Nothing Compares 2 U, a powerful ballad of loss and longing, is often associated with Sinéad O’Connor, but who originally recorded it? At COMPARE.EDU.VN, we delve into the song’s history and the artists behind it, offering clarity on its origins and impact. This comparison clarifies the song’s origins, explores its different iterations, and highlights the lasting impact of both versions.
1. Unveiling the Origins: Who First Recorded “Nothing Compares 2 U?”
“Nothing Compares 2 U” was first recorded by The Family, a funk/pop band associated with Prince. Prince wrote and composed the song, showcasing his prolific talent. The Family’s rendition was released in 1985 on their self-titled debut album.
2. The Family’s Version: A Deep Dive
2.1 Background of The Family
The Family was a short-lived project of Prince, featuring members of his musical circle. Led by Paul “St. Paul” Peterson, the band aimed to explore different musical styles. The band was a melting pot of musical talent and experimentation and it showcased the breadth of Prince’s creative vision.
2.2 Key Features of The Family’s Recording
The Family’s version is characterized by its 80s synth-pop sound, understated emotion, and soulful vocals by St. Paul Peterson. The arrangement is somewhat more subtle, allowing the listener to focus on the raw and emotive lyrics. It also allows the listener to appreciate Prince’s songwriting skills.
2.3 Initial Reception and Impact
Despite being a Prince composition, The Family’s version did not achieve mainstream success upon its release. The Family’s version remained relatively obscure until Sinéad O’Connor’s cover propelled the song to international fame. It wasn’t until later that listeners rediscovered this original rendition, offering a new perspective on the song’s origins.
3. Sinéad O’Connor’s Iconic Rendition
3.1 The Story Behind Sinéad’s Cover
Sinéad O’Connor discovered “Nothing Compares 2 U” and was deeply moved by its lyrics. She decided to record her own version, bringing her unique vocal style and emotional depth to the song. Her interpretation transformed the song into a global hit.
3.2 Distinguishing Features of O’Connor’s Version
O’Connor’s rendition is known for its raw emotion, powerful vocals, and stripped-down arrangement. The music video, featuring close-ups of O’Connor’s face, added to the song’s intensity and vulnerability. O’Connor’s interpretation connected with audiences worldwide.
3.3 Global Success and Cultural Impact
Sinéad O’Connor’s “Nothing Compares 2 U” became a massive hit in 1990, topping charts around the world. The song’s music video was equally impactful and received heavy rotation on MTV. O’Connor’s performance is often credited with introducing a new generation to the song.
4. Musical Comparison: The Family vs. Sinéad O’Connor
4.1 Vocal Performance
| Feature | The Family (St. Paul Peterson) | Sinéad O’Connor |
|---|---|---|
| Vocal Style | Soulful, controlled | Raw, emotive |
| Emotional Depth | Subdued | Intense, vulnerable |
| Tone | Smooth, polished | Piercing, heartfelt |
4.2 Arrangement and Instrumentation
| Feature | The Family | Sinéad O’Connor |
|---|---|---|
| Instrumentation | Synth-pop, layered | Stripped-down |
| Tempo | Moderate | Slow |
| Overall Sound | Polished | Raw |
4.3 Emotional Delivery
| Feature | The Family | Sinéad O’Connor |
|---|---|---|
| Emotional Tone | Reflective | Heartbreaking |
| Intensity | Measured | Unrestrained |
5. Prince’s Feelings about Sinéad’s Rendition
5.1 Prince’s Initial Reaction
Prince had a complex relationship with Sinéad O’Connor’s success with “Nothing Compares 2 U”. While he appreciated the song’s success, reports suggest he was also possessive of his work. He had mixed feelings and he was known to be protective of his songs and image.
5.2 Live Performances and Reclaiming the Song
Later in his career, Prince began performing “Nothing Compares 2 U” live. Some viewed this as Prince reclaiming the song, while others saw it as a tribute to O’Connor’s interpretation. Prince’s performances added another layer to the song’s legacy.
5.3 Prince’s 1984 Original Studio Version
In 2018, Prince’s estate released his original 1984 studio version of “Nothing Compares 2 U.” The release gave listeners a chance to hear Prince’s own take on the song, adding another dimension to its history.
