In the realm of premium paints, Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams stand as titans, each brand boasting a loyal following and a reputation for exceptional quality. For homeowners in Novi, Michigan, and beyond, choosing between these two industry leaders can feel like a daunting task. Selecting the right paint brand is a pivotal decision that directly impacts the longevity, aesthetics, and overall value of your home, whether you’re tackling an interior refresh or an exterior makeover.
Both Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams have earned accolades for their superior formulations, but each possesses distinct characteristics. This article provides a detailed comparison to empower Novi, MI residents and others to make an informed choice for their next painting project.
Ready to transform your home with a fresh coat of paint? Contact us today or complete our online inquiry form.
So, Benjamin Moore or Sherwin-Williams – which paint brand reigns supreme for your home? Continue reading to discover the answer.
Benjamin Moore versus Sherwin-Williams: A Head-to-Head Paint Showdown
Alt text: Benjamin Moore retail store showcasing a variety of paint cans and color samples.
Alt text: Exterior view of a Sherwin-Williams paint store with prominent brand signage.
The ultimate verdict in the Benjamin Moore vs. Sherwin Williams debate? It’s a tie! When it comes to paint performance, both brands deliver exceptional results. While subtle differences may exist between specific product lines, these nuances are often discernible only to seasoned painting professionals.
The primary differentiator lies in their business models. Benjamin Moore stores operate under a locally owned dealership structure, whereas Sherwin-Williams stores are company-owned. Therefore, if supporting local businesses resonates with you, Benjamin Moore might be your preferred choice.
Quality and Durability: Do Sherwin Williams Paints Match Benjamin Moore’s Longevity?
At the heart of any paint decision lies the question of quality. In the paint industry, you truly get what you pay for. Opting for budget-friendly, lower-quality paints for interiors or exteriors often translates to a subpar and short-lived paint job. Investing in quality paint, conversely, yields a superior and enduring finish. Arguably, the most challenging aspect of any paint project is selecting the perfect paint color.
Both Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams are synonymous with quality and durability in the paint industry. They are trusted and reliable brands for both professional painters and homeowners embarking on DIY projects. Whether you are painting interior walls or protecting your home’s exterior from the elements, these brands promise enduring beauty and protection.
Todd Tribble’s Professional Insight
Alt text: Side-by-side comparison of Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams paint cans, illustrating the brand rivalry.
“Having worked extensively with both Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams paints, I can confidently say that both brands perform exceptionally well. The critical factor is paint quality, not necessarily brand loyalty. Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams represent the pinnacle of paint manufacturing, and I would readily use either for any project. While designers might lean towards one brand based on personal preference, the performance is comparable.”
“Benjamin Moore’s Aura and Regal Select lines stand out for their outstanding coverage and remarkable touch-up capability. Sherwin-Williams’ Emerald Designer Edition and Emerald lines also provide excellent coverage and are known for their smooth application with both brushes and rollers.”
Alt text: Professional painters applying exterior paint to a house facade during favorable weather.
“Both brands consistently deliver high-quality products and are backed by exceptional customer service. The assurance of having knowledgeable paint professionals readily available for on-site support and problem-solving is invaluable. Our clients frequently request colors from both Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams, giving us ample opportunity to work with a diverse range of their paint offerings. Regardless of whether you choose Benjamin Moore or Sherwin-Williams, selecting their premium paint lines for your next project will guarantee excellent results.”
The Cost Factor: Sherwin-Williams vs. Benjamin Moore Paint Prices and Value
While the initial cost of paint can seem significant, it’s crucial to consider the long-term value proposition. Benjamin Moore paints typically retail around $57 per gallon, slightly more than Sherwin-Williams at approximately $53 per gallon. Despite the higher upfront investment, opting for quality paints from these brands can lead to long-term cost savings by minimizing the need for frequent touch-ups and ensuring a more durable, longer-lasting finish.
