For Mustang enthusiasts and potential buyers, the shift from the 2004 to the 2005 model year represents a significant turning point. Often considered a generational leap rather than a simple model year change, the 2005 Ford Mustang marked the beginning of the S197 platform, bringing with it a host of updates and improvements over the outgoing 2004 model, which was part of the “New Edge” SN-95 generation. If you’re in the market for a used Mustang and are trying to decide between a 2004 and a 2005, understanding the key differences is crucial. This comparison dives deep into what sets these two model years apart, helping you make an informed decision.
Comfort and Interior Space: A Step Up in the 2005
One of the most immediately noticeable upgrades in the 2005 Mustang is the interior. Ford prioritized driver and passenger comfort, resulting in a cabin that feels significantly more spacious and refined compared to the 2004 model. The 2005 Mustang boasts more comfortable and supportive seats, designed for longer drives. Ergonomics were also improved, with controls and gauges laid out in a more user-friendly manner. Overall, the interior of the 2005 Mustang provides a more pleasant and less cramped environment, making it a better choice for those who value comfort, especially on longer journeys.
Handling and Performance: The 2005 Mustang’s Edge
When it comes to handling, the 2005 Mustang demonstrates clear advancements over its 2004 predecessor, at least in stock configurations. While the 2004 Mustang, particularly in GT trim, offered respectable performance for its time, the 2005 model, built on the new S197 chassis, exhibits reduced body roll and a more planted feel on the road. This translates to more confident cornering and an overall more engaging driving experience. Although detailed track comparisons require professional testing, anecdotal evidence and general reviews suggest that the 2005 Mustang offers superior handling capabilities in typical driving scenarios compared to the 2004 model.
The Fun Factor: An Enhanced Driving Experience in the 2005
The “fun to drive” aspect is subjective but heavily influenced by factors like comfort, power delivery, and handling. In a direct comparison between a stock 2004 and 2005 Mustang, the latter generally comes out on top in terms of driving enjoyment. The 2005 Mustang combines improved comfort, potentially enhanced power (depending on specific trims and engine options – although base engines were similar), and demonstrably better handling. This combination creates a more well-rounded and enjoyable driving experience for a wider range of drivers. The newer platform of the 2005 model simply feels more modern and responsive behind the wheel.
Advantages and Disadvantages: Weighing the Pros and Cons
Both the 2004 and 2005 Mustangs have their own sets of advantages and potential drawbacks. The 2004 model, being the last of its generation, might benefit from some refinements accumulated over its production run. However, the 2005 Mustang, while representing a fresh start, also had its share of early model year quirks. Common issues reported for the early S197 Mustangs (including 2005 models) include potential battery drain problems (often fixable), water leaks into the cabin (also generally easy to address), and paint issues, particularly on the hood. The primary advantage of the 2005 Mustang lies in its modernity – it looks and feels significantly newer, and generally offers performance and comfort benefits as previously mentioned.
Styling and Looks: A Matter of Personal Preference, But a Generational Shift
Styling is highly subjective, but the design language shift between the 2004 and 2005 Mustangs is undeniable and significant. The 2004 Mustang carries the “New Edge” design philosophy, characterized by sharp lines and angular shapes, which was popular in the late 90s and early 2000s. The 2005 Mustang, conversely, embraced a retro-futuristic design, drawing heavy inspiration from the iconic Mustangs of the 1960s. For many, the 2005+ Mustang’s styling is a major draw, considered a successful modern interpretation of classic muscle car aesthetics and a significant improvement over the design trends prevalent up to 2004. However, some enthusiasts still appreciate the “New Edge” styling of the 2004 and earlier models, making it ultimately a matter of personal taste.
Size and Cabin Feel: More Room to Breathe in the 2005
The 2005 Mustang is physically larger than the 2004 model, and this translates to a more spacious feel inside the cabin. Occupants in the 2005 Mustang, particularly in the front seats, will notice a greater sense of personal space. The increased width and overall dimensions contribute to a less cramped and more comfortable environment, especially for larger individuals or those who prefer a roomier feel in their car.
Visibility: Similar Challenges in Both Models
Mustangs, in general, are known for having a high door line and a somewhat enclosed feeling from the driver’s seat. This characteristic is present in both the 2004 and 2005 models. While convertible versions naturally mitigate some visibility concerns, for coupe models, neither the 2004 nor the 2005 Mustang offers a clear advantage in terms of outward visibility. Drivers of both models will need to be mindful of blind spots and rely on mirrors and careful observation, especially in tighter driving situations.
Conclusion: The 2005 Mustang Emerges as the Stronger Overall Choice
Choosing between a 2004 and 2005 Mustang depends on individual priorities. However, for most buyers seeking a blend of modern comfort, improved handling, and updated styling, the 2005 Mustang represents a more compelling choice. While the 2004 Mustang might hold nostalgic appeal for some, the 2005 model’s advancements in key areas make it a more refined and enjoyable vehicle overall. Unless a specific preference for the “New Edge” styling or potentially a significantly lower price point for a 2004 model is a deciding factor, opting for a 2005 or newer Mustang is generally the recommended path for a better ownership experience.
