When you’re in the market for a new vehicle, safety is often a top priority. Vehicle safety scores are designed to help consumers make informed decisions, but understanding how to properly compare these scores is crucial. It’s not as simple as just looking at star ratings; there are important factors to consider to ensure you’re making a meaningful comparison between two vehicles.
Decoding Overall Vehicle Scores
The Overall Vehicle Score, often presented as a star rating, is a comprehensive assessment of a vehicle’s safety performance. This score is derived from a combination of crash test results, including frontal and side impact ratings, and rollover resistance evaluations. These individual probabilities of injury are weighted to reflect the real-world frequency of different types of crashes. The result is then compared to the average injury risk across all vehicles on the road. This comparison determines whether a specific vehicle poses a higher or lower than average risk of injury.
Star ratings for Overall Vehicle Scores are categorized as follows:
- ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐: Significantly lower than average injury risk
- ⭐⭐⭐⭐: Lower than average to average injury risk
- ⭐⭐⭐: Average to greater than average injury risk
- ⭐⭐: Greater than average injury risk
- ⭐: Significantly greater than average injury risk
Rules for Meaningful Vehicle Comparisons
While Overall Vehicle Scores provide a helpful summary, it’s vital to understand the limitations when you Compare 2 Vehicles. Direct comparisons are only valid under specific conditions related to vehicle class and weight.
Weight Class Consideration
A fundamental rule is that you can only accurately compare vehicles that are within a similar weight range. Specifically, the weights of the two vehicles being compared should not differ by more than 250 pounds. Comparing vehicles with significantly different weights can be misleading because crash forces and vehicle dynamics change considerably with weight variations. A heavier vehicle generally performs differently in a crash than a lighter one.
Vehicle Class Consideration
Beyond weight, the class of the vehicle is equally important. You can only compare vehicles that belong to the same vehicle class. Vehicle classes categorize vehicles based on their design and intended use, such as sedans, SUVs, pickup trucks, and vans. These different classes have inherent structural differences and are designed to perform differently in accidents. Comparing safety scores across different vehicle classes is not valid because the tests and standards are designed with class-specific characteristics in mind.
Examples of Vehicle Comparison Scenarios
To clarify these rules, consider these examples when you compare 2 vehicles:
-
Incorrect Comparison (Weight & Class): It is inappropriate to compare the safety score of a 4,500-pound SUV to a 3,000-pound sedan. They are in different vehicle classes (SUV vs. sedan) and the weight difference exceeds 250 pounds.
-
Incorrect Comparison (Class): Comparing a 3,600-pound pickup truck to a 3,400-pound van is also invalid. While they meet the weight requirement (within 250 pounds), they belong to different vehicle classes (pickup vs. van).
-
Correct Comparison (Weight & Class): It is valid to compare a 3,400-pound passenger car to a 3,650-pound passenger car. They are in the same vehicle class (passenger car) and their weights are within the 250-pound range.
Conclusion: Compare Vehicles Responsibly
When you compare 2 vehicles based on safety scores, remember that meaningful comparisons are only possible between vehicles in the same class and with similar weights (within 250 pounds). Understanding these guidelines ensures that you use safety ratings effectively and make informed decisions when choosing your next vehicle, prioritizing your safety and the safety of your passengers.