The Impact of Rising Paint Prices
Recent increases in paint prices underscore the importance of prioritizing quality over budget-friendliness. Investing in high-quality paints from Sherwin-Williams or Benjamin Moore can prove to be more economical in the long run, as they often require fewer coats and offer superior durability.
Why Stick with Premium Paint Brands?
Alt text: Close-up of a hand using a mini-roller to apply Benjamin Moore or Sherwin-Williams paint to an interior wall.
There’s a compelling reason why the paint conversation consistently revolves around Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams. These brands invest heavily in research and development, resulting in comprehensive product lines tailored to address virtually any painting need and project requirement. Their higher price point reflects their superior quality. Lower-quality paints often necessitate multiple coats, increased labor, and ultimately, more frequent repainting due to reduced longevity.
Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams Store Locations: Availability and Accessibility
There are approximately 6,640 Benjamin Moore retailers across the United States. Sherwin-Williams, as of 2024, boasts 3,925 store locations nationwide.
The key distinction lies in their ownership structure. Benjamin Moore operates through a network of independently owned retailers, while Sherwin-Williams stores are corporately managed. This means that Benjamin Moore product availability and offerings can vary slightly between locations.
Benjamin Moore’s locally owned model may appeal to consumers who prioritize supporting community businesses, while Sherwin-Williams’ extensive national footprint offers convenience and consistent service across locations.
Finding Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams Near You
Both Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore have convenient locations in Novi, MI.
Color Selection: A Spectrum of Options
When it comes to color palettes, both Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams offer an expansive and impressive array of colors, ensuring that every homeowner can find their perfect shade. Neither brand holds a definitive advantage in color variety.
Color Consultation Services
Benjamin Moore Color Consultations
Benjamin Moore offers in-store color consultations for $99 for 30 minutes. This service includes expert advice from a color specialist, a digital rendering of your space with the chosen colors, and up to 5 physical color swatches mailed to your home. Availability may vary by location.
Benjamin Moore also provides Virtual Color Consultations via a 30-minute Zoom call. Virtual consultations for interior rooms are $50 per room and include 5 color swatches. Exterior virtual consultations are $60 and include 8 swatches.
Sherwin-Williams Color Consultations
Sherwin-Williams also offers a complimentary 30-minute Virtual Color Consultation, providing expert color recommendations, color samples, and a personalized color plan.
Members of Sherwin-Williams’ PaintPerks™ program can access in-home color consultations for $95, which include the same benefits as virtual consultations, plus a $50 gift card and a detailed shopping list.
Color Matching Capabilities
Both Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams possess advanced color-matching technology and can accurately match colors from either brand due to shared colorant formulas. Both brands excel in color matching, ensuring homeowners can achieve their desired custom shades with precision. This capability empowers homeowners to realize their unique vision for their living spaces.
Paint Sheen Options
Both brands offer a comparable range of paint sheens, although the names may differ slightly. Certain product lines may also feature unique sheen classifications.
Choosing the Right Paint Sheen
Different paint sheens are best suited for specific applications and areas of the home. For instance, eggshell sheens are versatile and work well in most rooms, while high-gloss sheens are ideal for cabinets and trim. Consulting with paint experts at Benjamin Moore or Sherwin-Williams stores is recommended to determine the optimal paint sheen for your project.
Exploring the Best Benjamin Moore Paints
Benjamin Moore’s Regal Select paint line is widely recognized as a top-tier choice for several compelling reasons:
- It provides exceptional coverage and a beautiful, durable finish.
- It is known for its longevity, ease of application, and simple cleanup.
- It is available in a vast spectrum of colors.
- Benjamin Moore backs Regal Select with a lifetime warranty.
- The average price for Regal Select is around $66 per gallon, but pricing can fluctuate depending on the retailer.
Benjamin Moore Ben vs. Regal Select
Within the Benjamin Moore product family, Ben and Regal Select represent two excellent options catering to different needs and budgets.
Ben is Benjamin Moore’s value-oriented paint line.
- It offers good coverage and a satisfactory finish, but it lacks the premium feel of Regal Select.
