Every year, the tech world eagerly anticipates the next iteration of smartphone giants, and Samsung’s Galaxy Ultra series is always a highlight. The recent arrival of the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra has inevitably sparked the question: how does it truly stack up against its formidable predecessor, the Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra? A thorough Compare S23 Ultra And S24 Ultra analysis is essential to determine if Samsung has delivered enough innovation to warrant an upgrade.
The Galaxy S23 Ultra, a former champion recognized as the best phone and best camera phone, set a high benchmark with its exceptional camera system and comprehensive feature set. However, the Galaxy S24 Ultra enters the arena with a clear shift in focus towards AI-driven enhancements, aiming to redefine the flagship experience.
While reviewing the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra review, the integrated AI capabilities impressed with their intuitiveness and potential. Yet, a key point of discussion revolves around Samsung’s decision to replace the S23 Ultra’s 10x optical zoom camera with a 5x zoom lens. Is this a step back, or can AI and advanced image processing bridge the gap?
This in-depth Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra vs. Galaxy S23 Ultra comparison will delve into this critical camera question and explore other pivotal aspects. We’ll scrutinize their software, battery performance, display quality, and overall capabilities to provide a definitive answer to whether the Galaxy S24 Ultra is a worthy successor and if upgrading from the S23 Ultra makes sense for you.
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra vs. S23 Ultra: Specifications
Swipe to scroll horizontally
| Feature | Galaxy S24 Ultra | Galaxy S23 Ultra |
|---|---|---|
| Starting Price | $1,299 | $1,199 |
| Chipset | Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 for Galaxy | Snapdragon 8 Gen 2 for Galaxy |
| RAM | 12GB | 8GB/12GB |
| Storage Options | 256GB, 512GB, 1TB | 256GB, 512GB, 1TB |
| Display | 6.8-inch QHD+ AMOLED (1-120Hz) | 6.8-inch QHD+ AMOLED (1-120Hz) |
| Rear Camera System | 200MP Main, 12MP Ultrawide, 10MP 3x Telephoto, 50MP 5x Telephoto | 200MP Main, 12MP Ultrawide, 10MP 3x Telephoto, 10MP 10x Telephoto |
| Front Camera | 12MP | 12MP |
| Color Choices | Titanium Black, Titanium Gray, Titanium Violet, Titanium Yellow | Phantom Black, Cotton Flower, Botanic Green, Mystic Lilac, Lime, Sky Blue, Graphite, Red |
| Battery Capacity | 5,000 mAh | 5,000 mAh |
| Charging Speed | 45W | 45W |
| Dimensions | 6.4 x 3.11 x 0.34 inches | 6.4 x 3 x 0.35 inches |
| Weight | 8.22 ounces | 8.25 ounces |
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra vs. S23 Ultra: Price and Availability
The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra hit the market on January 31, 2024, succeeding the Galaxy S23 Ultra’s launch on February 17, 2023. Both are readily available through Samsung’s official channels and major retailers.
Reflecting the trend of rising prices in the flagship phone segment, the Galaxy S24 Ultra sees a $100 price increase compared to its predecessor. The S24 Ultra starts at $1,299, while the S23 Ultra debuted at $1,199. However, Samsung frequently offers attractive trade-in deals, potentially reducing the S24 Ultra’s price to as low as $669. While these promotions are compelling for a brand-new device, the S23 Ultra has been spotted at even lower prices, sometimes reaching $299 during special sales events.
Both models come in 256GB, 512GB, and 1TB storage configurations. A notable difference is that the Galaxy S24 Ultra standardizes 12GB of RAM across all storage options, whereas the S23 Ultra offers 8GB or 12GB RAM depending on the configuration.
In terms of aesthetics, the Galaxy S24 Ultra presents a curated palette of 4 titanium-infused colors, while the S23 Ultra boasts a wider selection of 8 colors. The S24 Ultra’s titanium violet and titanium yellow options offer a more vibrant and premium feel.
Winner: Galaxy S23 Ultra (due to potentially lower price points and wider color variety)
Galaxy S24 Ultra: was $1,419 now $669 w/trade-in @ Best Buy While the hardware upgrades are iterative, it’s in the software that differentiates the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra. From its new Circle to Search function to Google things easier on the phone, to the incredible editing abilities of Generative Edit, the various Galaxy AI features do make for a much more satisfying experience that saves you time.
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra vs. S23 Ultra: Design
(Image credit: Future)
Alt text: Side-by-side comparison of Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and S23 Ultra designs, highlighting subtle differences in frame and screen.
