The rules of Scrabble can be a source of confusion and debate, especially when it comes to less common word forms like comparative adjectives. This article explores the use of comparative adjectives in Scrabble, specifically focusing on the rules adopted by the Dover Scrabble Club, a group that prioritizes “Scrabble as nature intended.” Understanding these rules can enhance your Scrabble strategy and avoid disputes during gameplay.
Decoding the Dover Scrabble Club Rules
The Dover Scrabble Club utilizes a unique set of rules known as Scrabble II, designed to emphasize the use of “real” words and strategic vocabulary rather than relying solely on Scrabble word lists. They prioritize the American Heritage Dictionary, Fourth Edition (AmH4) as their primary lexicon.
So, are comparative adjectives allowed? The answer hinges on their presence in the AmH4. The club rules explicitly state:
“-ER (comparative) – if adjective is not a main entry in AmH4.”
This indicates that comparative adjectives are permissible if the base adjective appears as a main entry in the AmH4. However, if the adjective itself isn’t listed, its comparative form, ending in “-er,” is also disallowed.
This rule aims to maintain a balance between expanding vocabulary and preventing the use of overly obscure or contrived words. It encourages players to utilize common, recognized forms of adjectives. The club further clarifies that the Official Scrabble Players Dictionary (OSPD) acts as a secondary resource in cases where the AmH4 is silent on specific inflected forms, including comparatives.
Navigating the Nuances of Word Acceptance
The Dover Scrabble Club rules delve into further detail regarding word acceptance, especially concerning plurals and other derived forms. While the AmH4 remains the primary authority, the OSPD is consulted for specific cases where the dictionary is not explicit. This nuanced approach seeks to ensure fairness and consistency while promoting the use of legitimate words.
The club also employs a “Check the OSPD” rule, allowing players to challenge the AmH4’s rejection of a word by consulting the OSPD. This adds another layer of complexity and strategy to the game, as players can potentially score points with words not explicitly listed in the primary dictionary.
Conclusion: Mastering Comparative Adjectives in Scrabble II
In conclusion, comparative adjectives are allowed in Scrabble according to the Dover Scrabble Club rules, provided the root adjective is a main entry in the American Heritage Dictionary, Fourth Edition. The use of the OSPD as a secondary resource adds an additional layer of strategy and allows for challenges to the primary dictionary. By understanding these specific rules, players can confidently utilize comparative adjectives and enhance their Scrabble gameplay, adhering to the club’s philosophy of focusing on “words” rather than just points.
