Choosing the right evangelism course is crucial for effectively introducing individuals to Christianity. For evangelists comparing different resources, several programs offer distinct approaches and varying levels of theological depth. This article provides a detailed comparison of popular Christianity introduction courses, analyzing their strengths and weaknesses to aid in selecting the most suitable option for different contexts and audiences.
Simply Christianity
Simply Christianity serves as a basic introduction for those completely new to Christian concepts. Its strength lies in its accessibility, intentionally avoiding jargon to resonate with beginners. However, this simplification can be a double-edged sword. While approachable, the course sometimes shies away from core biblical terminology like “faith,” potentially diluting essential theological concepts. A notable positive aspect is its session dedicated to the reliability of the Bible, offering valuable supplementary information also found in the Alpha course. For evangelists seeking an extremely basic starting point, Simply Christianity can be useful, but requires careful supplementation to ensure theological completeness.
Alpha
Alpha is a more extensive program, likely better suited for discipleship after initial conversion rather than purely introductory evangelism. Despite its length (fifteen sessions), a call for decision is made as early as the third session, even before foundational concepts like faith and repentance are thoroughly discussed (introduced in the fourth session). This rushed approach raises concerns about potentially leading individuals into Christianity without full comprehension of its core tenets. Repentance and faith receive brief attention under the heading “How can I be sure of my Faith,” which seems an unusual placement for such critical doctrines. Repentance is allocated a single sentence, while faith receives approximately one page. By session six, Alpha presumes participants are already Christians, shifting focus to being filled with the Holy Spirit and speaking in tongues during a weekend retreat. While the theological stance in these later sessions is debatable, the assumption of conversion within six weeks of an introductory course appears premature. Evangelists considering Alpha should be aware of its fast pace and potential for theological shallowness in initial sessions.
Coming Alive
Coming Alive appears to be the least effective among the reviewed courses. Its ten-session length positions it awkwardly between a brief evangelistic introduction and a more in-depth discipleship program. The conceptual framework is described as “utterly confusing.” While substitutionary atonement is mentioned, it is presented as just one facet of the cross alongside moral example and other interpretations, potentially diluting its central importance. The course is likely to confuse individuals unfamiliar with basic Christian theology. The very first session delves into biblical theology, an unsuitable starting point for newcomers. Furthermore, a significant portion (70%) of Coming Alive assumes pre-existing salvation, rendering the latter part of the course irrelevant if conversion has not occurred within the first three weeks. For evangelists seeking clear and effective introductory material, Coming Alive is not recommended due to its confusing structure and theological assumptions.
Discovering Christianity
Initial impressions of Discovering Christianity were positive, particularly its early sessions focusing on Christ’s claims to divinity and His resurrection. The intent to establish Christ’s authority is commendable. However, the course falters when addressing the core of the gospel message. A reluctance to use terms like “sin” and “repentance” is evident. While understandable to aim for accessible language, replacing “sin” with phrases like “have not lived moral lives” or “are not good people compared with Jesus” inadequately conveys the profound concept of sin. Using and explaining the traditional term “sin” would be more effective and consistent with Christian tradition. The course seems to avoid Reformed theology and even omits potentially challenging verses from John’s Gospel. The discussion of atonement is described as convoluted, dwelling excessively on peripheral aspects like the love demonstrated in Jesus’ death (because it saves us) while insufficiently explaining how salvation is achieved. Evangelists seeking a theologically robust and clear gospel presentation may find Discovering Christianity lacking in its core message.
Christianity Explained
Christianity Explained emerges as the strongest course among those reviewed. Its six-session structure is well-paced, with each session carefully elucidating a specific aspect of the gospel. It avoids rushing decisions while progressively enhancing the student’s gospel understanding. Key gospel doctrines are discussed comprehensively. This course excels at conveying salvation by grace, not works, dedicating an entire session to this crucial concept, which is described as “masterfully done.” This session is often pivotal for students to grasp the essence of the gospel. The only noted weakness is the somewhat insufficient treatment of sin. While acknowledged, sin is primarily presented as a backdrop to the cross. Users of Christianity Explained may need to supplement it with a more thorough explanation of sin as the fundamental reason for Christ’s sacrifice. Integrating a session on sin, perhaps from Christianity Explored, before the crucifixion session is recommended. For evangelists seeking a balanced, clear, and theologically sound introductory course, Christianity Explained is highly recommended with a minor suggested enhancement.
Christianity Explored
Christianity Explored is presented as a well-structured program, explicitly designed as a response to the Alpha course. This seven-week course, accompanied by a DVD, utilizes the Gospel of Mark as its framework and is designed for small group settings, often incorporating a meal. Teaching can be delivered live or via DVD, followed by group discussion. Christianity Explored is lauded for its faithfulness to Scripture, clear gospel presentation, and explicit call to repentance and faith for non-Christians. It is highlighted as an “excellent resource” for evangelism. Furthermore, Christianity Explained, like Christianity Explained, is noted for its adaptability to one-on-one settings, facilitating gospel conversations in informal environments like coffee shops, eliminating the need for retreats or formal presentations. For evangelists seeking a scripturally sound, adaptable, and effective program, Christianity Explored stands out as a top choice.
