Compare and Contrast: Mastering the Art of Analytical Writing

What is Compare and Contrast Writing?

In your academic journey, you’ll encounter various types of writing assignments, each demanding a unique approach. Among the most common is the Compare And Contrast essay. This type of essay delves into the similarities (comparison) and differences (contrast) between subjects, ideas, or objects – typically two. Instructors assign these essays to cultivate your critical thinking, encourage you to forge connections between concepts, and push you beyond simple description. By carefully examining both the common ground and the diverging paths of your subjects, you achieve a richer understanding of each, their relationship to one another, and their most salient characteristics. This process of analytical exploration makes compare and contrast essays a valuable tool for deeper learning.

Identifying Compare and Contrast Assignments

Sometimes, assignment prompts explicitly signal a compare and contrast task using keywords like “compare,” “contrast,” “similarities,” and “differences.” Here are some illustrative examples:

• Compare and contrast the economic policies of the United States and China.
• Analyze the similarities and differences in the leadership styles of two prominent CEOs.
• Contrast the themes of love and loss in Shakespeare’s sonnets and Petrarch’s sonnets.

Notice how some prompts focus solely on comparison, others solely on contrast, and some on both. Recognizing these keywords makes it straightforward to identify a compare and contrast assignment.

However, not all prompts are this direct. Sometimes, the need to compare and contrast is implied. In other instances, it might be a stepping stone within a larger essay, where you first compare and contrast to build a foundation for a more complex argument or evaluation. Consider these examples where the compare and contrast element might be less obvious but still present:

• Discuss how two different scientific theories explain the same phenomenon. (Implies comparison and contrast of theories).
• Analyze the portrayal of family dynamics in two novels from different cultural backgrounds. (Requires comparing and contrasting cultural perspectives and narrative approaches).
• Examine the approaches to environmental conservation taken by two different countries. Which approach is more effective? (Combines comparison/contrast with evaluation).
• Explore the common themes found in poems written during World War I by soldiers from opposing sides of the conflict. What might explain any observed differences? (Combines comparison/contrast to identify commonalities and explain divergences).

For further guidance on deciphering assignment prompts, you might find resources on understanding academic assignments helpful.

Leveraging Compare and Contrast for Broader Writing Projects

Even when not explicitly required, employing compare and contrast techniques during your pre-writing phase can be incredibly beneficial. It can spark ideas and strengthen arguments for various types of essays. For instance, if you aim to argue that one economic model is superior to another, comparing and contrasting their core principles, strengths, and weaknesses can provide a solid framework for your evaluation. This preliminary exploration, even if the generated lists of similarities and differences don’t directly appear in your final paper, significantly enhances your analytical depth and argumentative power.

Uncovering Similarities and Differences: Effective Techniques

Visual aids like Venn diagrams and comparison charts are invaluable for efficiently organizing your thoughts when comparing and contrasting multiple items or concepts.

Venn Diagram: To create a Venn diagram, draw overlapping circles, one for each item you’re analyzing. The overlapping section becomes the space to list shared traits. The non-overlapping sections are dedicated to listing unique characteristics of each item. Here’s a simple example comparing two types of coffee:

Venn diagram illustrating the commonalities and differences between Arabica and Robusta coffee beans.

Comparison Chart: To create a comparison chart, identify the key criteria you want to evaluate across your subjects. List these criteria vertically along the left side of a page. Horizontally across the top, list your subjects. This creates a matrix where each cell allows you to detail specific aspects of each subject based on your chosen criteria. This method is particularly useful for structured, multi-faceted comparisons.

Here’s an example comparing different types of renewable energy sources:

As you brainstorm comparison points, always consider the assignment’s purpose, the course content, and your instructor’s expectations. What key learning outcomes is the comparison designed to achieve? How does it connect to broader themes studied in the course? Are there any clues within the assignment itself that guide your focus?

To stimulate your thinking, here are general questions applicable to various comparison subjects. These are starting points, not exhaustive lists. Adapt and expand upon them to suit your specific topics. Consider using the classic journalistic questions: Who? What? Where? When? Why? How? When comparing physical objects, think about properties like size, shape, color, sound, weight, texture, smell, quantity, duration, and location.

Comparing Historical Periods or Events:

• Timeline: When did each occur? What are their start and end dates? What were the key phases or turning points within each? What significant changes or continuities define each period? What is their overall historical significance?
• Social Structures: What types of work did people engage in? What were the dominant social relationships? What values and beliefs were central to each period’s culture?
• Political Systems: What forms of government existed? Who were the key figures and leaders? How was power distributed and exercised?
• Causation and Consequence: What were the primary causes and contributing factors leading to these events or periods? What were their immediate and long-term consequences? How did they shape subsequent historical developments?