While the Galaxy S24 Ultra maintains a familiar design language, Samsung has implemented subtle yet impactful refinements.
The most significant material change is the swap from the S23 Ultra’s armor aluminum frame to a titanium frame on the S24 Ultra. This upgrade contributes to enhanced durability and a slightly lighter weight of 8.22 ounces, compared to the S23 Ultra’s 8.25 ounces. Though the weight difference is minimal, it is perceptible when holding both devices.
Another key design evolution is the Galaxy S24 Ultra’s adoption of a completely flat display, departing from the curved screens that have long been a signature of the Galaxy S series. Samsung argues this flat screen enhances the S Pen experience, preventing slippage near the edges. Opinions are divided on this change, as the curved display of the S23 Ultra offered a sleeker aesthetic to some users.
Furthermore, Samsung has trimmed the bezels around the S24 Ultra’s display by 42%. This reduction is most noticeable at the bottom edge, allowing the screen to extend closer to the phone’s periphery and contributing to a more immersive visual experience. The front-facing 12MP camera cutout is also marginally smaller.
Overall, the design modifications in the S24 Ultra, while not radical, culminate in a more polished and refined appearance.
Winner: Galaxy S24 Ultra (for enhanced materials and refined design details)
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra vs. S23 Ultra: Display
(Image credit: Future)
Alt text: Display comparison showing Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and S23 Ultra screens with vibrant colors and excellent viewing angles.
A specification-based comparison of the Galaxy S24 Ultra vs. S23 Ultra reveals that both devices feature identical 6.8-inch QHD+ Dynamic AMOLED 2X displays. Pixel density remains consistent, ensuring exceptional sharpness and detail on both screens. Both also offer the same adaptive 1-120Hz refresh rate for smooth scrolling and optimized battery efficiency.
When viewing visual content, such as the “Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga” trailer, both phones exhibit exceptional viewing angles and impressive contrast, making the trailer visually striking in full-screen mode. However, the Galaxy S24 Ultra demonstrates a subtly brighter display.
Swipe to scroll horizontally
| Display Metric | Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra | Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra |
|---|---|---|
| Delta-E Color Accuracy (lower is better) | 0.25 | 0.3 |
| DCI-P3 Color Gamut Coverage (%) | 98.5 | 112.2 |
| Peak Brightness (nits) | 1,363 | 1,225 |
In Tom’s Guide’s display benchmark tests, the Galaxy S24 Ultra achieved a peak brightness of 1,363 nits, exceeding the S23 Ultra’s 1,225 nits. While this measured brightness falls short of Samsung’s advertised peak of 2,600 nits, it still represents a tangible, albeit incremental, improvement in display brightness for the newer Galaxy. The S24 Ultra also edges out the S23 Ultra in color accuracy, although the S23 Ultra shows a slightly wider color gamut coverage.
Winner: Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra (for slightly brighter and more color-accurate display)
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra vs. S23 Ultra: Cameras
(Image credit: Future)
Alt text: Close-up comparison of Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and S23 Ultra rear camera modules, highlighting the quad-camera setup on both phones.
Having extensively used the Galaxy S23 Ultra for nearly a year, it proved to be a reliable and high-quality backup camera. With the Galaxy S24 Ultra, Samsung has made a potentially divisive camera decision that might influence user preference.
The Galaxy S24 Ultra’s quad-camera system comprises a 200MP primary sensor, a 12MP ultrawide lens, a 10MP telephoto lens with 3x optical zoom, and a new 50MP telephoto lens with 5x optical zoom. The point of contention lies in the replacement of the S23 Ultra’s 10MP telephoto lens with 10x optical zoom with this new 5x zoom lens. The S23 Ultra’s setup included a 200MP main camera, 12MP ultrawide, 10MP 3x telephoto, and the 10MP 10x telephoto.
The shift from a 10x to a 5x optical zoom on the S24 Ultra might initially seem like a downgrade. However, Samsung argues that the larger sensor on the new 5x telephoto lens, coupled with advanced processing, delivers comparable optical-quality performance to the S23 Ultra’s 10x lens in many scenarios.
To provide a comprehensive camera compare s23 ultra and s24 ultra, over 200 photos were taken with both devices in various modes and lighting conditions.
In standard main camera shots, the differences between the S24 Ultra and S23 Ultra are minimal. Detail reproduction is virtually identical, as seen in shots of fruit displays, with the S24 Ultra exhibiting slightly brighter images. The S24 Ultra tends to expose brighter, while the S23 Ultra leans towards stronger contrast.