- Ben is a solid choice for budget-conscious projects.
Regal Select is Benjamin Moore’s premium paint offering.
- It applies smoothly, delivers superior coverage, and dries to a luxurious matte finish.
- While more expensive than Ben, Regal Select is the preferred option for achieving the highest quality results.
Benjamin Moore Advance Trim Paint
Benjamin Moore’s Advance Trim Paint is a water-based enamel specifically formulated for trim and cabinetry.
- It provides a smooth, furniture-like finish that resists cracking and peeling.
- Key advantages include low odor and easy water cleanup.
- It can be applied by brush, roller, or sprayer.
- A potential drawback is its higher price point compared to other trim paints.
- It typically requires two coats for optimal coverage and has a slower drying time.
Discovering the Best Sherwin-Williams Paints
Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint is a popular and budget-friendly option, renowned for its extensive color selection.
- It is self-priming, simplifying the painting process.
- SuperPaint offers good durability and is particularly recommended for areas exposed to high sunlight.
- It is easy to clean and suitable for DIY projects.
- Potential downsides include its water-thinnable formulation, which can sometimes lead to streaks and a less-than-perfectly smooth finish.
- It may require multiple coats when covering dark colors.
Sherwin-Williams Duration vs. Emerald
Duration and Emerald represent Sherwin-Williams’ premium paint lines.
- Both Duration and Emerald offer outstanding coverage and durability, backed by lifetime warranties.
- They impart a beautiful, high-end aesthetic to homes.
- These paints are best suited for professional application due to their advanced formulations.
- Both paints require a degree of skill to work with effectively, making them ideal for experienced contractors.
Sherwin-Williams ProClassic Interior Paint
Sherwin-Williams ProClassic Interior Paint is a favored choice for interior trim and molding.
- It is a low-VOC paint.
- ProClassic delivers a smooth, even finish.
- A primary limitation is its limited resistance to stains and moisture.
- It is also a relatively expensive option, ranging from $40 to $90 per gallon.
Choosing Paint as a Pro vs. a DIY Homeowner
Alt text: A DIY homeowner expertly painting an interior wall using a paint roller.
For professional painters, the ideal paint brand:
- Exhibits consistent flow and application characteristics with brushes and rollers.
- Features a reliable color tinting system ensuring excellent coverage and color consistency across gallons.
- Is supported by knowledgeable and readily accessible paint professionals.
For DIY homeowners, the best paint brand:
- Is self-priming for simplified application.
- Provides excellent coverage to minimize coats.
- Is reasonably priced to fit within a home improvement budget.
Ultimately, select the paint brand that offers the product best aligned with your specific project needs and financial considerations. However, investing in higher-quality paint is generally a wiser decision than opting for budget paints. No one wants to regret the time and money spent on a paint job due to premature wear or subpar results.
The Final Verdict: Benjamin Moore or Sherwin-Williams?
In the Benjamin Moore vs. Sherwin-Williams paint debate, there is no definitive winner. Both brands are exceptional choices and can be used effectively as the best paint for various siding types.
So, is Sherwin-Williams or Benjamin Moore superior?
Both Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams offer outstanding service and premium-quality interior and exterior paints.
Remember, the optimal paint for your project depends on a combination of factors, including the surface being painted, the local climate in Novi, Michigan, and your specific aesthetic and functional requirements. Regardless of whether you choose Benjamin Moore or Sherwin-Williams, prioritizing quality paint will ensure a beautiful, long-lasting, and value-enhancing finish for your home.
Experience the Highest Quality Paint and Service with Tribble Painting Company in Novi, MI
At Tribble Painting, we are passionate about paint and dedicated to delivering unparalleled service and products to our valued clients.
That’s why Tribble Painting exclusively utilizes the highest quality paints available and backs all our work with a 100% satisfaction guarantee.
Our team of skilled painters is ready to assist you in enhancing the beauty of your home with a fresh, flawless coat of paint.