Comparing Ideas or Theories:

• Core Concepts: What are the fundamental principles and concepts of each idea or theory? What specific phenomena or questions do they address?
• Origins and Proponents: When and where did these ideas originate? Who were the key thinkers and developers associated with them? Who are their current proponents or critics?
• Central Arguments and Goals: What are the main claims, arguments, or propositions of each idea or theory? What are their primary goals or objectives? What conclusions do they reach?
• Application and Scope: How are these ideas applied to real-world situations, populations, or phenomena? What are their practical implications? How broad is their scope of explanation?
• Plausibility and Evidence: Which idea or theory appears more convincing or well-supported to you, and why? What types of evidence are typically used to support or refute them?

Comparing Literary or Artistic Works:

• Descriptive Elements: What are the titles of the works? What subjects, scenes, or ideas do they depict or describe? What is the genre or medium of each work?
• Emotional and Stylistic Qualities: What is the overall tone or mood conveyed by each work? What artistic style or literary form is employed?
• Creators and Context: Who created these works? When were they created, and in what historical, cultural, or social context? What might have been the creator’s intentions or influences?
• Evaluation and Merit: Do you perceive one work to be of higher artistic quality or significance than the other(s)? If so, based on what criteria?
• Literary Elements (for writing): Analyze plot structure, character development, setting, thematic concerns, narrative voice, and literary devices employed in each work.

Comparing Individuals:

• Biographical Background: Where are they from? What is their age or lifespan? What are their key demographic characteristics (gender, race, social class, etc.)?
• Significance and Relationships: What are they known for or famous for? Do they have any direct or indirect relationship to each other?
• Personal Qualities and Actions: What are their personality traits and defining characteristics? What actions have they taken or accomplishments have they achieved? What are their beliefs and values? Why are they considered noteworthy or interesting?
• Key Distinctions: What are the most striking or significant aspects that differentiate these individuals? What makes each person unique or memorable?

Selecting Your Focus: Relevance and Significance

By this stage, you’ve likely compiled an extensive list of similarities and differences – excellent work! Now comes the crucial step of selecting which points are most pertinent, insightful, and worthy of inclusion in your essay. Ask yourself these critical questions to refine your focus:

• Assignment Relevance: Which points directly address the specific requirements and aims of the assignment?
• Course Context: Which points align with the major themes, concepts, and discussions within the course?
• Insight and Interest: Which points are genuinely interesting, informative, and likely to engage your reader?
• Argumentative Value: Which points contribute most effectively to the argument or thesis you intend to develop?
• Essential Information: Which points are fundamental or necessary to mention, even if they seem obvious?
• Overall Emphasis: In the context of your analysis, are the similarities or the differences ultimately more significant or revealing?

For example, when comparing two novels in a literature class, focusing on their typeface would likely be irrelevant unless your essay is about book design. Similarly, superficial details like the presence of illustrations are less important than elements such as character development, plot structure, setting, authorial style, and thematic depth. However, if your essay were for a typography or illustration course, these aspects might become central.

Sometimes, a point of comparison might be relevant but lack depth or originality. For instance, stating that both Wordsworth’s “Tintern Abbey” and Coleridge’s “Frost at Midnight” explore nature is relevant for a poetry comparison but not particularly insightful, given the Romantic poets’ well-known focus on nature. Instead, delve into how nature is portrayed differently, or which aspects of nature each poem emphasizes. This demonstrates a more nuanced and sophisticated understanding.

Crafting a Strong Thesis Statement

The thesis statement is the backbone of your compare and contrast essay. It provides focus, direction, and a roadmap for your reader. Avoid vague, generic statements like “This paper will compare two types of coffee” or “Coffee A and Coffee B are similar and different.” Instead, aim for a thesis that is specific, analytical, and ideally, argumentative. For example: “While both Arabica and Robusta beans offer caffeine, Arabica beans are distinguished by their smoother flavor profile and higher acidity, making them preferable for specialty coffee, whereas Robusta’s bolder, more bitter taste and hardier growing conditions make it ideal for instant coffee and coffee blends.”

Even this improved thesis could be strengthened by adding a layer of analysis: “While Arabica and Robusta beans share caffeine content, their contrasting flavor profiles—Arabica’s nuanced sweetness versus Robusta’s robust bitterness—reflect their distinct cultivation environments and target consumer markets, highlighting how geographical and economic factors shape even seemingly simple commodities like coffee.”

Consider why your chosen subjects and points of comparison are significant. What broader understanding or insight do you want to convey? Thinking about the “so what?” question will elevate your thesis from descriptive to analytical. You may find resources on constructing effective thesis statements helpful.