6. The Song’s Deeper Meaning: Exploring Themes
6.1 Loss and Longing
“Nothing Compares 2 U” is fundamentally about loss and the deep sense of longing that follows. The lyrics convey the emptiness and pain experienced after a significant relationship ends. The song resonates with anyone who has experienced heartbreak.
6.2 Unconditional Love
The song also touches on the theme of unconditional love. The singer expresses a willingness to try again, highlighting the enduring nature of their feelings. The willingness to give it another try shows commitment.
6.3 Universal Appeal
The themes of loss and love are universal. That’s why the song transcends cultural boundaries and continues to resonate with listeners today. Regardless of the listener’s background, the song connects with their shared experiences.
7. Critical Reception and Awards
7.1 Initial Reviews
Both versions of “Nothing Compares 2 U” received critical acclaim. The Family’s version was praised for its smooth vocals and polished production. Sinéad O’Connor’s version was celebrated for its emotional depth and rawness.
7.2 Accolades and Recognition
Sinéad O’Connor’s version won numerous awards, including MTV Video Music Awards and Billboard Music Awards. The song was also nominated for several Grammy Awards. The accolades underscored the song’s widespread popularity and critical acclaim.
7.3 Enduring Legacy
“Nothing Compares 2 U” remains a timeless classic. Both versions of the song continue to be enjoyed by listeners of all ages. The song’s enduring legacy is a testament to its power and emotional resonance.
8. Sinéad O’Connor’s Career Beyond “Nothing Compares 2 U”
8.1 Early Career and Debut Album
Sinéad O’Connor’s career began in the late 1980s with the release of her debut album, “The Lion and the Cobra”. The album showcased her unique vocal style and songwriting abilities. It also established her as a force in the music industry.
8.2 Controversies and Activism
O’Connor was known for her outspoken views and controversial actions. She used her platform to speak out against social and political issues. This included her protest against the Catholic Church on Saturday Night Live.
8.3 Later Albums and Collaborations
Despite controversies, O’Connor continued to release albums and collaborate with other artists. Her later work explored a range of musical styles, from traditional Irish music to reggae. She maintained her artistic integrity throughout her career.
9. Prince’s Vast Catalog and Influence
9.1 Prince’s Prolific Songwriting
Prince was one of the most prolific songwriters of all time. He wrote and composed hundreds of songs, many of which became hits for himself and other artists. His vast catalog is a testament to his boundless creativity.
9.2 Impact on Music Industry
Prince had a profound impact on the music industry. He was known for his innovative approach to music production, performance, and business. He challenged conventions and paved the way for future generations of artists.
9.3 Legacy as a Musical Genius
Prince’s legacy as a musical genius is undeniable. His influence can be heard in the work of countless artists across genres. He remains an icon and an inspiration to musicians around the world.
10. Cultural Impact of Both Versions
10.1 Impact on Popular Music
“Nothing Compares 2 U” had a significant impact on popular music. The song helped to usher in a new era of emotionally raw and authentic performances. The song influenced many artists.
10.2 Use in Film and Television
Both versions of the song have been featured in numerous films and television shows. Its usage in media underscores the song’s continued relevance and emotional resonance. The song adds depth to storytelling.
10.3 Continued Relevance Today
“Nothing Compares 2 U” remains relevant today. It continues to be covered by artists. The song’s message of loss and longing continues to strike a chord with new audiences.
11. Remembering Sinéad O’Connor and Her Legacy
11.1 Tributes and Memorials
Following her death, tributes poured in from around the world. Fellow musicians, celebrities, and fans shared their memories and appreciation for her music. Memorials were held to celebrate her life and legacy.
11.2 Lasting Impact on Music and Culture
Sinéad O’Connor’s impact on music and culture is undeniable. She was a trailblazer who challenged conventions and inspired countless people. Her music continues to resonate with listeners today.
11.3 Continuing Influence
Her influence extends beyond music. She remains a symbol of strength, vulnerability, and authenticity. Her legacy will continue to inspire artists and activists for generations to come.
