Are you tired of grocery bills eating up your budget? Every trip to the supermarket seems more expensive than the last, leaving you wondering where you can find the best deals. If you’re on a quest to save money on groceries, you’re likely asking the same questions many frugal shoppers do: “Which grocery store is the cheapest near me?” and “How can I compare grocery prices effectively?”
Like you, I’m always on the lookout for ways to stretch my budget further, especially when it comes to feeding my family. This desire to be a smart shopper led me to embark on a comprehensive grocery price comparison. I wanted to delve deep into the numbers and uncover which stores truly offer the most savings. The results were eye-opening, and I’m excited to share my findings with you.
You’re probably wondering just how much prices vary between different grocery chains. Common questions abound, such as:
- Is Aldi really cheaper than Walmart?
- When it comes to Meijer and Kroger, who wins on price?
- Is Kroger more expensive than Walmart for everyday items?
- And the big one: Is Aldi consistently the cheapest option compared to all others?
These are the very questions I aimed to answer with this in-depth price comparison. Living in northern Indiana, I focused my research on four major grocery chains prevalent in my region: Meijer, Kroger, Aldi, and Walmart. Each store has its own appeal. Meijer often boasts attractive meat sales. Aldi is known for its streamlined, budget-friendly shopping experience. Kroger frequently entices shoppers with compelling sales and loyalty programs, and Walmart, while perhaps not everyone’s favorite for ambiance, is undeniably a giant in retail with a reputation for low prices across the board.
This project became my most extensive grocery shopping investigation to date, and the discoveries I made about finding the cheapest grocery store truly surprised me. I’m eager to walk you through the details so you too can become a more informed and money-saving grocery shopper!
So, settle in and get ready for a detailed breakdown of grocery prices, statistics, and insights. Are you ready to discover how to compare grocery prices and find the cheapest grocery store in 2024? Let’s dive in!
Note: This is my fifth price comparison update in six years. I initially conducted this research in 2019 and have updated it regularly in 2021, 2022, and 2023. (I skipped 2020 due to the unique challenges of that year in obtaining consistent pricing data.) With rapid inflation impacting grocery costs, I undertook this latest update in April 2024 to provide you with the most current information to help manage your grocery spending.
Methodology: How We Compared Grocery Store Prices
To conduct a meaningful grocery shopping price comparison, I focused on stores with a significant presence across the United States. Walmart, a national retail behemoth, is widely recognized for its commitment to low prices. Aldi positions itself as a direct competitor, often claiming to undercut Walmart. Meijer and Kroger, while sometimes perceived as slightly more upscale, are major regional players known for their extensive reach and frequent sales events. I chose these four stores – Walmart, Aldi, Meijer, and Kroger – to ensure a robust and relevant comparison for the average American grocery shopper.
Large warehouse clubs like Sam’s Club and Costco, and specialty stores such as Trader Joe’s, Whole Foods Market, and WinCo Foods, were excluded from this comparison. Warehouse clubs present challenges due to bulk sizes that aren’t directly comparable to regular grocery store units, and specialty stores often have product selections that differ significantly from mainstream supermarkets. My goal was to create a head-to-head comparison of everyday grocery items available at widely accessible stores.
My first step was to compile a comprehensive list of common grocery items that most households regularly purchase. This formed the foundation of my price comparison. To ensure the list was thorough and relevant, I expanded it to include items specifically used by my family and even sought input from the Joyfully Thriving Facebook community. This valuable feedback enriched the list and made it even more representative of typical grocery needs.
To organize the comparison, I categorized the grocery items into 10 distinct shopping categories, covering a broad spectrum of supermarket departments:
- Dairy
- Pantry Staples
- Canned Goods
- Condiments (like peanut butter and ketchup)
- Baking Supplies
- Meat (fresh and frozen)
- Frozen Foods
- Paper Products & Household Items (like toilet paper)
- Personal Care Products
- Diapers
This meticulous process resulted in a list of 183 individual grocery items across these 10 categories, all of which were priced at each of the four stores.
The price collection process involved creating a detailed spreadsheet. I visited each of the four stores and meticulously recorded the prices for every item on my list. In addition to in-store price checks, I also utilized store mobile apps to verify and supplement pricing information, ensuring accuracy and capturing any digital deals or variations.
