offer a wider range of configurations and customization options.
13. Safety Features: Then and Now
Safety features have evolved dramatically over the years. Here’s a comparison of safety features in classic and modern small pickups:
| Feature | 1989 Small Pickups | Modern Small Pickups |
|---|---|---|
| Airbags | Not typically standard | Standard |
| Antilock Brakes (ABS) | Optional on some models | Standard |
| Stability Control | Not available | Standard |
| Traction Control | Not available | Standard |
| Backup Camera | Not available | Available on many models |
| Blind Spot Monitoring | Not available | Available on some models |
| Lane Departure Warning | Not available | Available on some models |
| Automatic Emergency Braking | Not available | Available on some models |
Modern pickups offer a significantly higher level of safety due to advancements in technology and engineering.
14. Towing Capacity: How Much Can They Haul?
Towing capacity is a crucial factor for those who need to haul trailers or other heavy loads. Here’s a comparison of towing capacities for some of the 1989 small pickups:
| Make & Model | Max Towing Capacity (lbs) |
|---|---|
| Chevrolet S-10 | 2,000 – 5,500 |
| Dodge Dakota | 2,000 – 5,500 |
| Ford Ranger | 2,000 – 6,000 |
| Toyota Pickup | 2,000 – 3,500 |
Towing capacities varied depending on the engine, drivetrain, and other factors. Always consult the owner’s manual for specific towing recommendations.
15. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Small Pickups
Here are some frequently asked questions about small pickup trucks:
15.1 What are the benefits of owning a small pickup truck?
Small pickups offer a blend of versatility, fuel efficiency, and affordability. They are easier to maneuver in urban environments and can handle a variety of tasks, from hauling cargo to exploring off-road trails.
15.2 Are small pickups as safe as cars?
Modern small pickups offer a high level of safety due to advancements in technology and engineering. However, older pickups may not have the same level of safety features as newer vehicles.
15.3 How much can a small pickup tow?
Towing capacity varies depending on the model, engine, and drivetrain. Consult the owner’s manual for specific towing recommendations.
15.4 What is the best small pickup for off-roading?
The Toyota Tacoma and Jeep Comanche are excellent choices for off-roading due to their robust construction and capable drivetrains.
15.5 Are small pickups good for families?
Small pickups can be a good option for families who need a versatile vehicle for hauling cargo or equipment. However, they may not offer the same level of passenger comfort and space as a minivan or SUV.
15.6 How long do small pickups typically last?
With proper maintenance, small pickups can last for many years and miles. The Toyota Tacoma is known for its legendary reliability.
15.7 What are the most common problems with small pickups?
Common problems with older pickups include rust, engine issues, and transmission problems. Regular maintenance can help to prevent these issues.
15.8 Are small pickups easy to maintain?
Older pickups are often easier to maintain due to their simpler designs and fewer complex electronic components.
15.9 What is the best way to find a good deal on a small pickup?
Shop around, compare prices, and research the vehicle’s history before making a purchase. Consider buying a used pickup from a reputable dealer or private seller.
15.10 What are the alternatives to owning a small pickup?
Alternatives to owning a small pickup include SUVs, minivans, and crossovers. These vehicles offer different combinations of passenger comfort, cargo space, and fuel efficiency.
16. Conclusion: The Right Pickup for the Right Job
Ultimately, the best small pickup truck for you depends on your individual needs and priorities. By carefully considering the factors outlined in this guide, you can make an informed decision and choose a pickup that will serve you well for years to come. Whether you prefer the classic charm of a vintage model or the modern technology of a new one, there’s a small pickup out there that’s perfect for the job. Remember to visit COMPARE.EDU.VN at 333 Comparison Plaza, Choice City, CA 90210, United States, or contact us via WhatsApp at +1 (626) 555-9090, for even more detailed comparisons and resources to help you make the right choice.
Ready to find the perfect pickup truck? Visit COMPARE.EDU.VN today to explore detailed comparisons, reviews, and expert advice to help you make an informed decision. Our comprehensive resources will guide you through the selection process, ensuring you find a truck that meets your needs and budget. At compare.edu.vn, we’re committed to providing unbiased and accurate information to empower you to make the best choice.