12. The Enduring Power of “Nothing Compares 2 U”
12.1 Why It Resonates
“Nothing Compares 2 U” resonates because of its honesty. It offers a raw depiction of loss and longing. The song’s emotional vulnerability allows listeners to connect with it on a personal level.
12.2 The Song as a Timeless Classic
The song has proven its timelessness. Its message transcends generations. Whether in the original version by The Family or Sinéad O’Connor’s iconic rendition.
12.3 Celebrating Music and Art
Ultimately, “Nothing Compares 2 U” is a testament to the power of music and art. It shows how a song can connect people, stir emotions, and leave a lasting legacy. The song reminds us of the impact art can have.
13. How to Choose Which Version to Listen To
13.1 Considering Your Mood
The best version of “Nothing Compares 2 U” to listen to often depends on your mood. If you’re seeking a more subdued, soulful rendition, The Family’s version is an excellent choice. If you prefer raw emotion, Sinéad O’Connor’s iconic interpretation is perfect.
13.2 Exploring Different Interpretations
Exploring both versions offers a richer understanding of the song. Each artist brings a unique perspective to the material. Listening to both versions deepens one’s appreciation.
13.3 Personal Preference
Ultimately, the choice comes down to personal preference. Some listeners prefer the original’s subtlety. Others are drawn to O’Connor’s intensity. Both versions have their unique strengths.
14. Other Notable Covers of “Nothing Compares 2 U”
14.1 Diverse Interpretations
Numerous artists have covered “Nothing Compares 2 U”. Each cover offers a unique take on the song. These covers demonstrate the song’s versatility.
14.2 Artists Who Have Covered the Song
Notable artists include Aretha Franklin and Chris Cornell. Each artist brings their signature style to the song. The diverse range of covers shows the song’s universal appeal.
14.3 Impact of Cover Versions
Cover versions keep the song alive. They introduce it to new audiences. Each interpretation adds a new dimension to the song’s legacy.
15. Prince’s Original Intentions for the Song
15.1 The Story Behind the Lyrics
Prince wrote “Nothing Compares 2 U” after the departure of his housekeeper, Sandy Scipioni, who looked after him during his early years. The song was born of a feeling of loneliness and abandonment. The origins of the song reflect personal loss.
15.2 How Prince Envisioned the Song
Prince originally envisioned the song as a simple expression of heartache. He likely never imagined it would become an international hit. His intentions were pure and heartfelt.
15.3 The Evolution of the Song Over Time
Over time, “Nothing Compares 2 U” has evolved in meaning. It has come to represent loss, longing, and resilience. The song’s evolution reflects its cultural impact.
16. Analyzing the Music Video of O’Connor’s Version
16.1 Visual Symbolism
The music video for Sinéad O’Connor’s version is iconic. Its visual symbolism enhances the song’s emotional impact. Close-ups of O’Connor’s face capture her vulnerability.
16.2 Impact on Viewers
The video resonated with viewers worldwide. Its simplicity and emotional honesty were groundbreaking. The video remains powerful.
16.3 Lasting Imagery
The lasting imagery of the video solidifies the song’s legacy. O’Connor’s shaved head and tearful expression are unforgettable. The video is a masterpiece.
17. The Role of Music in Expressing Grief
17.1 How Music Helps
Music plays a crucial role in expressing grief. It provides an outlet for emotions. It allows people to connect with others who have similar experiences.
17.2 “Nothing Compares 2 U” as an Anthem of Grief
“Nothing Compares 2 U” serves as an anthem of grief. Its lyrics capture the pain of loss. It offers solace.
17.3 Other Songs About Grief
Many songs explore the theme of grief. Each song offers a unique perspective. Music is a universal language for expressing sorrow.
18. Exploring Other Prince Songs Covered by Female Artists
18.1 “Manic Monday” by The Bangles
“Manic Monday” is another Prince song made famous by a female artist. The Bangles turned it into a hit. The song is a pop classic.
18.2 “I Feel For You” by Chaka Khan
Chaka Khan’s version of “I Feel For You” is iconic. Prince wrote and composed it. Khan’s rendition is a funk masterpiece.