For product selection, I aimed for generic or store-brand equivalents whenever possible to ensure a fair “apples-to-apples” comparison of base prices. While some name-brand items were included for consistency across stores, the focus was on the most affordable, readily available options at each location. Fresh produce was intentionally excluded from this price comparison due to significant seasonal and regional price fluctuations that would skew the results.
To maintain accuracy and comparability, prices were standardized to a per-ounce basis. When product sizes differed from my standard list, I calculated the unit price to identify the lowest cost per ounce. Efforts were made to compare similar sizes across stores whenever feasible.
Crucially, this price comparison is based on regular, everyday prices and does not incorporate temporary sales or promotional discounts. The objective was to determine which store consistently offers the lowest base prices for groceries, regardless of short-term deals.
It’s important to remember that grocery prices can vary geographically. The prices used in this comparison were collected in Northern Indiana in April 2024. However, the relative price rankings and overall trends observed should still provide valuable insights for grocery shoppers across different regions seeking to compare prices and save money.
Grocery Price Comparison Results: Unveiling the Cheapest Store
After numerous shopping trips and detailed research using store apps, the comprehensive price list was complete. With all the data compiled, the next step was to analyze the results and determine which store emerged as the cheapest overall.
To begin, I systematically identified and highlighted the absolute lowest price for each of the 183 items. If multiple stores offered the same lowest price, all were highlighted. This initial step revealed a clear picture of which stores were most frequently leading on price.
During the comparison, it became apparent that price differences were often minimal, with several stores being within pennies of each other on many items. Recognizing that shoppers often consolidate their trips, I decided to also highlight prices that were “second lowest,” defined as being within 5 cents of the absolute lowest price. This provided a more nuanced view, acknowledging stores that were highly competitive even if they weren’t always the absolute cheapest.
Instances of exact price matches across stores were counted for all stores involved. Similarly, if multiple stores had prices within the 5-cent “second lowest” range, they all received credit. This method of tallying may lead to totals that don’t perfectly align at first glance, but it accurately reflects the frequency with which each store offered the most competitive prices.
Finally, I tallied the highlighted lowest and second-lowest prices for each store, presenting the results both as raw numbers and as percentages of the total 183 items. Here’s a summary of the 2024 grocery price comparison results:
| 2024 Results | Aldi | Meijer | Kroger | Walmart |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lowest Price Count | 126 | 12 | 9 | 44 |
| Second Lowest Price Count | 5 | 7 | 5 | 40 |
| Total Lowest Price Count | 131 | 19 | 14 | 84 |
| Percentage of Lowest Prices | 69% | 7% | 5% | 24% |
| Percentage of Second Lowest Prices | 3% | 4% | 3% | 22% |
| Total Percentage of Lowest Prices | 72% | 11% | 8% | 46% |
The data clearly indicates that Aldi offers the lowest prices on the vast majority of items in this comparison, while Kroger has the fewest lowest-price items. While there are instances where all four stores are closely priced (within a nickel), these are relatively infrequent.
Aldi stood out by having the lowest price on nearly 70% of the 183 items on the list. This significant margin is compelling and suggests that Aldi should be a primary consideration for budget-conscious shoppers.
Interestingly, while Aldi excelled at having the absolute lowest price, it had the second-lowest price on very few items (only 5). This suggests that if Aldi isn’t the cheapest, it’s typically not a close second. Furthermore, Aldi’s limited product selection meant that some items on the comparison list were not available at Aldi at all.
Walmart emerges as a strong competitor to Aldi. In many cases where Aldi offered the lowest price, Walmart was often just pennies away. Walmart’s key advantage is its one-stop-shop convenience, offering a much wider range of products beyond groceries, which Aldi does not. For shoppers who value efficiency and prefer to handle all their shopping in one location, the slightly higher prices at Walmart might be an acceptable trade-off for the added convenience.
Kroger, in this comparison of everyday prices, appears to be the most expensive of the four stores. However, it’s crucial to remember that Kroger is renowned for its frequent and substantial sales, which are not reflected in this everyday price analysis. Kroger’s sales and digital coupons can often make its prices highly competitive, even beating Aldi’s everyday low prices on certain items. Additionally, Kroger’s fuel rewards program and extensive digital coupon offerings provide further avenues for savings that are not available at Aldi or Walmart.