The S24 Ultra shows improvements in portrait mode, producing images with warmer color temperatures, enhanced contrast, and richer colors. While both offer background blur, the S23 Ultra’s portrait shots can appear somewhat muted and less vibrant with a cooler color tone.
In low-light conditions, the Galaxy S24 Ultra’s larger sensor and bigger pixels enable it to capture more light, resulting in brighter images, as demonstrated in photos of a detached garage. The improvement is noticeable, though not dramatic.
However, when comparing long-range zoom capabilities, particularly at 10x zoom, the S23 Ultra maintains an edge. While the S24 Ultra produces brighter images at 10x, thanks to its newer sensor, the S23 Ultra retains finer details, especially in textures like brickwork on buildings.
At extreme zoom levels like 100x, the S23 Ultra’s detail advantage becomes more pronounced. While the S24 Ultra’s 100x shots are still respectable for a digitally zoomed image, the S23 Ultra captures noticeably more intricate details, leveraging its dedicated 10x optical zoom lens.
Galaxy S24 Ultra: Zoom test – YouTube
Galaxy S23 Ultra: Zoom test – YouTube
Video recording capabilities are similar, with both phones supporting up to 8K resolution. In 4K 30fps video, the S24 Ultra’s 5x optical zoom, combined with improved stabilization, delivers comparable zoom performance to the S23 Ultra, which can be more sensitive to hand shake at higher zoom levels.
In low-light video, the S24 Ultra’s brighter sensor again contributes to brighter footage. The S24 Ultra’s zoom camera also performs well in low light, albeit with some increased noise.
Image 1 of 2
(Image credit: Future)
Alt text: Example of Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra Generative Edit feature in action, showing AI-powered photo editing.
(Image credit: Future)
Alt text: Another example of Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra Generative Edit, showcasing AI’s ability to seamlessly alter image content.
While the Galaxy S24 Ultra’s camera system isn’t a radical departure from the S23 Ultra, and arguably a sidegrade in terms of long-range zoom, it introduces powerful Galaxy AI-driven photo and video editing features.
Generative Edit is a standout feature that uses generative AI to fill in missing image areas convincingly. For instance, resizing or repositioning objects in a photo results in a realistic background fill. This AI-powered editing capability simplifies complex edits that would be time-consuming to perform manually on the S23 Ultra.
Samsung Galaxy S24 Instant Slow-Mo Mode Sample – YouTube
Instant Slow-mo is another valuable Galaxy AI feature that allows users to apply a slow-motion effect to any recorded video after capture. Galaxy AI intelligently generates the necessary frames to create smooth and convincing slow-motion footage, even from regular speed videos.
Image 1 of 2
(Image credit: Future)
Alt text: Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra Edit Suggestions feature demonstrating AI-powered reflection removal from ultrawide camera photos.
(Image credit: Future)
Alt text: Another example of Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra Edit Suggestions, showing AI’s ability to refine ultrawide photos with ease.
Edit Suggestions leverages Galaxy AI to automatically remove unwanted reflections from photos, a feature that works effectively in scenarios like shooting through windows.
Winner: Galaxy S24 Ultra (for overall camera performance and innovative AI editing features, despite the 5x zoom trade-off)
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra vs. S23 Ultra: Performance
(Image credit: Future)
Alt text: Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra in hand, showcasing its powerful performance and smooth user experience.
In day-to-day use, both the Galaxy S24 Ultra and S23 Ultra exhibit exceptional responsiveness and fluidity. Multitasking, app switching, and general productivity tasks are handled seamlessly on both devices.
However, synthetic benchmark tests reveal the Galaxy S24 Ultra’s performance advantage, powered by the Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 for Galaxy. In Geekbench 6, the S24 Ultra outperforms the Snapdragon 8 Gen 2-equipped S23 Ultra, particularly in multi-core performance.
Swipe to scroll horizontally
| Benchmark | Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra | Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra |
|---|---|---|
| Geekbench 6 CPU Test (Single-core/Multi-core) | 2,300 / 7,249 | 2,091 / 5,511 |
| 3DMark Wild Life Unlimited (Score/FPS) | 20,627 / 123.5 | 14,611 / 87.5 |
| Adobe Premiere Rush Transcode Time (mins:secs) | 0:42 | 0:39 |
The most significant performance leap is in graphics processing. The Galaxy S24 Ultra sets new records in 3DMark’s Wild Life Unlimited test, scoring a remarkable 20,627, significantly surpassing the S23 Ultra’s already impressive 14,611.
The Galaxy S24 Ultra also supports ray tracing and features an enhanced cooling system with a vapor chamber nearly double the size of the S23 Ultra’s. This results in improved sustained performance and cooler operation during graphically intensive tasks like gaming. Games like Diablo Immortal, which supports ray tracing, feel more responsive and visually immersive on the S24 Ultra.