Structuring Your Essay: Organizational Strategies

Several effective organizational patterns exist for compare and contrast essays. Here are two primary methods:

Subject-by-Subject (Block Method)

This method dedicates separate sections to each subject. You discuss all aspects of your first subject, then transition to discuss all aspects of your second subject (and subsequent subjects, if comparing more than two). For shorter essays, each subject might be covered in a single paragraph. For longer essays, each subject will likely require multiple paragraphs.

Using our coffee bean comparison example, a subject-by-subject structure might look like this:

1. Introduction: Thesis statement comparing Arabica and Robusta beans.
2. Arabica Beans: Paragraphs discussing origin, flavor profile, growing conditions, common uses.
3. Robusta Beans: Paragraphs discussing origin, flavor profile, growing conditions, common uses.
4. Conclusion: Summarizing key differences and reinforcing the thesis.

The drawback of this method is that it can sometimes lead to a list-like structure, where the direct comparison between subjects is less pronounced. To mitigate this, ensure your thesis is strongly analytical and include a concluding section that explicitly draws connections and contrasts across subjects, synthesizing the points made in each section.

Subject-by-subject organization is particularly suitable for “lens” comparisons. In this approach, one subject (the “lens”) is used to better understand another, often less familiar, subject. For instance, you might compare a well-known historical event to a less-studied event to illuminate the latter. You would first provide a concise overview of the familiar event (the lens), and then dedicate the majority of your essay to analyzing the less familiar event through the framework established by the lens.

Point-by-Point (Alternating Method)

This method focuses on specific points of comparison, discussing each point in relation to all your subjects in turn. The structure can vary depending on the depth of analysis for each point. For shorter essays, a single paragraph might address one point of comparison across all subjects. For more in-depth analysis, you might dedicate separate paragraphs to each subject’s aspect of a particular point.

Using our coffee bean example again, a point-by-point structure could be:

1. Introduction: Thesis statement comparing Arabica and Robusta beans.
2. Flavor Profile: Paragraph comparing and contrasting the taste characteristics of Arabica and Robusta.
3. Growing Conditions: Paragraph comparing and contrasting the environmental requirements for cultivating Arabica and Robusta.
4. Common Uses: Paragraph comparing and contrasting how each type of bean is typically used in coffee products.
5. Conclusion: Summarizing key differences and reinforcing the thesis.

Alternatively, with more detail per point, you might structure it as:

1. Introduction: Thesis statement.
2. Flavor Profile – Arabica: Detailed paragraph on Arabica flavor.
3. Flavor Profile – Robusta: Detailed paragraph on Robusta flavor, directly contrasting with Arabica.
4. Growing Conditions – Arabica: Paragraph on Arabica cultivation.
5. Growing Conditions – Robusta: Paragraph on Robusta cultivation, contrasting with Arabica.
6. Common Uses – Arabica: Paragraph on Arabica uses.
7. Common Uses – Robusta: Paragraph on Robusta uses, contrasting with Arabica.
8. Conclusion: Synthesis and thesis reinforcement.

The point-by-point method excels at creating a clear, direct comparison, as it juxtaposes subjects within each paragraph. Remember, there are no rigid rules. The most important factor is clarity for your reader. Ensure your structure allows them to easily follow your comparison and understand your analysis. Consider the strategic placement of your points. If your essay aims to argue for the superiority of one subject, conclude with a point that highlights its strengths. Conversely, if emphasizing differences is key, end with a contrasting point.

Resources on essay organization can further assist you in crafting effective topic sentences, transitions, and overall essay structure.

Transition Words and Helpful Phrases

To guide your reader smoothly through your comparison and contrast, use strong transitions and clear topic sentences. Your thesis provides an initial roadmap, but strategic use of cue words and phrases will enhance clarity and flow.

Useful transition words and phrases for comparison and contrast:

• Comparison: like, similar to, also, similarly, in the same way, likewise, again, compared to, in like manner, both, each, equally.
• Contrast: unlike, in contrast, contrasted with, on the contrary, however, although, yet, even though, still, but, nevertheless, conversely, at the same time, regardless, despite, while, whereas, on the one hand … on the other hand, different from, in opposition to.

Examples of topic sentences using cue words:

• In contrast to Arabica beans, Robusta beans exhibit a much bolder and more bitter flavor profile.
• Similar to Arabica, Robusta beans also contain caffeine, though typically in higher concentrations.
• While both types of beans require specific climate conditions, Arabica beans, unlike Robusta, are more delicate and thrive at higher altitudes.

This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0

You may reproduce it for non-commercial use if you use the entire handout and attribute the source: The Writing Center, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

Make a Gift