Identifying Your Cheapest Grocery Store: Beyond the Averages
Based purely on everyday low prices, Aldi takes the lead as the cheapest grocery store in 2024. Walmart secures the second position, with Meijer and Kroger lagging behind in terms of consistently low base prices.
While these overall rankings are informative, it’s essential to delve deeper to find the absolute cheapest grocery store for you, considering your location and shopping habits.
Walmart is likely the most widely accessible and consistently affordable grocery store nationwide. Its broad geographic footprint and commitment to low prices make it a strong contender for “cheapest” in many areas. However, it’s important to reiterate that Walmart’s strength lies in everyday low prices, not in sales or deep discounts.
The most effective way to pinpoint the cheapest grocery store near you is to conduct your own mini price comparison at local supermarkets. Here’s a guide to doing this efficiently in under an hour.
Start by creating a focused list of 20-25 grocery items that you purchase regularly – the staples that consistently make their way into your shopping cart. Beginning with a smaller, manageable list prevents feeling overwhelmed (unlike my extensive 183-item project!). Focus on the two dozen or so items you buy most frequently each week.
Next, list the grocery stores that are conveniently located near you. Include both your regular shopping destinations and stores you might not have visited recently. You might be surprised by what you discover by expanding your comparison beyond your usual haunts!
Then, take your list and price out those 20-25 items at each of your local grocery stores and major chains. Quick tip: Many grocery chains now feature websites or mobile apps that allow you to browse prices from home, streamlining the comparison process significantly. Aldi, however, typically requires an in-store visit to get the most accurate pricing, as online prices through Instacart may be slightly inflated compared to in-store costs.
Once you’ve gathered your local price data, comparing the totals will reveal which store consistently offers the lowest prices for your specific shopping basket. I encourage you to share your findings in the comments below – what is your cheapest grocery store?
Here’s a printable price book template you can use to organize your personal price comparisons.
Grocery Price Inflation: A Look at Price Trends Over Time
This 2024 study marks my fifth annual grocery price comparison over the past six years (2019, 2021, 2022, 2023, and 2024). Analyzing the results across these years reveals interesting trends in grocery pricing.
While prices have undeniably risen overall, Aldi has consistently maintained its position as the cheapest store throughout this period, including in the 2023 comparison. However, the gap between Aldi and Walmart has narrowed. Walmart’s lowest prices have generally decreased slightly over time, while Aldi’s have shown a gradual increase.
Here’s a look back at the 2023 price comparison results:
| 2023 Results | Aldi | Meijer | Kroger | Walmart |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lowest Price Count | 124 | 12 | 10 | 48 |
| Second Lowest Price Count | 3 | 14 | 9 | 44 |
| Total Lowest Price Count | 127 | 26 | 19 | 92 |
| Percentage of Lowest Prices | 68% | 7% | 5% | 26% |
| Percentage of Second Lowest Prices | 1% | 8% | 5% | 24% |
| Total Percentage of Lowest Prices | 69% | 14% | 10% | 50% |
And the 2022 price comparison results:
| 2022 Results | Aldi | Meijer | Kroger | Walmart |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lowest Price Count | 115 | 22 | 17 | 68 |
| Second Lowest Price Count | 14 | 14 | 6 | 37 |
| Total Lowest Price Count | 121 | 36 | 23 | 105 |
| Percentage of Lowest Prices | 63% | 12% | 9% | 37% |
| Percentage of Second Lowest Prices | 3% | 8% | 3% | 20% |
| Total Percentage of Lowest Prices | 66% | 20% | 12% | 57% |
The 2021 price comparison data:
| 2021 Results | Aldi | Meijer | Kroger | Walmart |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lowest Price Count | 114 | 15 | 16 | 52 |
| Second Lowest Price Count | 4 | 12 | 4 | 45 |
| Total Lowest Price Count | 118 | 27 | 20 | 97 |
| Percentage of Lowest Prices | 62% | 8% | 9% | 28% |
| Percentage of Second Lowest Prices | 2% | 7% | 2% | 25% |
| Total Percentage of Lowest Prices | 64% | 15% | 11% | 53% |
And, going back to the original 2019 price comparison, we see a significant shift: Walmart was the cheapest store at that time:
| 2019 Results | Aldi | Meijer | Kroger | Walmart |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lowest Price Count | 56 | 15 | 26 | 97 |
| Second Lowest Price Count | 3 | 11 | 16 | 32 |
| Total Lowest Price Count | 59 | 26 | 42 | 129 |
| Percentage of Lowest Prices | 31% | 8% | 15% | 54% |
| Percentage of Second Lowest Prices | 2% | 6% | 9% | 18% |
| Total Percentage of Lowest Prices | 33% | 15% | 24% | 72% |
These historical comparisons underscore a crucial point: grocery prices are dynamic and change over time. Consistent price monitoring is essential for smart shopping.
