Choosing the right home security system is crucial for peace of mind. DIY home security systems have become increasingly popular, offering flexibility and affordability. Among the top contenders in the market are the Ring Alarm Pro and Ring Alarm (2nd Generation) systems. Both systems provide robust security features and are easy to install, but they cater to slightly different needs. This article provides a detailed comparison to help you decide which Ring Alarm system best suits your home security requirements.
The Ring Alarm system, showcasing the base station, sensor, and keypad, essential components of a modern home security setup.
Ring has established itself as a leader in home security, primarily known for its video doorbells and security cameras. Their alarm systems build upon this reputation, offering comprehensive protection that you can monitor and control yourself. Let’s delve into a comparison of the Ring Alarm Pro and Ring Alarm (2nd Gen) to understand their strengths and differences.
Ring Alarm Pro: The Comprehensive DIY Security Powerhouse
Ring Alarm Pro Kit, a top-tier DIY home security system providing advanced features and comprehensive protection for homeowners.
The Ring Alarm Pro is positioned as the most comprehensive DIY home security system in the Ring lineup. It stands out due to its integration of an Eero Wi-Fi 6 router directly into the base station. This dual functionality is a key differentiator, making it an excellent choice for users looking to upgrade both their home security and Wi-Fi network simultaneously.
Key Features of Ring Alarm Pro:
- Built-in Eero Wi-Fi 6 Router: This is perhaps the most significant advantage of the Pro system. It can replace your existing router or create a mesh network to enhance Wi-Fi coverage throughout your home.
- Internet and Power Backup: With a Ring Home Premium plan, the Eero router offers cellular internet backup in case of outages. The base station also includes a battery backup, ensuring your system remains operational during power failures.
- Versatile Compatibility: Ring Alarm Pro works with a wide array of security accessories, allowing for extensive customization based on your specific needs.
- Loud Siren: The system boasts a loud 104 dB siren, effectively deterring intruders and alerting neighbors.
- 24/7 Monitoring and Customer Service: Ring is unique in offering both 24/7 professional monitoring and customer service, providing constant support when you need it.
- Customizable Police Response: You have control over police dispatch, allowing you to verify alarms before requesting emergency services.
- Optional Professional Monitoring: While optional, professional monitoring is highly recommended and affordable compared to competitors.
Ring Alarm (2nd Generation): Simplicity and Affordability
Ring Alarm 2nd Generation 5-Piece Kit, a user-friendly and budget-conscious home security solution ideal for straightforward security needs.
The Ring Alarm (2nd Generation) is designed for users who want a reliable, easy-to-use home security system without the integrated router feature. It offers similar security capabilities to the Pro version but at a more accessible price point.
Key Features of Ring Alarm (2nd Generation):
- Ease of Use: Setting up and using the Ring Alarm (2nd Gen) is straightforward, making it ideal for users new to DIY security systems.
- Affordability: It is generally priced lower than the Pro version, making it a budget-friendly option.
- Extensive Camera Add-ons: Ring offers a broader range of camera options compatible with this system compared to other brands.
- Loudest Siren in Test Group: Surprisingly, the original Ring Alarm has an even louder siren at 113 dB compared to the Pro version.
- 24/7 Monitoring and Customer Service: Like the Pro, it offers round-the-clock monitoring and customer support.
- Optional Professional Monitoring: Professional monitoring plans are available at the same affordable rates as the Pro system.
Feature Comparison Table: Ring Alarm Pro vs. Ring Alarm (2nd Gen)
To provide a clearer comparison, here’s a table highlighting the key differences and similarities between the two systems:
| Feature | Ring Alarm Pro | Ring Alarm (2nd Gen) |
|---|---|---|
| Built-in Wi-Fi Router | Yes (Eero Wi-Fi 6) | No |
| Internet Backup | Yes (Cellular, with Premium Plan) | No (Cellular backup available as add-on with Ring Power Packs) |
| Power Backup | Yes (Base Station Battery) | Yes (Base Station Battery) |
| Siren Loudness | 104 dB | 113 dB |
| Smart Home Integration | Amazon Alexa, Works with Ring | Amazon Alexa, Works with Ring |
| Professional Monitoring | Optional, Affordable | Optional, Affordable |
| Price | Higher | Lower |
| Ease of Use | Easy | Very Easy |
Monitoring Plans and Costs
Both Ring Alarm systems offer flexible monitoring options. You can choose to self-monitor, receiving smartphone alerts when the alarm is triggered. However, to arm and disarm the system via the app, a Ring Protect plan is required. Professional monitoring, which includes 24/7 monitoring and cellular backup, is an affordable add-on to these plans.
- Ring Protect Basic: Starts at $3.99/month or $39.99/year per location. Includes video recording for one camera and event history.
- Ring Protect Plus: Starts at $10/month or $100/year per location. Includes professional monitoring, cellular backup, video recording for all cameras, extended warranties, and 10% off Ring products.
- Ring Protect Pro: Starts at $20/month or $200/year per location. Includes all Plus features, plus 24/7 Backup Internet, Extra Data for Backup Internet, and Ring Edge.
The Ring Protect Plus and Pro plans are particularly attractive due to their inclusion of professional monitoring at a competitive price.
Advantages of Choosing Ring Alarm Systems
Regardless of whether you choose the Pro or 2nd Gen system, Ring Alarm offers several compelling advantages:
- Loud Sirens: Both systems feature sirens that are among the loudest in the DIY security market, providing a strong deterrent.
- Reliable Performance: User reviews and tests confirm the systems are reliable, with quick alerts and effective alarm triggering.
- Comprehensive Customer Support: Ring’s 24/7 customer service sets it apart from many competitors, ensuring help is always available.
- Wide Range of Accessories: Ring’s ecosystem includes a vast selection of compatible accessories, including sensors, cameras, and smart lighting, allowing for a highly customized security setup.
- Improved Privacy Features: Ring has taken steps to enhance privacy, including offering end-to-end encryption for cameras and improved control over law enforcement requests.
Considerations Before You Buy
While Ring Alarm systems are highly rated, there are a few factors to consider:
- Subscription Dependency: To fully utilize the app’s functionality and professional monitoring, a subscription plan is practically essential.
- App Ecosystem: The Ring Alarm Pro requires using both the Ring app and the Eero app to manage all features, which might be slightly less streamlined for some users.
- Limited Smart Home Integration: Ring’s integration is primarily within the Amazon ecosystem and “Works with Ring” devices, which may be restrictive for users heavily invested in other smart home platforms.
Conclusion: Which Ring Alarm System is Right for You?
Choosing between the Ring Alarm Pro and Ring Alarm (2nd Gen) depends on your specific needs and priorities.
Choose Ring Alarm Pro if:
- You need to upgrade your Wi-Fi router and want a seamless integration with your security system.
- Internet backup is a critical requirement for your home security.
- You desire the most feature-rich DIY security system from Ring.
Choose Ring Alarm (2nd Gen) if:
- You are looking for a more affordable and straightforward home security solution.
- You already have a satisfactory Wi-Fi router setup and don’t need the integrated Eero router.
- Ease of use and simplicity are your top priorities.
Both Ring Alarm systems are excellent choices for DIY home security. By comparing their features and considering your individual needs, you can select the system that will provide the best protection and peace of mind for your home and family.