Winner: Galaxy S24 Ultra (for superior processing and graphics performance)
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra vs. S23 Ultra: Battery Life and Charging
(Image credit: Future)
Alt text: Battery life comparison image for Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and S23 Ultra, highlighting the S24 Ultra’s improved endurance.
Samsung’s decision to maintain the same 5,000 mAh battery capacity in the Galaxy S24 Ultra as the S23 Ultra might seem surprising. However, the improved power efficiency of the Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 chipset makes a substantial difference in battery endurance.
In Tom’s Guide’s battery benchmark test, the Galaxy S24 Ultra achieved a significantly longer runtime of 16 hours and 45 minutes, compared to the S23 Ultra’s 13 hours and 9 minutes. This notable jump in battery life further solidifies the S24 Ultra’s position as the superior device.
While charging speeds remain at 45W wired and 15W wireless for both models, the Galaxy S24 Ultra demonstrates slightly faster wired charging. In 30 minutes, it reaches a 71% charge, while the S23 Ultra reaches 57%.
Winner: Galaxy S24 Ultra (for significantly improved battery life and slightly faster charging)
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra vs. S23 Ultra: Software
(Image credit: Tom’s Guide)
Alt text: Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra S Pen highlighting software integration and features like handwriting recognition.
Both phones run Samsung’s One UI 6.1 based on Android 14, offering a similar user interface and feature set. Core functionalities like the S Pen and Samsung DeX remain largely unchanged between the two models. However, Samsung’s commitment to providing 7 years of software and security updates for the Galaxy S24 Ultra is a significant advantage, offering extended software support.
The key software differentiator lies in the Galaxy S24 Ultra’s suite of Galaxy AI features. These AI-powered tools are designed to enhance productivity and user convenience.
(Image credit: Future)
Alt text: Samsung Galaxy S24 showcasing the Circle to Search feature, enabling quick information lookup directly from any screen.
Circle to Search streamlines information retrieval by allowing users to simply circle anything on the screen to initiate a Google search, eliminating the need to switch apps or copy and paste.
Live Translate provides real-time translation within apps like WhatsApp, facilitating seamless communication across language barriers. This feature is particularly useful for international interactions.
(Image credit: Future)
Alt text: Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra Voice Recorder app demonstrating AI-powered transcription and summarization features.
The Samsung Voice Recorder app incorporates Galaxy AI to not only transcribe audio recordings but also identify different speakers and summarize recordings, enhancing organization and note-taking capabilities.
Other Galaxy AI features, such as Chat Assist and Live Translate for phone calls, offer additional functionalities that may become more refined and useful over time.
While the Galaxy S23 Ultra is slated to receive some Galaxy AI features in a future update, the Galaxy S24 Ultra currently offers a more comprehensive and integrated AI experience.
Winner: Galaxy S24 Ultra (for its innovative and time-saving Galaxy AI features and extended software update promise)
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra vs. S23 Ultra: Verdict
(Image credit: Future)
Alt text: Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra with S Pen, symbolizing the verdict and recommendation for the upgraded device.
The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra presents two potential drawbacks: a $100 price increase and a perceived downgrade in long-range zoom capabilities with its 5x telephoto lens. Considering the incremental improvements in overall camera performance, one might question the value proposition of the S24 Ultra.
Swipe to scroll horizontally
| Feature Category | Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra Points | Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra Points |
|---|---|---|
| Price (15 points) | 11 | 13 |
| Design (10 points) | 9 | 8 |
| Display (15 points) | 12 | 11 |
| Cameras (20 points) | 18 | 17 |
| Performance (15 points) | 15 | 13 |
| Battery and Charging (10 points) | 8 | 6 |
| Software and Special Features (15 points) | 15 | 10 |
| Total (out of 100) | 88 | 78 |
However, the Galaxy S24 Ultra’s enhanced processing power via the Snapdragon 8 Gen 3, brighter display, and significantly improved battery life justify its higher price point. Furthermore, the inclusion of practical and intuitive Galaxy AI features solidifies the Galaxy S24 Ultra as a worthwhile upgrade over the S23 Ultra.
While the extent and effectiveness of Galaxy AI features coming to the S23 Ultra remain to be seen, and may influence the upgrade decision in the future, currently, choosing the newer Galaxy S24 Ultra is the clear recommendation. For users seeking the latest technology and a demonstrably superior flagship experience, the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra is the definitive winner in this compare s23 ultra and s24 ultra matchup.