The shift is evident: In 2019, Aldi had the lowest prices on 33% of items, which has surged to 72% in 2024. Conversely, Walmart’s lowest price dominance has decreased from 72% to 46% over the same period. These are substantial shifts in the grocery price landscape.
Remember, these comparisons focus solely on everyday prices and do not account for sales. Strategically leveraging sales at different grocery stores remains a powerful way to maximize savings. Some stores, even those with higher everyday prices, offer deep discounts that can lead to significant savings when you stock up on sale items.
My personal approach involves checking weekly ads and capitalizing on Kroger’s sales, as their promotional prices often beat even Aldi and Walmart’s everyday lows. I then supplement with less frequent trips to Aldi to stock up on their consistently low-priced staples. This blended strategy, while currently effective for me, requires ongoing reevaluation to adapt to the ever-changing grocery price environment and ensure I remain a savvy shopper.
Actionable Strategies: How to Use Price Comparison to Save Money
Understanding which stores are generally cheaper is valuable information that can and should influence your grocery shopping habits.
Based on this price comparison, I now have a clearer understanding of items that are most cost-effective to purchase at Aldi and those that are better sourced elsewhere. I’ve also used this data to create a “stock-up price” list for various grocery staples. This list empowers me to recognize exceptional sales at any store and purchase items when prices dip below these everyday low benchmarks.
If you prefer to primarily shop at a single store, Aldi is definitively the most budget-friendly choice based on everyday prices. However, for maximum savings, consider adopting a multi-store strategy.
Knowing the lowest everyday prices for your pantry staples allows you to confidently stock up when you find sales that beat those prices. The most effective approach to grocery budgeting is to combine consistently low-priced everyday items with strategic purchases of sale items. This “best of both worlds” approach allows you to maximize your grocery budget.
My personal plan moving forward involves more frequent shopping trips to Aldi to leverage their everyday low prices, supplemented by strategically shopping Kroger sales. I will also continue to watch for meat sales at Meijer, particularly on ground beef. Walmart remains a convenient option for quick pick-ups when I need a low price and one-stop shopping. Ultimately, I aim to shop where I can secure the best value for every dollar spent. Fortunately, having multiple store options nearby allows me to take advantage of diverse deals and pricing strategies.
Utilizing store mobile apps to check prices regularly is also becoming an increasingly essential tool for smart shopping. I’ve already found myself using store apps in-aisle at Kroger to compare prices with Walmart in real-time and make immediate purchasing decisions based on price differences. The savings can be significant!
Dive Deeper: Access Detailed Grocery Price Data
Want to examine the raw data and perform your own price comparisons?
The information presented in this article is just a summary of a much more extensive dataset. To provide you with a comprehensive resource, I’ve compiled all of my research into a detailed 42-page printable PDF ebook, packed with in-depth price lists and analyses.
This ebook includes the following detailed lists:
- Master Price Comparison Chart (prices for all 183 items at all 4 stores)
- Lowest and Second Lowest Price Item Lists
- Stock-Up Price Lists (organized by category)
- Stock-Up Price Lists (alphabetical listing – my personal favorite!)
- Best Stores to Buy Specific Items (organized by category)
- Best Stores to Buy Specific Items (alphabetical listing)
- Aldi Shopping List (highlighting best buys at Aldi)
- Meijer Shopping List (highlighting best buys at Meijer)
- Kroger Shopping List (highlighting best buys at Kroger)
- Walmart Shopping List (highlighting best buys at Walmart)
I sincerely hope this grocery price comparison empowers you to save money on your next shopping trip! Will these findings change where you shop? What have you found to be the cheapest grocery store in your local area?
Continue Your Savings Journey:
Welcome! Explore how we thrive on a reduced income, discover customizable, faith-based books (with free printables), or learn to build an effective family stockpile. Subscribe to my email newsletter for blog updates here. Thank you for visiting!
