While the global economy has faced significant headwinds in recent years, particularly in the aftermath of the pandemic, the United States has shown remarkable resilience and growth, standing out when compared to other developed nations, especially in Europe. The US economy has demonstrated robust expansion, a thriving job market, and a notable decrease in inflation, leading to it outpacing many of its international counterparts.
In the final quarter of 2023, the US Gross Domestic Product (GDP) surged by an impressive 3.3%, significantly exceeding economists’ forecasts of 2%. This strong performance contributed to an overall growth rate of 2.5% for the entire year, positioning the US ahead of all other advanced economies and projecting a similar trajectory for 2024.
“The American economy is proving to be considerably more resilient than many others globally,” observes Ryan Sweet, Chief US Economist at Oxford Economics. “It appears the US economic engine is operating smoothly, while many other nations are experiencing sputtering growth.”
Experts attribute this economic divergence to several key factors that have uniquely positioned America’s economy for stronger performance compared to other countries.
1. The Impact of Substantial Economic Stimulus
The COVID-19 pandemic triggered widespread disruptions, forcing economies worldwide to confront unprecedented challenges. In response, the US government implemented a massive $2.2 trillion economic stimulus package in March 2020. This legislation was designed to provide immediate financial relief to American households, businesses, and individuals affected by lockdowns and job losses. Subsequently, two additional legislative measures were enacted to further support small businesses and maintain employment levels.
This unprecedented injection of federal funds into the US economy represented the largest fiscal stimulus in American history. Approximately $5 trillion was distributed across various sectors, ranging from enhanced unemployment benefits for individuals to financial aid for struggling state and local transportation systems.
Aaron Terrazas, chief economist at Glassdoor, suggests that policymakers learned valuable lessons from the 2008-2009 financial crisis. “A key takeaway from the previous recession was the importance of decisive and large-scale interventions to prevent prolonged economic downturns. Hesitation and limited action can extend economic pain. This understanding likely contributed to the more robust fiscal response this time around.”
This substantial stimulus is widely credited with bolstering consumer spending, a critical component of the US economy accounting for approximately 70% of its economic activity. This sustained consumer demand, despite inflationary pressures, has been a significant factor in maintaining economic momentum.
Ryan Sweet further notes that a portion of the stimulus funds contributed to increased household savings, creating a financial buffer that Americans could draw upon when needed. While other nations, including Japan, Germany, and Canada, also implemented significant stimulus measures, the scale of the US response was notably larger.
European countries, while possessing well-established social safety nets, were able to leverage existing programs without the need for equivalent increases in spending. However, this advantage in immediate program adaptability could not compensate for the sheer magnitude of the US stimulus, which provided a more significant economic boost.
2. The Adaptability of the US Labor Market
High inflation has undeniably impacted American households and influenced perceptions of the economy. However, a remarkably strong labor market has supported disposable income, which is the primary driver of consumer spending.
The US unemployment rate has consistently remained below 4% since February 2022, matching historic lows. Simultaneously, despite rising prices, real wages have also experienced growth, with lower-income households witnessing some of the most significant real wage increases. Furthermore, the US experienced a notable surge in productivity in 2023, reaching its fastest growth rate in years.
Julia Pollak, chief economist at ZipRecruiter, highlights the flexibility of US labor laws, which allowed businesses to rapidly adjust their workforces at the onset of the pandemic. While this resulted in short-term job losses, it enabled companies to adapt swiftly and invest in innovative technologies.
She illustrates this with the hotel industry, which implemented workforce reductions and has not returned to pre-pandemic staffing levels. “Hotels have fundamentally transformed their operations. They’ve adopted self-service check-in and mobile technology, reduced the frequency of room cleaning, and phased out room service, as customer preferences have shifted towards services like Uber Eats and takeout,” Pollak explains.
This transformation has resulted in leaner, more efficient hotel operations with reduced reliance on personnel. While initially painful for workers, this adaptability has contributed to the long-term health and resilience of the sector, ultimately benefiting the broader economy and workforce.
Another advantage for the US labor market is its capacity for replenishment, particularly through immigration. This influx of workers is especially crucial at a time when the retirement of the baby boomer generation is slowing population growth and potentially impacting labor force participation.
In contrast, European countries often prioritized maintaining employment through government support. For example, the UK’s furlough scheme covered 80% of employee wages for over 18 months, encouraging businesses to retain staff even during lockdowns. While the US experienced higher unemployment rates initially, expanded unemployment benefits provided direct financial support to affected workers, injecting cash directly into the economy.
3. Energy Independence as an Economic Buffer
The United States’ status as a net energy exporter is a significant factor contributing to its economic strength, especially when compared to countries more reliant on energy imports.
When Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 triggered a surge in global energy prices, Europe absorbed a much greater economic shock than the US. Germany, a major European manufacturing hub, heavily depended on Russian natural gas supplied via the Nord Stream pipeline. The energy crisis significantly impacted German productivity.
Elevated energy prices fueled inflation across Europe, creating what experts termed a “double-shock” – the pandemic followed by the Ukraine conflict. Ben Westmore, who monitors the US economy for the OECD, emphasizes the disproportionate impact of the Ukraine war on European energy prices compared to the US.
Gas prices in Europe experienced a dramatic increase of approximately 20% between early 2021 and 2022, while the US saw a comparatively modest rise of only 3-4%. Westmore also points out that European businesses demonstrated a greater tendency to pass on increased energy costs to consumers, further contributing to inflationary pressures.
“These factors have collectively contributed to a faster moderation of inflation in the US compared to many other nations, particularly in Europe,” he concludes.
More on the global economy