18.3 Prince’s Talent for Writing for Women
Prince had a talent for writing songs that resonated with women. He understood female emotions. His songs were often empowering.
19. The Technical Aspects of the Song
19.1 Song Structure
“Nothing Compares 2 U” features a simple song structure. It is built around a verse-chorus format. Its simplicity enhances its emotional impact.
19.2 Key and Tempo
The song is typically performed in a minor key. It helps to convey sadness. The tempo is slow.
19.3 Instrumentation Details
The Family’s version features synth-pop instrumentation. O’Connor’s version is more stripped down. Each version is uniquely arranged.
20. Examining the Lyrics: A Verse-by-Verse Analysis
20.1 First Verse
The first verse sets the tone. It introduces the theme of loss. It establishes the singer’s sadness.
20.2 Second Verse
The second verse delves deeper into the singer’s emotions. It conveys a sense of emptiness. The lyrics are poignant.
20.3 Chorus
The chorus is the heart of the song. It emphasizes the depth of the singer’s longing. The phrase “Nothing Compares 2 U” is iconic.
21. The Impact of “Nothing Compares 2 U” on LGBTQ+ Community
21.1 Connection to the Song
“Nothing Compares 2 U” resonates with the LGBTQ+ community. The themes of love and loss. It is universal.
21.2 Interpretations of the Lyrics
The lyrics can be interpreted in different ways. The LGBTQ+ community finds meaning. Love transcends boundaries.
21.3 Cultural Significance
The song holds cultural significance. It promotes acceptance. It celebrates love.
22. Personal Anecdotes and Stories Related to the Song
22.1 Listener Experiences
Many listeners have personal stories connected to the song. They share their experiences. It serves as a source of comfort.
22.2 Cultural Impact
The song’s cultural impact. Its power to heal. Music is a universal experience.
22.3 The Song as a Source of Comfort
The song provides solace. It connects people. It reminds people of a common bond.
23. The Future of “Nothing Compares 2 U”
23.1 Continued Popularity
“Nothing Compares 2 U” will remain popular. The song’s message. Music lives on.
23.2 New Interpretations
New artists will interpret the song. It will continue to evolve. Music is a living art form.
23.3 Legacy for Future Generations
Its legacy will endure. It will inspire artists. It is a gift.
24. FAQ About “Nothing Compares 2 U”
24.1 Who originally wrote “Nothing Compares 2 U?”
Prince wrote and composed “Nothing Compares 2 U.”
24.2 Who first recorded “Nothing Compares 2 U?”
The Family first recorded “Nothing Compares 2 U” in 1985.
24.3 When did Sinéad O’Connor release her version?
Sinéad O’Connor released her version in 1990.
24.4 Was Prince happy with Sinéad O’Connor’s version?
Prince had mixed feelings about O’Connor’s version.
24.5 Why is Sinéad O’Connor’s version so popular?
Her version resonated emotionally with audiences.
24.6 Did Prince ever perform the song himself?
Yes, Prince performed the song later in his career.
24.7 What is the song about?
The song is about loss and longing.
24.8 How has the song impacted popular culture?
It ushered in an era of emotional performances.
24.9 What makes each version unique?
The Family’s is soulful, and O’Connor’s is raw.
24.10 Where can I find both versions of the song?
Both versions are available on music platforms.
25. Conclusion: The Dual Legacy of a Timeless Song
“Nothing Compares 2 U” holds a unique place in music history. While The Family first recorded Prince’s composition, Sinéad O’Connor’s interpretation transformed the song into a global phenomenon. The song’s power lies in its ability to connect with listeners on a profound emotional level, regardless of who performs it. Both versions continue to be celebrated for their unique qualities, contributing to the song’s enduring legacy. If you’re struggling to compare different versions of songs, albums, or artists, visit COMPARE.EDU.VN for more comprehensive comparisons. Let us help you make informed decisions.
Interested in more music comparisons? Visit compare.edu.vn at 333 Comparison Plaza, Choice City, CA 90210, United States or contact us via Whatsapp at +1 (626) 555-9090.
